acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

PreCoG: Preview-Edit for Efficient Video Correction in Generation-Time

Abstract

Iterative text-to-video generation relies on feedback to correct compositional and temporal failures. However, existing methods typically require another full generation run for each correction, repeating computation and potentially disrupting already correct content. We introduce **PreCoG**, an iterative framework for correcting semantic failures during video generation. **PreQA** diagnoses failures from low-cost previews and constructs corrective conditions, while **PreEdit** edits cached generation trajectories under these conditions, attenuating orthogonal changes to limit disruption of already correct content.**PreCoG**completes generation only for the selected candidate, reusing its cached trajectory to reduce redundant computation and help preserve semantic consistency between the preview and the final video. Experiments show that **PreCoG** achieves the highest VBench score among the compared methods and approaches VSR's leading prompt alignment at its inference time. It also outperforms GENMAC on all three quality and alignment metrics at its inference time.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Video Generation, Agentic Video Generation, Efficient Video Generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_nuDzOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the computational waste of repeatedly regenerating videos in text-to-video generation, which can also destroy content that was already correct. It proposes to first check errors on low-cost drafts, make targeted edits on the draft’s generation trajectory, and fully render only once at the end. On Wan2.2, it show higher quality and alignment scores with roughly half the time cost. However, the evaluation lacks evidence that supports its core claims.

Critical strengths

(1)The motivation of the paper is commendable, and it is backed by corresponding experimental exploration, which provides some reference value.

(2)The paper is well written.

Critical weaknesses

(1) Although the motivation is reasonable, the paper does not verify whether “a correct draft leads to a correct final video” actually holds.

(2) The core selling point of the paper, that fixing one part breaks another, lacks quantitative evidence; there are only two simple illustrative examples.

(3) The numbers in Table 6 look somewhat strange (e.g., apart from Wan2.2-T2V-A14B, the entries all end in 0 or 5). Could the authors explain this?

(4) Please report the number of prompts and seeds for each table/figure, as well as the prompts that were excluded.

(5) How were the PreCoG AB/GN values in Table 6 and Table 4 obtained?

Others: In the Microsoft Edge browser, the formulas in Figure 1 are displayed as “?”.

Questions for authors

Pls see weaknesses.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Weakness 1, Weakness 2

We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful review and constructive feedback.

W1. Preview-to-final reliability. Figure 3(a) quantitatively evaluates this premise using paired previews and full renders. Among accepted previews, approximately 96.69% also yield accepted full renders. Conversely, all accepted full renders have accepted previews, with no false rejections observed in this sample. These results support preview-based assessment for the initial candidates evaluated.

To avoid relying solely on Gemini 3.1 Pro or initial candidates, we further evaluate both initial and edited candidates using the deployed Qwen3.8-27B evaluator (Appendix G, Fig. 9).

Candidate groupBoth rejectBoth acceptPreview reject / full acceptPreview accept / full reject
Initial candidates48.57%49.71%0.00%1.71%
Edited candidates48.29%48.17%0.00%3.54%

These results support preview-based assessment across evaluators and for both initial and edited candidates.

W2. Preserving satisfied content during correction. The risk of altering already correct content during correction is an established challenge discussed in multi-turn image editing (MT Forcing [1]), regeneration-based video refinement (VideoRepair [2]), and video editing (Vera [3]). We invoke this documented challenge as motivation, rather than introduce it as a new empirical finding based solely on our two examples. Figure 4 illustrates how this challenge manifests in our setting, while Table 2 quantitatively evaluates the effectiveness of our proposed correction mechanisms.

 To further quantify this issue in our setting and evaluate PreCoG’s effectiveness in addressing it, We have added a quantitative comparison of VSR, GENMAC, and PreCoG, all using Qwen3.8-27B as their feedback VLM. An independent Gemini 3.1 Pro evaluator compares each method’s initial candidate (iteration 0) with its final selected candidate, assessing whether the original problems are resolved and whether new problems are introduced.

