acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Aural: Towards Spoken-Content-Aware Spatial Auditory Scene Understanding with Large Audio Language Models

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large audio language models (LALMs) have advanced from recognizing *what is present* to understanding *where sources are*. Existing spatial LALMs can model both spoken content and general sound sources; however, these capabilities are largely treated as separate tasks, without explicitly connecting spoken content to spatially grounded sound events. This task separation limits joint understanding of speech and the surrounding auditory scene, where spoken content can be crucial for interpreting the situation. For example, a crash followed by speech may indicate very different situations depending on whether a speaker calls for help or comments on a dropped plate. To address this gap, we first curate **AuralSpeech**, a corpus for spatially localizing and transcribing speakers. We then introduce **AuralScene**, a multiple-choice question-answering dataset for spoken-content understanding, spatial grounding, and relational reasoning. Unlike existing datasets that primarily study these capabilities in isolation, AuralScene explicitly couples spoken content with spatially grounded sound events to support joint scene-level reasoning. To enable its systematic construction, we propose **Spatial Auditory Graph (SAG)**, a structured representation of spatial auditory scenes that enables the generation of diverse and controllable spatial audio scenes and question-answer pairs. Finally, we develop **AuralListener**, a baseline spatial LALM for the proposed tasks that combines monaural and spatial audio token streams, enabling controlled analysis of their complementary roles in spatial auditory understanding. Through comprehensive evaluations, we analyze how spoken content, monaural, and spatial audio representations contribute to understanding and identify remaining challenges in the proposed tasks, providing a step toward **spoken-content-aware spatial audio understanding**.

Primary area:
datasets and benchmarks
Keywords:
Large Audio Language Model, Multimodal System, Spatial Audio Understanding, Benchmark

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_pVSxOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper first curates AuralSpeech, a corpus for spatially localizing and transcribing speakers. It then introduces AuralScene, a multiple-choice question-answering dataset for spoken-content understanding, spatial grounding, and relational reasoning. Unlike existing datasets that primarily study these capabilities in isolation, AuralScene explicitly couples spoken content with spatially grounded sound events to support joint scene-level reasoning. To enable its systematic construction, the paper proposes Spatial Auditory Graph, a structured representation of spatial auditory scenes that enables the generation of diverse and controllable spatial audio scenes and question-answer pairs. Finally, it develops AuralListener, a baseline spatial LALM for the proposed tasks that combines monaural and spatial audio token streams, enabling controlled analysis of their complementary roles in spatial auditory understanding.

Critical strengths
  • The paper introduces spoken-content-aware spatial auditory scene understanding, jointly interpreting spoken content, sound events, and their relationships within a 3D auditory scene.
  • It presents AuralSpeech and AuralScene, and proposes Spatial Auditory Graph, a structured scene representation that enables automatic generation of spatial audio scenes and question-answer pairs.
  • It develops AuralListener, a spatial LALM baseline combining monaural and spatial audio token streams for the proposed tasks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The model comparison on AuralScene in the main table is unfair. The authors' own AuralListener is directly fine-tuned on the 420k AuralScene training QA pairs in Stage 3, while all the other audio language models in the comparison are tested zero-shot without training on this dataset. The high score in the main table mainly comes from training on the in-domain training split, which does not prove the model architecture itself is better than others.
  2. All the audio in AuralScene is generated from simulated rooms in SoundSpaces 2.0 and TTS synthesized speech from GPT-SoVITS, with no real recorded binaural audio at all. Although the paper tests on STAR-Bench and BiDepth, neither of those benchmarks tests reasoning that combines spoken content with sound events, so it remains unclear whether this method works on real binaural recordings.
Questions for authors
  1. After AuralListener finishes Stage 2 training on SpatialSoundQA and AuralSpeech only, before fine-tuning on the AuralScene training set in Stage 3, what score does it get when tested directly on AuralScene for a fair comparison with other zero-shot models?
  2. Can you fine-tune at least one open-source spatial audio language model baseline on the AuralScene training set and compare under the same training condition?
Reviewer_p76NOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces AuralSpeech and AuralScene for spoken-content-aware spatial auditory understanding. AuralSpeech supports speaker transcription, localization, and spatially conditioned transcription, while AuralScene evaluates perception and relational reasoning over speech and environmental sounds. A Spatial Auditory Graph guides scene synthesis and question generation. The proposed baseline, AuralListener, combines monaural and spatial audio representations, with experiments examining their complementary contributions and transfer to external benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a meaningful gap between understanding spoken content and grounding sound events spatially. The graph-based pipeline provides a systematic way to construct scenes with explicit temporal, spatial, and causal relations.
  2. Dataset validation is substantial: all retained scene graphs and evaluation questions undergo human verification, complemented by an audio-only human reference and scene-level confidence intervals.
  3. The token-stream and speech-supervision ablations provide useful diagnostics. Evaluations on STAR-Bench and BiDepth also extend the analysis beyond the proposed datasets.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The necessity of jointly using speech and environmental sounds is insufficiently established. Generated speech can explicitly narrate causal relations, as in Figure 2’s blender–dog example, potentially allowing some interaction questions to be answered without hearing the corresponding environmental event. The question-only baseline and encoder-branch ablations do not isolate this possibility; transcript-only evaluation and controlled removal or replacement of event audio would clarify what these questions actually require.

