- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper reconstructs high-resolution 3D urban wind fields from a single vertical LiDAR column, together with building geometry and inflow conditions. It proposes a coarse-to-fine framework consisting of low-resolution completion and two super-resolution stages, a physics-guided mixture-of-experts module with region-specific experts and losses (general air, building boundary, vortex, high-speed, and ordinary regions), and a momentum–energy-guided mechanism that decides whether the second super-resolution stage is trained on ground-truth or predicted intermediate states. Experiments on 4,824 samples report an MAE of 0.1408, a 46% reduction over the best baseline.
Critical strengths
- The introduction is well written: the two challenges are clearly explained and directly correspond to the proposed components.
- The comparison includes a large number of baselines, and the ablations analyze each module as well as individual experts.
Critical weaknesses
- Gains do not come from the physics-guided designs. The largest improvement comes from the sampling mechanism (Table 2), but simply training on predicted inputs already achieves most of it (Pred-only 0.1485 vs. ours 0.1408, Table 5); this is essentially scheduled sampling, which is not cited. The direct reconstruction baseline already outperforms all compared methods, and several learned baselines are worse than nearest-neighbor interpolation, raising concerns about baseline adaptation.
- Role of the LiDAR/Radar input and generalization are not validated. Since building geometry and inflow conditions are given as input, an ablation without the LiDAR column is needed to show its contribution. The data source, sample variation, and split protocol are not explained, so generalization to unseen conditions is unclear.Unclear writing and task definition.
- Presentation and reproducibility. "Radar" and "LiDAR" are used interchangeably, and the sampling mechanism has several different names. The repository only contains checkpoint files, which appear incomplete, without model or training code.
Questions for authors
- What is the performance without the LiDAR/Radar input, using only building geometry and inflow conditions?
- What is the data source, what varies among samples, and does the test set contain unseen geometries or inflow conditions?
- Beyond the Pred-only setting, what is the specific contribution of the momentum–energy schedule, and how does it differ from scheduled sampling?