MethodSamples with original problems resolved ↑Samples with new problems introduced ↓
VSR87.06%25.79%
GENMAC82.30%12.38%
PreCoG90.71%8.57%

These outcomes are assessed separately: a sample may resolve its original problems while introducing new ones. The results quantitatively confirm that existing feedback-based correction methods can introduce new errors during refinement. PreCoG achieves both the highest problem-resolution rate and the lowest new-problem rate, supporting the effectiveness of its targeted editing mechanism in correcting identified failures while limiting unintended changes.

References

[1] Houyuan Chen et al. MT Forcing: Towards Stable and Consistent Multi-Turn Image Editing with Autoregressive Diffusion. arXiv:2610.25404, 2026.

[2] Daeun Lee et al. VideoRepair: Improving Text-to-Video Generation via Misalignment Evaluation and Localized Refinement. arXiv:2411.15115, 2024.

[3] Hongkai Zheng et al. Vera: A Layered Diffusion Model for Content-Preserving Video Editing. arXiv:2606.23610, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Weakness 3, Weakness 4, and Weakness 5

W3. Numerical precision in Table 6. To accelerate preliminary validation of PreCoG's generalizability across backbones, we evaluated configurations other than Wan2.2-T2V-A14B in two batches, each covering half of the evaluation samples. The batch-level mean scores were inadvertently saved with insufficient decimal precision before aggregation, producing the recurring trailing zeros and fives in Table 6. We apologize for this reporting error. The corrected means, calculated from the unrounded evaluation results, are provided below.

TaskBackboneVBench DirectVBench PreCoGDeltaT2V-Comp. DirectT2V-Comp. PreCoGDeltaVS2 DirectVS2 PreCoGDelta
T2VWan2.2-TI2V-5B79.7881.07+1.2948.6154.22+5.613.4193.608+0.189
T2VSkyReels-V2-T2V-14B81.2182.37+1.1652.8358.91+6.083.5783.752+0.174
T2VHelios-Base80.7181.64+0.9350.4255.69+5.273.4903.652+0.162
I2VWan2.2-TI2V-5B82.1082.84+0.7454.2959.12+4.833.5983.740+0.142
I2VWan2.2-I2V-A14B83.3884.03+0.6558.2163.42+5.213.7583.889+0.131

VBench and T2V-Comp. are reported on a 0-100 scale; Delta denotes the change from direct generation. We have updated Table 6 accordingly. The corrections are small and preserve the improvement over direct generation in all three metrics across the tested configurations.

W4. Prompt coverage, generation seeds, and timing samples. All quality scores use the same randomly selected set of 180 prompts from each of the seven T2V-CompBench categories, giving 1,260 prompts in total, with matched generation seeds across the compared methods. The full benchmark contains 200 prompts per category (1,400 in total); the remaining 20 prompts per category are outside this quality-evaluation subset. The generation seeds used in our experiments are 17 and 20260822.

Our original timing evaluation used those remaining 20 prompts per category, giving a separate set of 140 prompts. We have now recomputed inference time on the same 180 prompts per category used for quality evaluation, so the revised quality and timing comparisons use the same prompt population.

W5. AB/GN evaluation. We evaluate videos generated by PreCoG using prompts from the official Action Binding (AB) and Generative Numeracy (GN) categories of T2V-CompBench. Both the visual models and evaluation procedures follow the standard T2V-CompBench pipeline. AB uses Grid-LLaVA to assess whether each subject performs its specified action, with scores normalized and averaged across videos. GN uses GroundingDINO to compare detected object counts with the requested quantities, averaging scores across frames and then videos. Both category scores are reported on a 0–100 scale.

Other comment. Figure 1 rendering. We thank the reviewer for bringing this rendering issue to our attention. We have rasterized the main figure, so its equations no longer depend on PDF font rendering.

Thanks for the rebuttal and new experiments. Some concerns are addressed, but I still have a few questions:

(1) The false acceptance rate increases from 1.71% to 3.54% after editing. Does this affect the correction loop?

(2) The new comparison is helpful, but it still relies on VLM judgments. Not sure how well this matches human evaluation.

(3) The explanation for the strange numbers in Table 6 makes sense, but the original reporting issue still raises some concerns about the experimental reliability.

Overall, the rebuttal helps, but I'm still a bit concerned about the reliability of the results. I'll keep my original score for now.

