- Rating
- 3(−1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies when pipeline guidance should be retained when distilling multi-agent workflows into directly executable single-agent skills. It distinguishes capability resources from pipeline guidance and introduces Behavior-Outcome Freedom, a diagnostic intended to guide this retention decision. The proposed AdaSkill framework preserves validated capabilities, removes runtime orchestration, and uses a threshold calibrated on development interventions to decide whether to retain pipeline guidance. The authors present a candidate-conditional theoretical account, analyze 16 matched interventions and 15 atomic treatments, and evaluate performance and latency across 11 datasets spanning four task families. They also report workflow-excluded construction experiments to evaluate the calibrated policy separately from the mechanism analysis.
Critical strengths
- A useful distinction between capabilities and workflow constraints.
The paper asks which parts of a multi-agent workflow should survive conversion into a single-agent skill. It separates tools and declarative knowledge from pipeline rules and runtime orchestration (Sections 3.1 and 3.4). This is a useful way to frame the problem. Keeping useful resources does not require keeping every ordering rule or decision gate. The distinction gives a concrete design principle for building lower-overhead agents.
- An experimental design aimed at isolating the role of pipeline guidance.
The paper includes component ablations and Full-versus-Discard comparisons that hold tools, knowledge, the evaluator, and the execution budget fixed (Sections 4.3–4.4). It also tests threshold selection with the target workflow regime excluded, then executes the resulting skills (Section 4.5). These controls are relevant to the central question and go beyond an end-to-end performance comparison. The evaluation covers four task families and reports both performance and deployment overhead.
Critical weaknesses
My only concern is the internal consistency of the reported data and diagnostic statistics. I have two specific concerns below. If the authors cannot provide a convincing explanation supported by the underlying results, I may recommend rejection with a rating of 1 (Clear rejection).
- The binary score variances in Table 4 do not match the stated six-run protocol.
Section B.3 (p. 20, lines 1059–1061 and 1073) states that each diagnostic item is run six times and that BIRD has no execution failures. Table 4 (p. 23, lines 1195–1215) reports two identifiable BIRD SRR items with a mean score variance of 0.250. Section B.2 defines SRR as a binary score.
With k successes in six runs, the usual sample variance is k(6-k)/30. For an item with varying scores, the possible values are 0.1667, 0.2667, and 0.3000. The mean over two such items can only be 0.1667, 0.2167, 0.2333, 0.2667, 0.2833, or 0.3000. None rounds to 0.250. Using population variance does not explain the whole table either: binary population variance cannot exceed 0.25, but BIRD EX is 0.275 and CE Real MSA is 0.300.
Please clarify the effective run counts, variance denominator, and aggregation rule for each row. Please provide the six raw binary scores for each of the two BIRD SRR items and the code used to produce Table 4.
- The CE Real MSA variance in Table 4 conflicts with the Freedom range in Table 11 under the stated definitions.
Table 4 reports five valid CE Real MSA diagnostic items, six runs per item, and a mean score variance of 0.300. Table 11 (p. 30) gives the corresponding output-space Freedom range as [0.000, 0.592]. The relevant definitions appear in Equation (2), Section B.2, and Table 3.
For six binary scores, the maximum sample variance is 0.300. It occurs only with three correct and three incorrect runs. The reported mean therefore requires this split for all five items, under the stated protocol and rounding precision.
MSA checks agreement with one reference method label. The canonical output distance checks whether two method labels differ. Across the 15 distinct run pairs, nine correct–incorrect pairs have different scores. At most 12 pairs can have different method labels, since the three correct runs share the reference label.
Let U indicate different method labels and V indicate different scores. Then P(V=1)=0.6, P(U=1)<=0.8, and V=1 implies U=1. For these binary variables, Spearman correlation equals Pearson correlation. The minimum correlation is sqrt[(0.60.2)/(0.80.4)] = 0.6124. Freedom is therefore at most 1-0.6124 = 0.3876, or 0.388 after rounding. This is below the reported maximum of 0.592.
This calculation assumes six runs per item, binary MSA, one reference method label, binary label-distance, and the 15 distinct non-diagonal pairs. If the implementation differs, please explain the difference. Please provide the per-run method labels, binary scores, effective run counts, and per-item Freedom values for these five items. If corrections are needed, please also check whether they affect the reported correlations, threshold calibration, and routing conclusions.
These are requests to resolve statistical inconsistencies, not allegations of data fabrication. Table-entry errors, mismatched result versions, or undocumented implementation choices could explain them. The run-level records are needed to establish which explanation applies.
