- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper is difficult to follow. The introduction is not clear, and neither are the following sections. It's hard to understand (1) what the problem is; (2) what the limitations of current approaches are; and (3) how the authors aim to overcome these limitations. From what I could understand, the remaining question is: why is HRL an appropriate solution for this extremely noisy setting?
I would expect the authors to provide this justification in the Related Work section at the latest. The paper mentions relevant works such as EarnHFT, but without explaining their limitations or including the complete methods as baselines for comparison. The introduction also mentions expressiveness power and overfitting, but the connection between these issues and the proposed solution is not clearly established or empirically demonstrated.
At the current stage, the presentation makes it difficult to assess the contribution. I believe this paper needs substantial revision before being submitted again.
Critical strengths
The problem seems to be interesting, although the presentation did not highlight it.
Critical weaknesses
The presentation makes it difficult to assess the contribution.
Questions for authors
Why weren't the papers in the Related Works used as baselines? What are their limitations?