Reviewer_NMqNOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PreCoG, an iterative framework for correcting semantic failures during text-to-video generation at generation time. It couples two components. PreQA decomposes the prompt into a fixed set of atomic visual requirements and runs three agents: a Planning Agent (adapted from GENMAC) that maps the prompt to a source condition and spatiotemporal layout, an Evaluation Agent that scores low-cost previews against each requirement with binary verdicts, and a Refinement Agent that constructs a matched target condition (repair plan) and a counterfactual condition (the target with only the diagnosed attributes replaced by their observed failure values). PreEdit is a training-free editor that reuses the cached trajectory of the highest-coverage preview: it computes a source-relative update and a target-counterfactual contrast direction, applies blockwise soft projection that clips the update onto the contrastive segment, and blends the projected and regular updates within an early window, then continues denoising from the edited state. Previews share the first 14 native denoising steps with full rendering (14+2+2 preview schedule, at most four editing rounds); only the selected candidate receives full rendering from its cached state. Experiments on Wan2.2-T2V-A14B over T2V-CompBench prompts report gains of 1.43 VBench points, 7.01 T2V-CompBench points, and 0.146 VS2 over direct generation at 2.26x its inference time, outperforming GENMAC on all three metrics at 0.86x its time and approaching VSR's VS2 at 0.56x its time, with component ablations, a five-model VLM ablation, six backbone/task configurations, and a four-rater human preference study.

Critical strengths
  1. Well-motivated and coherent framework. The three design principles (assess low-cost previews before full rendering, edit relative to an existing trajectory rather than regenerate, treat spent computation as a reusable asset) are each concretely realized, and the decoupling of cheap diagnosis from expensive final rendering is the right decomposition for this problem.
  2. PreEdit is clean and training-free. The method reuses cached latent states, applied velocities, and solver state; the target-counterfactual contrast isolates the direction from observed failure toward the desired state while the shared unconditional CFG response cancels; and Appendix E.2 provides an actual derivation (Eq. 6) showing the blended update cannot increase squared distance to any correction in the bounded segment. Hyperparameters, block geometry, CFG scales, and windows are all specified exactly.
  3. The ablation suite is unusually complete for this subfield. Table 2 isolates each component (full-video evaluation, planning, target refinement, regeneration-instead-of-editing, counterfactual projection), and critically the regeneration-instead-of-editing control directly tests the paper's central claim that cached editing beats another full generation round. Table 5 ablates the PreQA model across five VLMs, and Table 6 shows consistent gains across four T2V and two I2V backbones, arguing against single-model overfitting.
  4. The preview-reliability analysis (Fig. 3) is honest and useful. Sweeping shared trajectory length from 6 to 14 native steps (72.0% to 98.24% decision agreement) empirically justifies the 14-step preview budget, and the authors explicitly flag that the diagnostic uses an independent evaluator in stateless requests.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence for the framework's central premise has coverage gaps. The 98.24% preview/full decision agreement is measured with Gemini 3.1 Pro, whereas the deployed system uses Qwen3.8-27B as Evaluation Agent, so the reliability number does not come from the deployed configuration. More importantly, the diagnostic explicitly covers initial candidates under a fixed generation seed only; the system's actual dependency is on edited previews, whose decision reliability after correction edits is never measured. Fig. 3(a) also contains an unexplained 0.00% cell, and only the false-accept direction (1.76%) is discussed.
  2. The correction loop is driven by the same species of VLM verdict that the VLM-based metrics reward, with no measured agreement between them. The Evaluation Agent's binary verdicts decide when to stop editing, while VS2 and T2V-CompBench are also VLM judgments; nothing quantifies how often a Qwen "requirement satisfied" verdict coincides with VS2 or human preference. Table 5 shows VS2 ranging from 3.584 to 3.918 across evaluators, so results are visibly evaluator-sensitive, yet the headline configuration (Qwen3.8-27B) is also one of the better-performing evaluators, which raises an evaluator-overfitting concern that is not addressed.
  3. Timing and quality are computed on different cohorts, by the authors' own disclosure. Baseline timing retains all cohorts with available outputs while quality uses the matched completed-output subset; Fig. 8's Pareto curves therefore combine numbers computed on different populations. Additionally, all baselines are the authors' own Wan2.2 re-implementations (with VSR adapted from the Visual Self-Refine baseline described in VISTA rather than an official release), and no official baseline numbers are cited, so baseline fairness rests on undocumented implementation choices.
  4. The VBench number uses a self-defined protocol and this is not flagged in the main text. The abstract and Table 1 claim the "highest VBench scores" while Appendix F reveals this is an unweighted mean of six quality dimensions with temporal flickering excluded, not the official VBench total. PreCoG's dynamic degree (78.12) also trails direct generation (81.25), suggesting correction may systematically suppress motion; this is not analyzed even though "limit unrelated changes" could mechanistically explain it.
  5. The main comparison against feedback baselines exists on a single backbone (Wan2.2-T2V-A14B); the other five configurations in Table 6 compare PreCoG only to direct generation, so generality of the baseline comparison is asserted rather than shown.
Questions for authors
  1. Can you report preview/full decision agreement for edited candidates (not only initial ones) and under the deployed Qwen3.8-27B evaluator? What is the 0.00% cell in Fig. 3(a), and what happens in the false-reject direction (preview rejects a video whose full render would have passed)?
  2. Is there any measured agreement between the Qwen requirement verdicts that drive the stopping rule and the VLM-based metrics (VS2, T2V-CompBench) or human judgments? Was the PreQA model selected by system performance, and how do you rule out overfitting to the evaluator? GPT-4.1 reaches VS2 3.918 versus 3.854 for the Qwen3.8 configuration; why was Qwen3.8-27B chosen for the headline?
  3. Can inference time be recomputed on the same matched subset used for quality and alignment, and can you cite official baseline timings or release your re-implementations? For VSR specifically: is it the VISTA paper's Visual Self-Refine baseline adapted to Wan2.2, and how does it differ from VISTA itself as listed in Table 1's related-work lineage?
  4. Do the dynamic-degree drops (78.12 for PreCoG vs 81.25 for direct generation and CachedSearch) reflect a systematic motion suppression caused by limiting unrelated changes? And can the abstract/Table 1 state the VBench protocol (six-dimension equal mean, flickering excluded) at least briefly?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Weakness 1,Question1, Weakness 2 and Question2