  2. The interpretation of the SCU comparison is confounded. Appendix D.2.1 attributes higher scores on several reasoning tasks to SCU, but “with SCU” and “without SCU” contain different questions and target events, rather than the same questions evaluated with and without speech information. These differences therefore cannot establish a benefit from spoken content alone and should be presented as comparisons between subsets with potentially different difficulty.

  3. Speech-supervision ablation does not isolate the benefit of spatial supervision. Figure 4 replaces full AuralSpeech supervision with single-speaker ASR, simultaneously changing the supervision tasks, speaker composition, and amount of training data. A control using the same multi-speaker audio and a matched training budget, but ordinary transcription targets, would better establish the specific contribution of STL/TST supervision.

  4. Transfer of the central speech–event reasoning capability remains untested. The external evaluations provide useful evidence of spatial perception and reasoning, but the reported tasks do not directly assess semantic interactions between spoken content and environmental events. Consequently, this central capability is evaluated within the synthetic SAG pipeline; a small independently constructed or real-recorded interaction test set would substantially strengthen the generalization evidence.

Questions for authors

Are training steps and speech-audio exposure matched across the supervision variants in Figure 4?

How are partially overlapping events handled? Appendix B.1 defines “before/after” using non-overlapping intervals, whereas the oracle prompt in Appendix C.3 assigns these labels to overlaps below 50% based on onset order. Are such cases excluded or scored using a consistent rule?

Reviewer_TRjTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces AuralSpeech and AuralScene for spoken-content-aware spatial audio understanding. AuralSpeech supports joint speaker transcription/localization and spatially conditioned target-speaker transcription. AuralScene uses Spatial Auditory Graphs (SAGs) to generate binaural scenes and multiple-choice questions about source attributes and temporal, spatial, and causal relations. Its evaluation set contains 2,700 questions from 113 validated scenes. The paper also develops AuralListener, which combines frozen spatial and monaural encoders with a LLaMA-2-7B decoder and curriculum training. Experiments include component and supervision ablations, audio-only human evaluation, scene-level confidence intervals, and transfer evaluation on STAR-Bench and BiDepth.

Critical strengths
  1. The authors verify graphs and evaluation questions, use disjoint environments for AuralSpeech, and provide an audio-only human reference in Appendix D.2.3. This goes substantially beyond simply converting existing audio captions into questions and could support useful controlled research.

  2. On the SCU subset in Table 6, accuracy falls from 65.00% to 55.07% without mono tokens and to 50.36% without spatial tokens. Appendix D.2.2 reports scene-level bootstrap intervals rather than treating all questions from one scene as independent samples. These analyses, together with the speech-supervision ablation and spatial transfer results, give the proposed baseline diagnostic value even though architectural novelty is not the main contribution.

Critical weaknesses
  1. In Section 4.3 and Appendix B.4, SCU membership is largely determined by whether a queried object is speech, identified through a semantic paraphrase of its utterance. This establishes a speech-grounding task, but does not by itself establish that the answer requires combining the meaning of speech with evidence from a non-speech event. The blind baseline addresses question-only shortcuts, while removing an encoder tests a representation choice; neither directly measures whether speech alone, a transcript, or a subset of the event audio is sufficient. This matters because speech is explicitly generated to describe, explain, or react to the surrounding events. In addition, the with/without-SCU groups contain different questions and target objects, so the differences described as improvements from SCU in Appendix D.2.1 are not a paired intervention. The benchmark needs a clearer account of which questions require both information sources, supported by input controls or matched counterfactuals.

  2. AuralScene evaluation uses 113 SAGs generated within the same overall ontology, question-template scheme, and simulation pipeline as training. Different generating LLMs, human verification, and the reported scene-level intervals are valuable safeguards, but do not test robustness to different speech–event associations or acoustic rendering assumptions. Appendix E explicitly acknowledges class-dependent spatial priors. STAR-Bench and BiDepth provide useful evidence of spatial transfer, but the reported evaluations do not directly test the newly proposed joint interpretation of spoken meaning and surrounding events in a different scene-generation process or real recordings. This leaves uncertainty about how much the benchmark advances that capability beyond its controlled construction.

Overall, I lean toward weak rejection. The resource is promising, and the existing validation deserves credit, but the evidence does not yet sufficiently distinguish the proposed joint-understanding capability from speech-based source identification and regularities of the construction pipeline.

Questions for authors
  1. What fraction of the evaluation questions, broken down by SNP/SRR/MRR, requires both spoken meaning and a non-speech event? Can you report transcript-only or speech-only results on the relevant subsets, and distinguish semantic source identification from questions whose answer changes when the speech–event relationship changes?

  2. Can you provide a matched control that changes spoken content while holding the non-speech scene fixed, or changes the relevant event/spatial relationship while preserving the speech? Such a control would materially strengthen the joint-understanding claim and the interpretation of SCU gains.

  3. Is there evidence on the proposed joint task outside the current AuralScene construction pipeline, for example a held-out relation composition, different rendering setup, or manually recorded scene subset? Please clarify what aspects of this claim are supported by the existing STAR-Bench/BiDepth results.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.