- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a novel framework for the text-controllable physics simulation thourgh agentic generation. Specifically, the proposed method will first ask the agent to infer mathematical functions and their parameters for each temporal chunk. The authors then apply a differentiable Material Point Method (MPM) simulator and fit the parameters to minimize the trajectory error. In addition, the authors also provide a new metric, Motion-IG to better evaluate the text-motion alignment.
Critical strengths
- The topic is interesting, which explores agents' understanding capability to formulate the accurate motion behaviors.
- The quantitative results on the proposed metrics are satisfying.
- The proposed metric is reasonable, although it needs to be strictly verfied by human perferencce.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors should report the proposed method on more evaluation metrics. For example, in MotionPhysics, they use overall consistency, cliip similiarity and energy-constrained motion score for quantative results.
- The authors provide a new metric to measure the motion-text alignment, the reliability should be evaluated. For example, the authors should use user study to evaluate the correlation between human preference and the proposed metric within different ablation studies.
- There should be more ablation study to justify the technical designs. For example, the authors select different function family for different motion cues. What if the function is not such accurate since the trajectory in the real world is usually not perfect. In addition, how these formulation and hyper-parameters are chosen? Are they fitted on the test set? If so, the evaluation is not fair for other methods.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weakness part.
4 comments
Dear Reviewer j4Np,
We appreciate your careful feedback and valuable comments. Following your feedback, we conducted additional evaluations using diverse metrics and further validation of Motion-IG, along with further analyses of our method. These additions helped us provide stronger evidence for the validity and robustness of our proposed metric and clarified how inaccurate motion plans affect simulation outcomes.
With the discussion ending soon, we would be grateful if you could share your thoughts on our responses. Please let us know if any concerns remain or if there is anything we could clarify further.
Best regards,
The Authors
Thanks for authors' detailed response, which solves most of my concerns. After read all the reviews and authors' rebuttal, I lean to acceptance now.
We sincerely appreciate your careful review and your decision to raise your score; your suggestions have greatly improved our paper.
Response to reviewer j4Np
[W1] Results with additional evaluation metrics
[W2] Further validation of Motion-IG
[W3] Motion function selection, inaccurate plans, and clarification