We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful review and constructive feedback.

W1 & Q1. Preview/full decision agreement.

We independently assess each preview and its corresponding full render with the same VLM judge against the prompt requirements, then compare their pass/reject decisions.

For each prompt, we generate a preview and its corresponding full render. The 0.00% cell in Fig. 3(a) indicates that no preview was rejected when its corresponding full render was accepted. A false rejection would lead to unnecessary correction and additional computation, since a candidate whose full render would have passed is instead sent for further correction.

We chose Gemini 3.1 Pro for Fig. 3 as an evaluator distinct from the Qwen3.8-27B agent used in our main experiments, so that the preview/full reliability analysis would not rely solely on the same VLM. We now additionally report results under the deployed Qwen3.8-27B evaluator for both edited and initial candidates in Appendix G, Fig. 9.

Candidate groupBoth rejectBoth acceptPreview reject / full acceptPreview accept / full reject
Initial candidates48.57%49.71%0.00%1.71%
Edited candidates48.29%48.17%0.00%3.54%

These results are highly consistent with the findings on initial candidates evaluated by Gemini 3.1 Pro.

W2 & Q2. Evaluator agreement and choice of the PreQA model.

Evaluator dependence. Our offline metrics do not reuse the online PreQA evaluator, Qwen3.8-27B. Following T2V-CompBench's standard evaluation pipeline, its VLM-based categories use LLaVA-v1.6-34B [1], with Grid-LLaVA for consistent attribute binding, action binding, and object interactions, and D-LLaVA for dynamic attribute binding. The remaining categories use detection- or tracking-based metrics. VideoScore2 uses the official TIGER-Lab/VideoScore2 checkpoint, trained from Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct [2] with supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement learning, rather than the online Qwen3.8-27B agent.

Agreement with independent evaluation. For prompts whose initial previews did not satisfy all requirements, we compare the full renders of candidates accepted by Qwen3.8-27B with those of randomly selected earlier intermediate candidates from the same correction trajectories.

