- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates diffusion-based posterior sampling for linear inverse problems. The authors employ singular value decomposition (SVD) of the linear measurement operator and compare the measurement SNR with the diffusion SNR along different singular directions. Based on this comparison, different DDIM update rules are applied to generate posterior samples. The authors also establish asymptotic convergence to the true posterior distribution under certain assumptions.
Critical strengths
1.Clear presentation and motivation.
The paper is well structured, with clearly stated research objectives. The proposed algorithm is relatively easy to understand for readers familiar with diffusion-based inverse problems.
2.Theoretical analysis.
The paper provides theoretical analysis and establishes asymptotic posterior convergence under specific assumptions.
Critical weaknesses
Limited algorithmic novelty compared with DDRM.
Although the authors propose Posterior-DDIM with asymptotic posterior convergence guarantees, its algorithmic design is closely related to DDRM. In particular, both methods employ essentially the same SVD-based noise partitioning strategy, and their updates along measurement-dominated directions have identical marginal distributions under certain parameter choices. While the proposed method introduces modifications to the sampling updates, their necessity and practical contributions relative to DDRM are not sufficiently demonstrated.
Questions for authors
Could the authors provide a direct comparison between Equation (8) of DDRM and Equations (22)–(24) of this paper, clarifying the main algorithmic differences and their significance? I would also appreciate targeted ablation studies demonstrating whether these modifications lead to meaningful empirical improvements.