acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Q-OPS: When Selective Quantum Machine Learning Fails—A Cost-Aware Quantum-Kernel Bandit Audit for Human–AI Allocation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Advanced computation creates economic value only when its decision contribution exceeds its resource cost. Quantum-assisted AI makes this urgent: benchmarks ask whether a quantum routine changes an output, but organizations must decide before invocation whether it is worth acquiring under partial feedback and hard constraints. We ask whether pre-invocation context can guide a learner to decline or acquire Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) evidence. In synthetic human–AI task-mode allocation, a classical procedure fixes allocations and routes inadmissible cases to review, while quantum samples remain evidence rather than decisions. We introduce Q-OPS (Quantum-Optional Policy Selection), an audit that casts decline, depth-one or depth-two QAOA as priced contextual-bandit actions and compares linear, radial-basis-function (RBF), and six-qubit fidelity-kernel representations using ridge upper-confidence bounds. Across 320 held-out instances (221 eligible), the warm-started depth-one distribution improves normalized score over uniform support sampling by 0.331; an oracle invokes on 55.7% and earns 4.245 cumulative expected proxy reward. Yet every learner invokes on 100% and earns , , or ; aggregate losses include mandatory depth-two calls costing 0.66 although their largest archived gain is 0.494. The evidence separates reference-relative output quality, pre-invocation predictability, proxy net evidence value, and downstream decision value, which is not measured. Practitioners and policymakers should demand a decline option, resource price, pre-purchase information boundary, matched alternatives, and non-tradeable constraints. Limited to exact simulation on enumerable synthetic supports, Q-OPS motivates warm-state and classical-reference controls, fresh-instance mechanism tests, and participatory studies of costs and stakeholder-defined outcomes.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
human–AI allocation, contextual bandits, selective computation, value of computation, quantum machine learning, quantum kernels, QAOA, responsible AI

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_zotiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Q-OPS, a framework for evaluating whether contextual bandits can learn when to invoke quantum computation based on its expected benefit and cost. The authors consider 3 actions: (1) decline, (2) invoke QAOA at depth 1, and (3) invoke QAOA at depth 2. The authors compare ridge-UCB, RBF, and quantum kernel representations. The experiments show that QAOA improves solution quality relative to uniform sampling. However, all three learned policies invoke quantum computation on every eligible instance and obtain negative cumulative rewards.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper considers whether quantum computation should be invoked based on its expected benefit and cost, which is an interesting question.
  2. The authors report negative results on the failures of the tested learning algorithms and acknowledge important limitations of their evaluation.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The technical novelty and contribution are limited. This paper does not propose new algorithms, bandit formulations, or theoretical results. The main contribution is an evaluation/audit combining existing QAOA, kernel representations, and ridge-UCB. Moreover, in the experiments, QAOA is primarily compared against uniform sampling rather than competitive baseline methods. So the technical contribution is rather limited for ICLR.
  2. The proposed evaluation/audit relies entirely on a synthetic environment and a manually constructed evaluation objective given in Equation (1). The paper does not justify the choice of this objective function and the coefficients (i.e., why choosing coefficients 2, 9, 600, 150, 45?) or examine whether the main findings remain valid under different objectives or environments.
  3. The observed learning failures are not adequately explained.
  4. The presentation is unnecessarily complicated and repetitive. The authors introduce many nonstandard terms and frequently use lengthy expressions with multiple hyphens, such as "reference-relative output quality" and "proxy net evidence-acquisition value", which makes the main ideas harder to follow. Many notations are used before being defined. For example, Figure 1 uses symbols such as λ\lambda and G2G_2 before their formal definitions. Equation (1) introduces numerous quantities, but they are only briefly explained in Appendix B, without precise mathematical definitions. Figure 1 is difficult to understand since it combines too many elements without explaining how they are related. It also contains numerous symbols and technical terms without sufficient explanation. Table 1 largely repeats experimental settings already described in the main text.
Questions for authors
  1. What motivates the particular evaluation objective in Equation (1)? How were the coefficients of its different terms determined? More importantly, are the main experimental findings robust to other objective functions or different choices of these coefficients?
  2. What general insights can be drawn from the negative results? The paper shows that the tested UCB policies fail to learn effective selective invocation. Could you identify whether this failure arises from insufficient contextual information, the learning algorithm, or the experimental design?
Reviewer_4yKsOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