MetricRandom intermediate candidateCandidate accepted by Qwen3.8-27BDifference
Mean VS2 ↑3.6433.872+0.229

These results support an association between Qwen3.8-27B's acceptance decisions and higher VS2 alignment scores, as assessed by the separate VideoScore2 checkpoint trained from Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct [6] through supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement learning.

Choice of the PreQA model for the headline results. We chose Qwen3.8-27B for its open-weight availability and support for reproducible local deployment. Local deployment also allows us to measure agent inference overhead on specified hardware and include it in the reported end-to-end runtime. Although GPT-4.1 and Gemini achieve higher scores on some metrics, their API response times also include network communication and provider-side queuing and scheduling, which we cannot separately measure or control. Qwen therefore provides a practical default for reproducible quality-efficiency comparisons.

PreCoG is designed as a framework that accommodates different video backbones and VLM agents. Our main comparisons evaluate direct generation, feedback baselines, and PreCoG under a common backbone configuration, with the same feedback model used by methods requiring online assessment. The VLM ablation examines sensitivity to the agent choice; it is not intended to establish a ranking of VLMs. We acknowledge that this choice affects performance and do not claim that Qwen is universally optimal.

References

[1] Haotian Liu et al. LLaVA-NeXT: Improved reasoning, OCR, and world knowledge. 2024. https://llava-vl.github.io/blog/2024-01-30-llava-next/.

[2] Shuai Bai et al. Qwen2.5-VL Technical Report. arXiv:2502.13923, 2025. https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.13923.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Weakness 3 and Question 3

W3 & Q3. Matched-sample timing and baseline implementations.

Matched-sample timing. We have recomputed inference time using exactly the same matched sample subset used for quality and alignment evaluation. The revised timing results and quality-time comparisons therefore use the same evaluation population. The changes are small and leave the runtime ranking unchanged. PreCoG remains the fastest search or feedback method, taking 0.56 times the runtime of VSR and 0.87 times that of GENMAC.

MetricDirect generationFull best-of-NCachedSearchVQQAVSRGENMACPreCoG
Time (s)893.23577.34329.73120.23625.72347.12043.5

Baseline implementations. The baseline methods do not provide official adaptations for Wan2.2 and MiniMax-H3. However, the other baselines provide public source code, while VQQA provides detailed prompt examples describing its feedback and refinement procedure. These resources guide our backbone-specific adaptations. We document the generation budgets, stopping criteria, and output-selection rules in the experimental details, and provide our implementations and configurations at the anonymous link below to make the adaptation choices transparent and reproducible.

Anonymous implementation repository: PreCoG-Wan22-Baselines

VSR provenance. We apologize for the inaccurate attribution in our implementation details. Our implementation adapts the Visual Self-Refine example from the official Self-Refine repository [1], specifically its Visual-Self-Refine-GPT4V notebook, to video generation. It is not derived from a VISTA implementation. Qwen3.8-27B inspects each full video and refines the prompt for the next full generation. We use four generations with the same seed and deliver the final video, without early stopping or best-candidate selection. We have corrected the VSR paragraph in Appendix "Detailed Experimental Settings" to identify this source and link the original notebook. VISTA is discussed as related work; our VSR results do not constitute a comparison with the full VISTA system.

References

[1] Aman Madaan et al. Self-Refine: Iterative Refinement with Self-Feedback. arXiv:2303.17651, 2023. https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17651. Official Visual Self-Refine example: https://github.com/madaan/self-refine/blob/main/colabs/Visual-Self-Refine-GPT4V.ipynb.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Weakness 4 and Question 4

W4 & Q4. Evaluation protocol and motion fidelity.

PreCoG targets compositional and temporal failures in AIGC workflows with multiple interacting requirements. Many standard VBench prompts are relatively simple, such as “a cat drinking water” and “a bird and a cat” [1]. Of 100 randomly sampled VBench prompts, 83 initial previews were accepted at iteration 0, providing limited coverage of the correction loop under our configuration. We therefore use T2V-CompBench, whose prompts jointly constrain attributes, actions, spatial relationships, interactions, temporal changes, and object counts, more closely reflecting the compositional demands of practical AIGC workflows.

