- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript presents MIRAGE, a visual–LiDAR–inertial mapping framework that uses mesh-Gaussian scene representation and achieves centimeter-level accuracy in sensor-rig trajectory estimation and high-quality 3D reconstruction. Built upon Voxel-SLAM, MIRAGE incorporates MASt3R and depth priors from Depth Anything into its odometry pipeline and extends the system with 3DGS-based reconstruction. The manuscript also introduces a synchronized RGB–LiDAR–IMU benchmark dataset featuring full 6-DoF ground-truth trajectories over long traversals in object-rich indoor environments.
Critical strengths
- A unified pipeline that integrates RGB, LiDAR, and IMU data for high-quality mesh-Gaussian reconstruction.
- A novel dataset featuring synchronized RGB–LiDAR–IMU data and full 6-DoF ground-truth trajectories over long traversals in object-rich indoor environments.
Critical weaknesses
-
My primary concern is that this work appears to be an ad hoc improvement and 3DGS extension of Voxel-SLAM. While the overall goal is to achieve large-scale, high-fidelity 3D Gaussian Splatting reconstruction, the manuscript lacks a clear formulation of the underlying research problems, making the contributions appear largely engineering-driven.
-
Despite 3D Gaussian Splatting being a central focus of the manuscript, it receives insufficient discussion in the Introduction and Related Work sections, whereas the Contributions and Method sections explicitly emphasize its treatment. This further obscures the main focus and contributions of the work.
-
To improve localization accuracy using visual information, the front-end employs MASt3R correspondences and LiDAR depth maps completed using Depth Anything priors for camera pose estimation. This introduces substantial computational overhead, while Table 1 shows only limited improvements in trajectory accuracy over Voxel-SLAM.
-
Although the proposed dataset is presented as one of the main contributions, its comparison with existing datasets is limited to discussions in the Introduction and Related Work sections. A more systematic comparison is missing.
Questions for authors
-
How does the proposed method perform without loop closure? In Table 1, Fast-LIVO2 is an odometry method that inevitably accumulates trajectory drift, whereas the proposed method is a SLAM system with loop closure detection and optimization to mitigate such drift. An ablation study without loop closure would help clarify the source of the accuracy improvements.
-
Why is Voxel-SLAM categorized as an offline method in Table 1? The original Voxel-SLAM paper reports real-time performance.
-
How does the proposed dataset differ from existing datasets? I suggest including a comparison table in the revised manuscript to clearly highlight the distinguishing characteristics and advantages of the proposed dataset.
-
What is the runtime performance of the proposed system?
Response to R3 — huEB
Thank you for the questions on the research focus, loop closure, and dataset scope.
Research problem and contribution.
No-loop results and visual utility.
Optimization stages and runtime.
Benchmark.