Questions for authors
-
How was the BIRD SRR mean score variance of 0.250 in Table 4 calculated? Under the stated six-run protocol, the mean sample variance over two score-varying binary items cannot take this value. Please provide the six raw scores for each item, the variance denominator, and the aggregation code. Were any runs excluded, or were different sampling budgets used?
-
Were the CE Real MSA entries in Tables 4 and 11 computed from the same runs? Under the stated definitions, a mean sample variance of 0.300 requires three correct and three incorrect runs for each item. This limits output-space Freedom to approximately 0.388, below the reported maximum of 0.592. Please provide the per-run method labels and scores, and explain any differences in run counts, distance definitions, or data versions.
-
How does AdaSkill account for differences between candidate pipelines on the same task? Freedom is measured from the Base Agent before skill construction. Section 3.3 also notes that candidates with the same Freedom can have opposite effects. If two qualified source pipelines share the same task, metric, and diagnostic setup, would AdaSkill give both the same retention decision? What information allows the method to distinguish a helpful pipeline from a harmful one in this setting?
-
How are conflicting module decisions handled when constructing one skill? For example, CE retains method-selection guidance but discards numerical-estimation guidance. However, method selection also affects numerical error. Could you show a concrete example of how a source rule is assigned, retained, or removed when it affects both metrics? What determines which instruction takes priority if the retained guidance constrains a decision assigned to the discard route?
6 comments
Official Response to Reviewer bM8q (2/2)
[Q3] Distinguishing Candidate Pipelines on the Same Task
Yes. Two qualified pipelines on the same task and metric receive the same routing decision from . AdaSkill does not estimate candidate-specific direction , providing best-in-class average value rather than individual-candidate safety.
- What decides (whether to constrain). Computed on Base Agent runs before synthesis, measures whether contracting behavior toward successful anchors preserves () or reverses () outcome-rank order. As an effect modifier rather than a candidate-lift estimator, assigns all candidates on the same task-metric module the same
Retain/Discarddecision. - What qualification decides (admissibility, Section 3.1). AdaSkill checks only whether a source workflow is published, high-performing on the same objective, clause-aligned to scored decisions, and interface-compatible (all fixed prior to target evaluation). This yields a grounded structural proposal, not a positive-transfer guarantee.
- What lies outside scope (). Realized direction and strength () are unestimated and excluded from converter inputs (as Section 3.3 notes, candidates sharing can have opposite alignment). With a pre-frozen threshold, routing attains best-in-class average value over calibrated structural units rather than individual safety (Prop. 3.1; Appendix A.8), while surviving errors are diagnosed via execution evidence (Figure 10). We will state this boundary explicitly in Section 3.3.
[Q4] Handling Conflicting Module Decisions in a Single Skill
Conflicting module decisions are resolved when generating SKILL.md by assigning each source rule to the metric module that scores the decision step it directly controls, not by runtime priority arbitration. A Retain module fixes the choice for its own step, while a Discard module omits source rules for downstream steps instead of adding opposing directives (Section C.2), so the two never conflict.
- Concrete assignment and removal in CAIS.
rule_based_select_methodand estimator-validity checks (such as the IV relevance test; Appendix F.1) govern estimator selection and are retained as metric-scoped prose inSKILL.mdunder MSA (Retain, Figure 16, e.g., forbidding matching/PSM on RCTs and selecting OLS or IV). Conversely, clauses governing post-selection tuning, support-gap heuristics, and F04 backtracking control numerical estimation and are removed under MRE (Discard, Figure 10), leaving covariate choice unconstrained once the estimator is chosen while keeping tool advisory outputs available on both routes. - Scope of claims on cross-metric coupling. Assigning rules by scored decision step does not eliminate cross-metric coupling, as choosing the right method does not determine numerical accuracy alone (captured by in Eq. 3; e.g., in Figure 10, AdaSkill and Full both select IV yet produce estimates of
4049.36versus1469.96under different covariates). We claim no theoretical optimality for hybrid routing (Appendix A.8), and Table 8's gains over Full (MSA89.7/96.8versus84.6/90.3; MRE23.1/15.9/4.3versus26.3/17.3/7.6) reflect the empirical effect of the composed skill as a whole.
Thank you for the clarification
Thank you for the detailed response and for providing the raw records and recomputation code. The five-run records explain the BIRD SRR variance of 0.250 and the CE Real MSA Freedom range of [0, 0.592]. These resolve my two original concerns about the internal consistency of Tables 4 and 11. Please update the run counts and related pair counts consistently throughout the paper.