VBench’s video-quality metrics remain useful for assessing general visual and temporal properties on these samples. Applying them to task-specific videos follows prior practice in SVI [2], Frame-wise Conditioning Adaptation [3], and DreamStyle [4]. We report the equal-weight mean of six VBench quality dimensions, excluding temporal flickering, on videos generated from T2V-CompBench prompts to complement compositional evaluation.

We acknowledge that PreCoG’s dynamic degree decreases from 81.25 to 78.12. This indicates that fewer generated videos exceed VBench’s optical-flow thresholds; it does not, by itself, establish whether the motion changes improve or impair adherence to the requested actions. Our correction mechanism may favor preserving content outside the targeted edit, potentially trading some motion intensity for more controlled correction. We therefore do not interpret the dynamic-degree results as evidence that motion is unaffected.

To assess whether the generated motion satisfies the prompt, we additionally evaluate Video-Bench’s Action Consistency [5], which measures whether specified actions are accurately and completely executed.

MethodAction Consistency (1-3, higher is better)
Wan2.2 direct generation2.216
GENMAC2.188
PreCoG2.344

PreCoG achieves higher action consistency despite its lower dynamic degree. These results prove the prompt-relative action fidelity.

References

[1] VBench official prompt suite. Example prompts from subject consistency and multiple objects: https://github.com/Vchitect/VBench/blob/master/prompts/prompts_per_dimension/subject_consistency.txt and https://github.com/Vchitect/VBench/blob/master/prompts/prompts_per_dimension/multiple_objects.txt.

[2] Wuyang Li et al. Stable Video Infinity: Infinite-Length Video Generation with Error Recycling. ICLR, 2026.

[3] Zheyuan Liu et al. Frame-wise Conditioning Adaptation for Fine-Tuning Diffusion Models in Text-to-Video Prediction. TMLR, 2025.

[4] Mengtian Li et al. DreamStyle: A Unified Framework for Video Stylization. CVPR, 2026.

[5] Hui Han et al. Video-Bench: Human-Aligned Video Generation Benchmark. CVPR, 2025.

Reviewer_6L1YOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents an iterative text-to-video generation approach, which reuses the existing caches, i.e., PreCoG. PreCoG consists of two modules, i.e., PreQA and PreEdit. PreQA generates corrective conditions for the following generations and PreEdit edits caches to generate the final video. The authors exploit Wan2.2-T2V-A14B and T2V-CompBench, VBench, and VideoScore2 in the experimentation. The idea of using cached trajectories is interesting while there are some points to improve:

  1. The paper is hard to follow and some important terms can be explain, e.g., CFG etc.
  2. The denoising steps for editing may be different for different models.
  3. There is a strong assumption of the prompt, i.e., the prompt is clear and contains enough details for the video generation.
Critical strengths
  1. The idea of reusing cached trajectories is interesting for video generation.
  2. The conterfactual edit is useful to avoid hallucination
  3. The experimental results are interesting.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper is hard to follow and some important terms can be explain, e.g., CFG etc.
  2. The denoising steps for editing may be different for different models.
  3. There is a strong assumption of the prompt, i.e., the prompt is clear and contains enough details for the video generation.
  4. The experiments are conducted on Wan2.2, and other recent models, e.g., Minimax-H3, can be used. In addition, the models with shorter steps may be analyzed, which may be exploited in real usecases.
Questions for authors
  1. What will be the edit steps for the models with fewer steps, e.g., 5 steps or 6 steps, or even 1 steps.
  2. What will be the results on Minimax-H3?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Weakness 1, Weakness 2 and Question 1

We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful review and constructive feedback.

W1. Clarity and terminology. Classifier-free guidance We appreciate the reviewer's suggestion to make the terminology more accessible. Classifier-free guidance (CFG) combines conditional and unconditional predictions to strengthen prompt adherence during diffusion sampling [1]. We have clarified this terminology and its role in PreEdit in the revised manuscript. At each sampling step, it combines the model's text-conditioned and unconditional predictions by amplifying their difference. The guidance scale controls this amplification, with stronger guidance generally encouraging closer prompt adherence, potentially at the cost of sample diversity. In PreEdit, the target and counterfactual predictions are evaluated at the same latent state and timestep using the same guidance scale and unconditional prediction, so the shared unconditional term cancels when their difference is taken. Solver state refers to the numerical sampler's internal information, including its current step and the historical model predictions used by multistep solvers such as UniPC [2]. We cache this information alongside latent states to support subsequent continuation.

