- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This papers introduces a new method for 3D surface mesh deformation. The method builds upon cage-based deformation and their associated cage coordinates, which generalize barycentric coordinates to polyhedron. The key idea in the paper is to use a second cage, with encloses to standard one, to scaffold the deformation and obtain better metric on the final surface deformation. The paper uses Mean Value Coordinates as the deformation engine, and The paper is evaluated on various tasks, including neural cages, aerodynamic shape optimization and robot morphology co-design. Each use case report marginal to significant gain in various metrics.
Critical strengths
- The paper's core idea is quite simple and effective
- Its computational cost seems reasonable
- The framework could extend to other type of cage coordinates
- Multiple use cases are explored for validation
Critical weaknesses
- It remains unclear how performance gains are maintained for other type of cage coordinates
- A better assessment of the 2-cage system for spiky features and sharp structure - and more generally a qualitative analysis from a geometric point of view - could help
- I cannot assess from the paper whether the method is sensitive to the cage structure. in other words, given two inner cages, with with different vertex density and connectivity, for the same target surface to deform, which criteria makes one better than the other?
- in general, the visuals of the paper do not help evaluating qualitatively the results
Questions for authors
- Are there any foreseeable limitations for application to other cage coordinates, namely green coordinates ?
- Does the method extends to quad and triquad cages and what adaptation would be needed ?
- In the appendices, one limitations worries me a bit (page 15): the non preservation of common translation. This is not a show stopper, but a bit buried in the document and I'd like to understand more what this implies in practice. Particularly for (interactive) design use cases.
4 comments
Dear authors,
Thank you for you revision. It answers my questions.
I understand you do not have a formal criterion for ranking two inner cages, but in practice then, which "principles" did you apply to create them in the reported experiments?
Response to Reviewer taS5
Thank you very much for the follow-up. We are glad the revision answers your questions and enthused by your engagement. In every experiment we followed one principle: the inner cage is never designed for Structural Affinity. We reuse the inner cage of the baseline or of prior work, so CBD and CBD-SA always share the identical inner cage and the comparison isolates the coupling.
- Neural Cages: the inner cage is predicted for each shape by the network, from the published 42-vertex template of Neural Cages, unchanged.
- Aerodynamics: a closed cage that follows the wing's chordwise and spanwise stations, padded slightly around the wing, at the same lattice resolution as the FFD baseline (2×3, 4×6 and 8×12 stations for Small, Medium and Large), so that design-variable counts match FFD.
- Robot co-design: a coarse structured cage around the fingertip (42 vertices).
- Articulated characters (App. A.5): the human cage released with Neural Cages.
In practice, these follow the usual cage-design guidelines: enclose the shape with a small margin, follow its main sections, and give the cage as many handles as the task needs degrees of freedom. Structural Affinity then makes denser cages safer to use, since nearby handles move together rather than independently, which is where its benefit was largest.
Thank you again for your engagement, and we would be very happy to answer any further questions.
Thank you for clarifying.
Response to Reviewer taS5
Thank you for the thoughtful review, and for recognizing that the core idea is simple and effective, that its cost is reasonable, and that the framework could extend to other cage coordinates. Your questions on exactly that extension are answered below and in the new App. A.2.
Structural Affinity uses coordinates in two separate places.
Green coordinates remain fully usable for the mesh deformation itself. For building C, their face-normal terms can be negative, so they would first be clipped or paired with a different overlap measure. This is our analysis rather than an experiment which is discussed in Sec. 7 and App. A.2.
Eq. 2 depends only on the weight vectors, not on the face type. A quad or mixed outer cage needs only polygonal mean-value coordinates; the affinity and the propagation are unchanged (App. A.2).
The denser of two inner cages benefits more from coupling, which intuitively follows from the smoothness-expressiveness tradeoff. We do not yet have a formal criterion for ranking two inner cages.
We agree the original visuals were too thin. The new Fig. 3 shows, for each test pair, the deformed mesh and the final cage of both methods. The meshes reach the target with similar fidelity; the Vanilla NC cages fold over, stretch into spikes and have irregular triangles, while the CBD-SA cages stay compact and evenly triangulated. App. B.7 adds 22 further visual comparisons (Figs. 13–16).
To isolate spikes, we also ran controlled one-handle edits on a 3D fingertip mesh (App. C, Fig. 17). Over 210 edits, CBD inverts mesh triangles in 107 and CBD-SA in 44; in the edit shown, CBD inverts 149 of 5,120 triangles and CBD-SA none. Deep inward presses can still invert triangles under CBD-SA, though far less often than under CBD.
This deserves more visibility. App. A.1 now points to a dedicated explanation in App. A.2 and A.4, and exact handle placement is stated in the method section.
Interactive editing is outside the scope of this paper, which targets optimizer-driven design, but we now describe how Structural Affinity can be applied there (App. A.4).
Thank you again for your thorough evaluation. It has been a pleasure to engage with your questions and comments and we hope that our new analysis addresses them. We are excited to continue discussing our work with you.