- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes VPRP, a two-stage framework for nighttime lens flare removal. A pretrained coarse network estimates a flare-free image and a flare component. A Prompt Restoration Network then refines the result using a mask-derived input and multiscale decoder features from the frozen coarse network. A prompt calibration block uses these features to modulate the refinement features. Experiments report improvements across several U-shaped backbones on Flare7K++, with additional evaluations on BracketFlare, FlareX, and FlareReal600. On Flare7K++, VPRP improves UNet from 27.189 to 28.109 dB and FF-Former from 27.900 to 28.443 dB.
Critical strengths
The motivation is clear and addresses a practical limitation of existing flare removal methods: residual artifacts after coarse restoration. The framework is complete, combining mask-guided refinement with feature guidance from the coarse network. The authors evaluate several backbones, including UNet, Uformer, HINet, Restormer, and FF-Former, and provide additional results on BracketFlare, FlareX, and FlareReal600 in the appendix. This makes the empirical evidence broader than a single-backbone improvement. Freezing the coarse network also makes the method potentially useful for improving existing pretrained models without retraining the entire pipeline.
Critical weaknesses
The main concern I have is about the threshold selection procedure. Appendix A.0.2 states that the authors evaluate mask IoU against ground-truth masks on the test set and then choose a threshold around 0.1 based on the observed optimum. This seems to imply that test-set annotations are used to select a method hyperparameter. The paper should clarify whether the threshold was independently fixed before this analysis or actually selected using these results. If the latter is the case, the affected evaluations should be repeated with a validation-selected threshold. Another issue is that the source of the performance gain is not fully clear. Table 2 shows that adding PCB improves the refinement network, but it does not compare PCB with ordinary feature concatenation or standard affine modulation using the same coarse-stage features. It also omits the configuration with the mask block but without PCB. Therefore, the results support the usefulness of transferring coarse features, but do not fully establish whether the proposed visual prompting mechanism is necessary or whether the two components work together as claimed. The explanation of masking is also somewhat confusing. Equation 2 supplies the complete coarse flare-free image to the refinement network alongside the masked image and predicted flare. Consequently, information from the masked regions remains available through another input branch. This does not mean the design cannot work, but describing it as explicitly excluding corrupted pixels seems stronger than what the architecture actually enforces. The paper should distinguish between providing a spatial cue and removing access to potentially unreliable information. In terms of novelty, the method currently appears incremental. The PCB uses conditional multiplicative and additive feature modulation, while transferring features between restoration stages is also an established idea. The paper would benefit from a clearer explanation of what is technically new beyond combining these operations with flare-derived masking. A controlled comparison with a conventional feature-conditioning module would make this contribution easier to assess. Finally, the efficiency claims are stronger than the reported evidence. The minimum parameter increase of around 1% corresponds to a lightweight configuration, whereas the UNet configuration achieving the approximately 0.92 dB gain increases parameters from 9.0M to 11.8M and FLOPs from 62.4G to 84.9G. These may be reasonable trade-offs, but they are not uniformly negligible. The paper should present the performance and overhead of each configuration together rather than emphasizing the lowest overhead separately from the largest improvement.
Questions for authors
1.Was the threshold around 0.1 selected using an independent validation set or the test-set ground-truth masks described in Appendix A.0.2? If test annotations informed the choice, could the authors reevaluate the affected results with a validation-selected threshold? 2.Could the authors compare PCB with ordinary concatenation-plus-convolution or standard affine feature modulation, using the same coarse features and comparable parameter and training budgets? 3.Could the authors provide the missing mask-only configuration in Table 2? This would help separate the individual contributions of masking and PCB. 4.Since the complete coarse image is still supplied in Equation 2, what does “excluding corrupted pixels” mean operationally? What happens if the complete-image input branch is removed? 5.Could the authors explicitly pair each configuration’s restoration gain with its parameter, FLOPs, and runtime overhead, and clarify the inference timing protocol?