acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

UniOPSD: Unifying Outcome and Hindsight Feedback for Agentic Reinforcement Learning

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Reinforcement learning has become an effective approach to training language model agents, but sparse and delayed outcome rewards provide limited guidance for credit assignment across long interaction sequences. Recent work on on-policy self-distillation (OPSD) offers complementary supervision by evaluating a policy's sampled responses under privileged training-time context. However, our diagnostics show that positive average agreement between outcome and hindsight feedback coexists with substantial local disagreement, raising the question of how to allocate influence between them at each decision. We introduce UniOPSD (Unified On-Policy Self-Distillation), which unifies these feedback sources through adaptive local credit arbitration. UniOPSD constructs comparable credit estimates from environmental returns and successful-peer hindsight at shared interaction anchors. Historical agreement determines the global mixing level, while current signal availability and relative precision adjust each source's influence at individual decisions. The episode-level outcome contribution is retained, and bounded token modulation refines the fused step credit for policy optimization. With Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct and Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct, UniOPSD achieves ALFWorld success rates of and , WebShop success rates of and , and Search-QA aggregate accuracies of and , respectively. On 3B WebShop, UniOPSD improves over SDAR by percentage points. We will open-source the code upon acceptance.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Agentic Reinforcement Learning, On-Policy Self-Distillation, Credit Assignment

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_RevmOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how to combine two step-level credit signals in agentic RL: GiGPO's outcome-based step advantage and a hindsight signal from on-policy self-distillation, where the policy rescores its own response given a successful peer's actions. Observing that the two signals are positively correlated on average but often disagree locally, the authors propose UniOPSD. A running correlation between the signals sets a global mixing weight, per-row precision proxies adjust it, and a bounded token modulation is applied on top. Experiments cover ALFWorld, WebShop and Search-QA with Qwen2.5-3B and 7B.

Critical strengths

The paper is clearly written and unusually careful about the limits of each design choice. The diagnostics on agreement, disagreement and coverage between the two signals are informative.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The central mechanism is not shown to matter. With u = 0.5 as used in all experiments, Eq. (7) simplifies exactly to c̄ = 1 − 2ρ̂², since the denominator is always 0.25. The frozen-correlation variant (ρ0 = 0.25) gives c̄ = 0.875. The observed mean correlations on ALFWorld and WebShop (0.27 to 0.32) give c̄ between about 0.80 and 0.85 before shrinkage, and shrinkage moves them closer to 0.875. So the adaptive rule and the frozen control differ by a few percent in global weight, and only on the 10% to 33% of rows where both signals exist. On WebShop the all-row mean outcome weight is already 0.976. It is hard to see how this difference produces the 1.6 to 3.1 point gaps in Table 2. Also, the "w/o teacher" ablation removes the hindsight branch and token modulation together, so the gain over GiGPO cannot be attributed to the arbitration rule rather than simply adding hindsight credit.

  2. The method does not outperform existing approaches. On ALFWorld it is below the strongest baseline at both scales (82.8 vs SDAR's 84.4 for 3B, 83.6 vs StepOPSD's 88.4 for 7B). On 7B WebShop it is below SDAR (82.0 vs 82.8), and on Search-QA it leads by under one point. The only clear gain is 3B WebShop. Existing fixed-weight combinations such as SDAR and StepOPSD therefore already handle this setting at least as well, which weakens the case that adaptive arbitration is needed.

  3. The reported numbers are peak values from online validation with 128 episodes. For example, 3B ALFWorld is reported at 82.8 (update 125) while the final checkpoint is 75.0. With this protocol, differences of a few points are not reliable, which matters because nearly all the comparisons above are within that range.

Questions for authors
  1. Can you compare UniOPSD with GiGPO plus hindsight credit and token modulation using a fixed mixing weight, for several values of c (e.g. 0.7, 0.8, 0.9)? This is the direct test of whether adaptive arbitration helps.

  2. Please report results from a fixed final checkpoint on the full evaluation split for all methods, and state whether the baselines in Table 1 were rerun or taken from prior papers.

  3. Given that c̄ = 1 − 2ρ̂² at u = 0.5, what is the actual range of c̄ during training on each benchmark, and how does it compare with the frozen variant's 0.875?

2 comments

The authors did not provide any response during the rebuttal phase, so I am maintaining my score.

We sincerely thank you for your careful review and constructive feedback, and we apologize for not responding during the rebuttal period. We greatly appreciate the time and effort you have devoted to evaluating our work. We will carefully consider your suggestions and revise the manuscript accordingly before our next submission. Thank you again for your valuable input. We also wish you every success in your research and future submissions!

Reviewer_tVBbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper focuses on the problem of potentially conflicting evaluations of the same decision from outcome-based feedback and successful-peer hindsight feedback when combining RL with OPSD. To address this problem, the authors propose UniOPSD, building on GiGPO. Specifically, UniOPSD extends GiGPO's episode-level and step-level credit assignment by using a frozen behavior policy to compute the difference in log-probabilities of sampled actions with and without a successful trajectory as privileged context. This difference is then processed through anchor-wise centering and scale matching to obtain hindsight step credit. To resolve conflicts between outcome credit and hindsight credit, UniOPSD uses historical Pearson correlation to determine the global mixing tendency of the two credit signals, and further adjusts the fusion weight for each decision based on signal availability and relative precision at the current anchor.