W2 & Q1. Backbone-dependent sampling and adaptation on few-step, chunked video models. PreCoG does not require identifying a unique, model specific denoising step before the framework can be used. Its configurable preview length and editing window allow users to balance computational efficiency and correction quality according to their application needs. Different settings can provide different trade-offs, without requiring a single optimal step configuration for each backbone

We demonstrate this adaptation on Helios-Distilled [3], which autoregressively generates consecutive short chunks under a single prompt. Its default three-stage spatial-pyramid schedule uses 2–2–2 steps per chunk. We construct previews using 2–1–1 steps, retaining the first-stage sampling budget while completing each subsequent stage in one step. For the first chunk, we retain Helios’s amplified first-stage budget and use 4–1–1 steps. This produces a full-resolution preview spanning all chunks for VLM assessment against the complete prompt requirements.

In this implementation, stream correction is restricted to the first chunk, after which subsequent chunks are regenerated through Helios’s native continuation process. Because later chunks are conditioned on the generated history, correcting the first chunk changes their conditioning context; reusing their original outputs would retain continuations generated under the previous history. Accordingly, cache reuse is confined to the shared trajectory of the first chunk, while subsequent chunks are regenerated conditioned on the corrected history. This differs from Wan2.2’s joint generation of the complete clip.

The results below demonstrate that PreCoG remains effective in this few-step setting. Strictly one-step generators provide no intermediate denoising trajectory to cache, edit, and resume, and therefore fall outside the scope of PreCoG’s current trajectory-based correction.

MethodVBench ↑ΔT2V-Comp. ↑ΔVS2 ↑ΔTime (s) ↓Ratio
Direct generation81.5540.00037.5150.0003.1660.00031.7501.000×
VSR81.927+0.37347.094+9.5793.481+0.314278.1208.759×
GENMAC80.324−1.23047.571+10.0563.309+0.142577.83018.199×
PreCoG82.540+0.98647.790+10.2753.524+0.442234.5007.386×

References

[1] Jonathan Ho and Tim Salimans. Classifier-Free Diffusion Guidance. arXiv:2207.12598, 2022.

[2] Wenliang Zhao et al. UniPC: A Unified Predictor-Corrector Framework for Fast Sampling of Diffusion Models. NeurIPS, 2023.

[3] Shenghai Yuan, Yuanyang Yin, Zongjian Li, Xinwei Huang, Xiao Yang, and Li Yuan. Helios: Real Real-Time Long Video Generation Model. arXiv:2603.04379, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Weakness 3, Weakness 4 and Question 2

W3. Prompt ambiguity and simple requests. Prompt ambiguity reflects a gap between a user's intent and its linguistic expression: the same wording may correspond to multiple plausible user intentions. Given only that wording, existing agentic video correction pipelines cannot uniquely identify which intention the user actually holds. Their generation and assessment instead depend on the semantic interpretations adopted by the underlying video model and VLM. This is a shared challenge across existing pipelines, rather than a limitation specific to PreCoG's correction design.

Resolving such ambiguity requires additional user context. For example, an upstream personalized agent could use memory of the user's language habits and preferences, or seek clarification, to translate the request into a more explicit prompt before passing it to an agentic video generation pipeline. This provides a complementary layer of intent grounding that can be combined with existing correction methods, including PreCoG.

For simple but unambiguous requests, the initial preview may already satisfy the expressed requirements. PreCoG then accepts it at iteration 0 and proceeds to final rendering using the cached shared trajectory, without correction rounds. The additional preview-stage overhead is quantified below.

ComponentTime (s)Additional cost relative to direct generation
Direct full generation893.2Reference
One passing PreQA assessment5.2+0.6%
Four additional preview-completion steps110.0+12.3%
Additional preview decoding and saving25.9+2.9%
Total additional preview-stage cost141.1+15.8%

Thus, the additional preview-stage cost is moderate relative to full generation, while simple prompts that already pass do not incur correction rounds.

