- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper builds on Nasr-Esfahany & Kiciman 2023 and studies the increase in loss function values after rotating the initial distributions. It then studies the effect of rotating initial noise distribution on single-cell editor's predictions.
Critical strengths
- Corrollary 1 is neat, relating the transport map coming from OT and and CFM by inverting the covariance of the initial noise . May consider move to body.
- Paper did not overstate results.
Critical weaknesses
- Dense Writing section 4.1, 4.2 and 5, can't follow what's going on.
- I believe the paper is AI written which is fine and the authors acknowledged AI usage. But the sentences are filled with 'it', 'that', 'they', 'both' without out spelling out what each means. One looses track of the meaning easily. Also the abstract is dense and wordy.
- I don't see clearly the paper's contribution over Nasr-Esfahany & Kiciman 2023.
Questions for authors
- Give a simple example with visualizations and write in simplest words what is the question the paper is addressing. I know sec 4.1 is the proof-of-concept example, but it's hard to read with unclear words such as 'both arms' and 'the family' and so on. Also give clear visualization of the setup of the example.
- The intro needs significant rewritting. State what community and what audience would care about the work. How is this work useful for respective fields. For example, why would a single-cell biologist care about section 5. Do you have a pipeline that biologists can adapt to their work?
- Per weakness 3.
- As far as I understand, most of the results looks neutral and doesn't look like one can draw conclusions from them?