The authors evaluate UniOPSD and multiple baselines on three types of tasks: ALFWorld, WebShop, and Search-QA, using Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct and Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct as backbones. UniOPSD achieves some improvements over GiGPO.

Critical strengths

Strength 1: The problem addressed in this paper is of strong practical relevance. Conflicts between multiple credit signals are common in many settings, especially when combining RL with OPSD. The paper also provides some concrete experimental evidence showing that this problem indeed exists, which provides strong motivation for the proposed work.

Strength 2: The proposed idea of using both historical and current information to assess credit reliability and dynamically adjust the weights of different credit sources provides useful insights and directions for future research on resolving conflicts between multiple credit signals.

Strength 3: The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive, covering multiple agent settings and comparing against most mainstream RL or OPSD methods. UniOPSD also achieves some improvements over GiGPO.

Critical weaknesses

Weakness 1: The credit arbitration rule has limited justification, and some potential systematic biases in hindsight supervision are not systematically considered or addressed.

  • Equation (5) defines outcome precision in an inverse-variance form based on returns within an anchor, assuming that higher variance indicates less reliable outcome credit. However, different trajectories within the same anchor may take different actions. Therefore, a larger return variance could simply reflect genuinely different returns associated with different actions, rather than indicating that outcome credit is unreliable.
  • Equations (6)–(8) use historical Pearson correlation to determine the global mixing tendency. However, even if the two signals have shown similar overall trends in the past, I do not think this guarantees that hindsight credit provides reliable evaluations of current actions. This is because the reliability of hindsight credit depends heavily on the policy and the current privileged context. The current privileged context changes frequently throughout training and is unrelated to the historical context.

Weakness 2: UniOPSD shows only limited improvements over strong baselines.

  • Although UniOPSD achieves some improvements over GiGPO, its advantage over the strongest existing baselines is neither consistent nor particularly clear. Across the six main benchmark-model configurations, UniOPSD achieves the best result in only three. On Search-QA, its improvements over the strongest baseline are only 0.7 and 0.8 percentage points for the two model sizes, respectively, while it still falls behind existing methods in some ALFWorld and WebShop settings.
Questions for authors

Q1. On the Statistical Meaning of Outcome Precision (Eq. 5)

Could the authors further explain why return variance across different actions within the same anchor can be interpreted as estimation uncertainty in outcome-based step credit? Different actions may inherently have different expected returns, so higher variance does not necessarily imply lower credit reliability. Is there any experimental or theoretical evidence to support this interpretation?

Q2. On Historical Correlation and Systematic Hindsight Bias (Eqs. 6–8)

When the privileged context is constantly changing, can the historical overall correlation between outcome and hindsight credit really serve as a reasonably stable indicator of the reliability of hindsight feedback for the current decision?

In particular, a successful-peer trajectory used as privileged context may contain redundant or unnecessary actions, and the model could develop a stable but incorrect preference for these actions because of the privileged context. Could the authors explain how the existing correlation-guided and precision-guided weighting mechanisms identify or mitigate this kind of action-dependent systematic bias?

Reviewer_b5qGOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

UniOPSD combines outcome-based and hindsight-based feedback for agentic RL. It constructs two step-credit signals at shared interaction anchors. Historical correlation sets the global mixing level. Local availability and precision proxies adjust each decision’s weight. Bounded token modulation further refines the update. Experiments cover three agent domains with 3B and 7B models.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper identifies a concrete feedback-fusion problem. Table 7 shows local disagreement despite positive average correlation between outcome and hindsight credit. This supports studying their influence separately rather than treating them as interchangeable supervision.

  2. The component comparisons show practical promise. UniOPSD outperforms GiGPO, inverse-variance fusion, and frozen-correlation fusion across all six settings in Table 2. It also improves 3B WebShop success by 7 points over SDAR.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The hindsight signal is insufficiently justified. A successful peer may not provide valid guidance for the failed trajectory’s current state. Section 4.1 selects the first successful peer without ablations. Singleton anchors and all-failure groups also limit its ability to supply missing credit.

  2. The arbitration mechanism lacks validation. Table 7 shows disagreement, not successful conflict resolution. Proposition 1 gives only basic algebraic properties. Table 2 lacks separate fusion/token-modulation controls and tuned constant mixing. Tables 1–2 also omit cross-seed uncertainty.

Questions for authors
  1. Please explain the link between the problem and the method. Why should successful-peer log-probability gaps resolve uncertain local credit? Why should historical correlation and local variance identify which signal to trust? Please provide evidence for both assumptions.

  2. Section 4.1 selects the first successful peer. How sensitive is hindsight credit to this choice? Please compare alternative peers and explain how the method handles singleton anchors and all-failure groups.

  3. Table 7 shows disagreement, but not successful conflict resolution. What fraction involves opposing nonzero signs? Does arbitration favor the signal that better predicts held-out continuation returns?

  4. Why is Proposition 1 needed beyond stating basic properties of averaging and clipping? Please explain how it informs the method and evaluate its separate fusion and token-modulation controls in Table 2, alongside tuned constant mixing.

  5. Please report multi-seed mean ± SD for Tables 1–2. Please also clarify checkpoint selection, baseline provenance, and the Search-QA aggregation rule.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.