Q-OPS studies whether contextual bandits can learn when to invoke costly quantum computation. In synthetic human–AI task allocation, a classical solver fixes an allocation and a feasibility gate selects eligible instances. A ridge-UCB policy then chooses decline, depth-one QAOA, or depth-two QAOA using linear, RBF, or quantum-kernel features. QAOA is simulated exactly on a CPU; its samples are scored without updating the allocation. Reward is the normalized expected score gain over uniform sampling minus a prescribed depth cost. At the primary price, all three learners invoke on every eligible instance and earn negative cumulative reward, while a hindsight oracle invokes on 55.7% and earns positive reward. The paper contributes an auditable evaluation protocol, a negative empirical result, and a framework separating output quality, predictability, net acquisition value, and downstream decision value.

Critical strengths
  1. Reproducible numerical evidence. Exact finite-state simulation and archived traces support direct verification. Reanalysis reproduces cumulative rewards of -0.477125 for quantum UCB and 4.244823 for the oracle, and separates initialization losses from later rewards.

  2. A clear protocol for evaluating selective invocation. The study specifies pre-call information, a zero-reward decline action, eligibility rules, and invocation prices. Fixed-action baselines and a price sweep show how invocation performance changes with cost.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Standard bandit scheduling with no established quantum contribution. Q-OPS uses standard contextual UCB with action costs and a zero-reward decline option. Replacing QAOA with classical candidate generators leaves the scheduling formulation and update rules unchanged. The experiments omit a depth-zero warm-start control and a competitive classical generator, leaving QAOA's incremental value unresolved. The quantum kernel provides no meaningful gain over the matched RBF kernel. The reported losses also lack an identified mechanism connecting them to quantum computation.

  2. The evaluation does not measure allocation improvement or computational savings. Acquired samples never update the classical allocation. Reward measures distribution score gain over uniform sampling minus an assigned depth price. The pilot improved the allocation in 0 of 64 eligible cases; the held-out study then evaluated distribution scores. Depth prices are not calibrated to measured execution costs, and the reward omits the cost of constructing the four context features that require support enumeration. The reported rewards therefore do not establish the task value of selective invocation.

Questions for authors
  1. What result establishes the quantum components' contribution over classical candidate generators and a classical kernel in the same bandit framework?

  2. What results connect proxy reward to allocation improvement and net benefit after feature construction and invocation costs?

Reviewer_Nb5XOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether information available before a call can help determine when quantum computation is worth using. In a synthetic human–AI task allocation environment, the authors treat declining and invoking QAOA at two depths as alternative actions, and compare linear, RBF, and quantum-kernel representations. Although the simulated quantum outputs improve over uniform sampling, the learned policies fail to select calls appropriately at the primary cost setting. The quantum kernel also shows no clear practical advantage over RBF.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem setting is practically relevant. Considering both invocation costs and the option not to invoke is closer to an actual resource-allocation decision than comparing output quality alone.

  2. The authors are transparent about the negative results and clearly distinguish simulated proxy rewards from real application benefits. Results across different cost settings also help clarify the scope of the findings.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The experimental coverage is fairly limited. The main evaluation uses one synthetic environment, with 221 of the 320 test instances eligible for the bandit. The 30 runs change the order of the same instances, so they provide limited evidence of stability across independently generated datasets. It remains unclear whether the main negative findings would persist with a new set of instances or a longer learning horizon. These additional experiments would make the conclusions more convincing.

  2. The comparison of learning strategies is incomplete. The three learners mainly differ in their representations and all use the same UCB decision rule. Their shared failure therefore does not distinguish between insufficient information in the context and an exploration strategy that is poorly suited to this setting. A simple greedy policy or another exploration method would help explain the results. The authors discuss these directions, but do not yet provide the corresponding experiments.

Questions for authors
  1. Do the same patterns of excessive invocation and negative reward persist on newly generated instances or with a longer learning horizon?

  2. How would a greedy policy without the exploration bonus, or another exploration method, perform? Could this help determine whether the failure mainly comes from value prediction or UCB exploration?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.