I have one follow-up question about MSA scoring. The supplementary README notes that some Synthetic reference labels (e.g., iv_encouragement and did_twfe) differ from the labels requested in the diagnostic prompt (iv and did), and the diagnostic code compares the strings directly. I understand that Synthetic MSA is excluded from the CE MSA routing coordinate. Could you clarify whether the final Synthetic MSA evaluation uses a label mapping, and whether correcting this mismatch would change any reported results or conclusions?
Official Response to Reviewer bM8q (1/2)
We sincerely thank Reviewer bM8q for the remarkably statistical audit and for recognizing the value of our capabilities-vs-constraints distinction and experimental controls.
[W1, W2, Q1, Q2] Resolution of Statistical Discrepancies in Tables 4 and 11
Both discrepancies come from a text typo in Sections 4.6, B.3, and C.1, which mistakenly reported N=6 (from the Section C.5 sweep) instead of the actual n=5 runs executed. Because all tables and routing decisions were computed directly from the n=5 raw logs, every reported number reproduces identically and zero results change.
Variance and Aggregation Rule. The main diagnostic batch runs n=5 trials per item (M=10 for T2SQL, M=6 for CE). For each identifiable item (where behavior and score distances vary across the 5 runs), we compute the unbiased sample variance with Bessel's correction (ddof=1, denominator n−1=4) and average across the Kout identifiable items. With n=5 and k successes, binary sample variance is k(5−k)/20, which equals 0.200 for k∈{1,4} and 0.300 for k∈{2,3}.
Under n=5, all discrepancies resolve directly:
1. Table 4 Binary Score Variances (BIRD SRR, BIRD EX, Spider EX)
q758/q1368[1,1,1,1,0]/[1,1,1,0,0]0.200/0.300q1454/q538/q1195/q337[0,0,0,0,1]/[1,1,0,0,1]/[1,1,0,0,1]/[1,0,0,0,1]0.200/0.300/0.300/0.300q91/q51[1,0,0,0,0]/[0,0,1,1,0]0.200/0.300Run exclusions. Zero runs were excluded for CE or BIRD. In Spider, 3 of 5 runs on
q25timed out and the remaining 2 valid runs both scored1(zero variance), soq25was non-identifiable.2. CE Real MSA Variance (Table 4) vs. Freedom Range (Table 11)
Tables 4 and 11 were computed from the exact same n=5 runs. Your bound Fout≤0.388 is exact for n=6. Under n=5 ((25)=10 pairs), a variance of 0.300 occurs when k=2 or k=3. When k=2 (2 correct runs sharing the reference label, and 3 incorrect runs with three distinct wrong labels), there are 6 score-differing pairs (P(V=1)=0.6) and 9 label-differing pairs (P(U=1)=0.9). Your formula yields ρ=(0.6×0.1)/(0.9×0.4)=0.4082 and Fout=1−ρ=0.592 (item
q25below).q26[iv]rdd, iv, iv, rdd, ols0,1,1,0,00.3000.388q5[ols]ols, ols, matching, ols, matching1,1,0,1,00.3000.000q15[matching]ols, matching, ols, matching, matching0,1,0,1,10.3000.000q25[iv]rdd, iv, iv, ols, matching0,1,1,0,00.300q11[did]did, did, ols, did, matching1,1,0,1,00.3000.198q10[rdd]rdd, rdd, rdd, rdd, rdd1,1,1,1,10.000Over the 5 identifiable items, mean variance is 0.300 (Table 4), mean Fout is 0.236 (Tables 7 and 11), and the range is [0.000, 0.592] (Table 11). The family-level CE MSA routing input (0.167, Section 4.5) averages Textbook (
0.098) and Real (0.236).3. Impact on Results and Sensitivity Sweep (N∈[4,20])
Zero downstream numbers change because all reported results already used this n=5 batch. In our separate 20×20 sweep on CE Real (Section C.5 and Figure 9), we executed 20 runs per item and subsampled N without replacement (
audit/mn_sweep.py). Because F stabilizes once N≥5 (shifting by only0.009on MSA and0.000on MRE between N=5 and N=6), the n=5 main batch required no re-execution. We will update the run-count text in Sections 4.6, B.3, and C.1 from 6 to 5.4. Raw Records and Code for Verification (
supplementary.zip)raw/A_batch1_n5/andraw/C_budget_sweep_ce_real_n20/contain the time-stamped run directories (2026-04-01) withresults.jsonand full trajectory logs.audit/per_run_records.csvandaudit/per_item_audit.csvlist all per-run method labels, SQL queries, raw scores, variances, and F values.audit/recompute_from_raw.pyandaudit/mn_sweep.pyrecompute Tables 4 and 11 and the N-sweep table directly from the raw JSON logs with 100% agreement.