- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PowerSim couples PowerFoam’s bounded power-diagram representation with differentiable Material Point Method (MPM) simulation. It updates primitive positions, scalar radii, dipole orientations, appearance directions, and adjacency according to simulated motion. The resulting pipeline supports material estimation from deformation videos, object selection from multiview masks, scene composition, and dynamic reflections. Experiments compare dynamic reconstruction and material estimation against PAC-NeRF and PhysDreamer.
Critical strengths
-
The framework provides a practical way to animate PowerFoam scenes while updating geometry, appearance, and adjacency together.
-
Dynamic reconstruction results are encouraging: mean PSNR is 25.73 dB, compared with 22.06 dB for PAC-NeRF and 19.00 dB for PhysDreamer.
-
The optimization-free primitive-selection procedure is useful, achieving 0.80 mean IoU compared with 0.82 for SemanticFoam, which requires semantic optimization.
Critical weaknesses
-
Minor conceptual novelty. The central strategy—coupling rendering primitives to MPM and differentiating through simulation and rendering for material estimation—is already established by prior work discussed in the paper. The proposed position, rotation, scale, and appearance updates are reasonable adaptations, but the paper does not establish a sufficiently substantial methodological advance beyond that transfer.
-
The claimed representational advantage is not adequately validated. Explicit cell boundaries and adjacency are potentially useful, but the paper does not demonstrate quantitatively that they yield more accurate material volumes, contact behavior, or continuum deformation. Particle masses are assigned using occupied grid voxels rather than exact cell volumes, further limiting the demonstrated connection between explicit geometry and physical accuracy.
-
The evaluation does not isolate the source of improvement. Better dynamic PSNR may partly reflect differences in the underlying static representations. Without controls for initial reconstruction quality and quantitative component ablations, it is difficult to attribute the gains to the proposed coupling.
-
Material estimation gains are limited in scope. Young’s modulus estimation improves on average, but Poisson’s ratio error remains tied with PhysDreamer at 0.16. The experiments do not establish accurate recovery of heterogeneous material fields, despite this being a highlighted capability.
Questions for authors
-
Beyond applying established differentiable MPM coupling to PowerFoam, what is the central technical insight that could not be obtained through a straightforward adaptation of existing pipelines?
-
Can the authors quantify how explicit power-cell boundaries improve physical accuracy, particularly for volume evolution, contact, and large deformation?
-
How much of the dynamic reconstruction improvement remains after accounting for differences in static reconstruction quality?
-
Can the authors provide quantitative ablations of radius scaling, dipole rotation, appearance rotation, and adjacency rebuilding?
5 comments
Response to kv8K (2/3): Isolation of static reconstruction quality and material estimation gains
3/ Isolation of static reconstruction quality. We thank the reviewer for suggesting this insightful comparison which further reveals interesting observation and strengthens our PowerSim result. As shown below, we separate reconstruction quality into a static score (first frame, before any simulation) and a dynamic score (averaged over simulated frames after first floor contact, where the object deforms).
| Method | Static PSNR / SSIM (first frame) | Dynamic PSNR / SSIM (frames after floor contact) |
|---|---|---|
| PAC-NeRF | 26.32 / 0.938 | 17.72 / 0.898 |
| PhysDreamer | 27.26 / 0.952 | 18.62 / 0.906 |
| PowerSim (Ours) | 26.75 / 0.943 | 23.71 / 0.915 |
Interestingly, the three methods start from comparable static quality, within 1 dB of each other. PowerSim is 0.51 dB below PhysDreamer and only 0.43 dB above PAC-NeRF on the static frame, yet it is 5.09 dB and 5.99 dB ahead of them, respectively, on the deforming frames. The gain therefore cannot be explained by first-frame reconstruction quality; it comes from how each representation follows the simulated deformation.
4/ Material estimation gains. We agree that the gain is concentrated in Young's modulus, and we argue this reflects what the benchmark can measure:
- Poisson's ratio is weakly identifiable from visual dynamics. In a drop, governs the dominant visible response (compression and rebound at impact), while only affects the subtle lateral bulging, which barely changes the rendered images. The column therefore does not separate methods: the tie at 0.16 reflects that neither method can reliably recover from this kind of motion
- Heterogeneous material fields. To the best of our knowledge, there is no official benchmark provides ground-truth spatially varying materials. We instead demonstrate it qualitatively on real captures: the recovered field reproduces the observed motion of the carnation (Fig. 4).
Response to kv8K (3/3): Quantitative ablations of components
5/ Quantitative ablations of components. We thank reviewer for suggesting this analysis, which could help clearly indicate the effectiveness of each component update. Below, we provide more quantitative ablations of each component and we already updated this in the revised manuscript. For the ablation, we rerun the forward simulation process in the GSO benchmark by keeping each component at its rest value during simulation, while everything else is unchanged. As in Table 1 of the main paper, these scores are averaged over all 24 frames of the sequence, including the static first frame.
| Variant | PSNR | SSIM |
|---|---|---|
| w/o dipole rotation | 24.03 | 0.909 |
| w/o radius scaling | 24.16 | 0.903 |
| w/o appearance rotation | 23.87 | 0.907 |
| w/o adjacency rebuilding | 24.22 | 0.917 |
| Full | 25.73 | 0.930 |
The full update rule achieves the best result, and removing any single component lowers PSNR by 1.5–1.9 dB, which indicates that each update contributes to a faithful simulation result.
Response to kv8K (1/3): Conceptual Novelty and Representational Advantage
We thank the reviewer for recognizing that PowerSim provides “a practical way to animate PowerFoam scenes while updating geometry, appearance, and adjacency together.” We appreciate reviewer’s assessment that the dynamic reconstruction results are “encouraging” and that the “optimization-free primitive-selection procedure is useful.”. We provide detailed responses to feedback as follows:
1/ Conceptual Novelty. We agree that coupling rendering primitives to MPM and differentiating through simulation and rendering were introduced by prior work. However, extending this paradigm to PowerFoam is non-trivial. Unlike Gaussians, whose covariance can be transformed directly by the deformation gradient, a PowerFoam primitive is a power cell coupled to its neighbours, with a radius, an oriented surface plane and appearance directions. Each requires a dedicated update rule to follow the MPM deformation, and our ablations (Fig. 7 and the quantitative ablation in 5/ below) show that each one contributes.
Central Insight. In Gaussian representation, each primitive must absorb the full deformation gradient, which stretches kernels into needle-like artifacts under large deformation. In PowerFoam, a cell's shape is also determined by its neighbours. We exploit this to split the deformation: the anisotropic part (stretch and shear) is carried collectively by the cell structure as MPM moves the sites, while each primitive only takes the rotation and uniform scale from the polar decomposition F=RS. This split is what keeps the cells well-formed under extreme deformation, and it is not available to existing per-primitive pipelines.
More importantly, PowerSim is a complete framework: foam selection and editing to obtain simulation particles, material estimation from video, and physics simulation with rasterized or ray-traced rendering. We also argue that its representation, PowerFoam, is well suited to physics simulation, thanks to three key properties supported by our experiments:
2/ Representational advantage. We thank the reviewer for this insightful question. PowerSim uses the same MPM solver, constitutive models and colliders as the baselines, so the physical behaviour (deformation, contact and mass) is determined by MPM rather than by the cell geometry. Our claimed advantage is that PowerFoam represents and renders the simulated deformation more faithfully, especially under large deformation (as shown in Fig. 2 and Fig. 7); we do not claim more accurate physics.