W4 & Q2. Evaluation on MiniMax-H3. Following the reviewer's suggestion, we have now added a comparison on MiniMax-H3 against direct generation, VSR, and GENMAC in Appendix I, Table 7. Metric definitions follow Table 1.

Since MiniMax-H3 is CFG-distilled, we apply correction directly to its conditional sampling trajectory without a separate unconditional branch. At the edited state z=zi,kedit\mathbf z=\mathbf z_{i,k}^{\mathrm{edit}}, let fH3f_{\mathrm{H3}} denote H3's native conditional velocity prediction. We use

\mathbf v_{i,k}^{\mathrm{cf}}=f_{\mathrm{H3}}(\mathbf z,t_k,P_i^{\mathrm{cf}}),$$ $$\mathbf d_{i,k}=\mathbf v_{i,k}^{\mathrm{tar}}-\mathbf v_k^{\mathrm{src}},\qquad \mathbf a_{i,k}=\mathbf v_{i,k}^{\mathrm{tar}}-\mathbf v_{i,k}^{\mathrm{cf}}.$$ Here $\mathbf v_k^{\mathrm{src}}$ is reused from the cached source trajectory. The blockwise soft projection and displacement update remain unchanged. | Method | VBench ↑ | Δ | T2V-Comp. ↑ | Δ | VS2 ↑ | Δ | Time (s) ↓ | Ratio | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | Direct generation | 83.894 | 0.000 | 55.241 | 0.000 | 3.497 | 0.000 | **174.276** | 1.000× | | VSR | 83.105 | −0.788 | 56.713 | +1.473 | **3.942** | +0.446 | 739.995 | 4.246× | | GENMAC | 84.208 | +0.314 | 50.723 | −4.517 | 3.867 | +0.370 | 902.154 | 5.177× | | **PreCoG** | **84.310** | **+0.416** | **57.120** | **+1.879** | 3.914 | +0.417 | 715.457 | 4.105× | Δ denotes the absolute change from direct generation; time ratios are normalized to direct generation. We attribute PreCoG's smaller relative efficiency advantage on MiniMax-H3 to the higher relative forward-pass overhead of counterfactual correction under CFG-distilled sampling, and the larger share of runtime occupied by VLM assessment given H3's faster native inference. Nevertheless, PreCoG achieves the highest VBench and T2V-Comp. scores, improves all three metrics over direct generation, and runs faster than VSR and GENMAC.
Reviewer_6L1YOpenReview ↗

Response to rebuttal

Thank you for your reply, I raised my score.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

We thank all three reviewers for their constructive feedback and helpful discussions. Our discussion and additional experiments have addressed the following concerns:

  1. Correction effectiveness and content preservation. Our new human study shows that PreCoG resolves the most original problems (89.11%) and introduces the fewest new problems (8.86%), outperforming VSR and GENMAC on both criteria. Independent VLM evaluation shows the same trend.

  2. Preview reliability after correction. Under the deployed Qwen3.8-27B evaluator, 93.15% of accepted edited previews also yield accepted full renders, with nearly identical rates across the evaluated correction rounds. This supports preview-based assessment while quantifying the remaining risk of premature acceptance.

  3. Generality across backbones. New comparisons on MiniMax-H3 and Helios-Distilled cover CFG-distilled and few-step autoregressive generation. PreCoG leads the reported VBench quality aggregate and T2V-CompBench score on MiniMax-H3, and all three metrics on Helios-Distilled at 0.84× VSR’s runtime and 0.41× GENMAC’s runtime.

  4. Prompt-relative action fidelity. Additional Video-Bench evaluation shows higher Action Consistency for PreCoG (2.344) than direct generation (2.216) and GENMAC (2.188), supporting better execution of requested actions despite the observed reduction in dynamic degree.

PreCoG contributes a training-free framework for generation-time video correction, combining low-cost preview diagnosis through PreQA with counterfactual-guided editing of cached trajectories through PreEdit. By reusing computation and fully rendering only the selected candidate, this design enables efficient, targeted correction while limiting disruption to already correct content.

Best Regards, Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.