- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript investigates the effectiveness of data augmentation and ImageNet-pretrained weights for remote sensing scene classification. Although the experiments demonstrate that these techniques can improve classification performance, the manuscript offers little, if any, original contribution. The findings largely reiterate well-established knowledge in both the machine learning and remote sensing communities. The work falls substantially short of the novelty and scientific contribution expected of a research article.
Critical strengths
The manuscript presents a series of straightforward experiments illustrating the effectiveness of data augmentation and pretrained weights for remote sensing scene classification. Based on experimental results from four datasets, the authors further propose a framework for selecting data augmentation strategies. However, the generalizability of this framework has not been established through evaluation on larger or more diverse datasets.
Critical weaknesses
- Lack of novelty and scientific contribution. The manuscript reads more like a course assignment report than an original research article. Its primary findings, data augmentation and ImageNet pretraining benefit remote sensing scene classification, have been widely recognized and extensively investigated in the existing literature. Reconfirming these established observations through additional experiments does not, by itself, constitute a meaningful scientific contribution.
- Limited generalizability of the proposed augmentation selection framework. The proposed framework appears to be derived specifically from the four datasets considered in this study. Its applicability beyond these datasets remains unclear, as no experiments are conducted on additional, larger-scale, or more recent benchmarks. Consequently, there is insufficient evidence to support its general applicability or practical value.
- Potentially fabricated references. Some references in the manuscript appear questionable and may not correspond to verifiable publications. Such as [5],[14],[18].
Questions for authors
The manuscript lacks a substantive original contribution, primarily reproduces findings that are already well established, and provides insufficient evidence for the generalizability of its proposed framework. The concerns regarding potentially unverifiable references further undermine confidence in the scholarly rigor of the work. These issues are fundamental rather than matters that can be adequately addressed through a routine rebuttal.