- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work addresses cross-subject EEG-based emotion recognition, incorporating audio and video during training while requiring only EEG at inference. The method uses Topology-Aware Relational Distillation to transfer region-dependency structures from a multimodal teacher to the student, and Masked Decision-Space Alignment to align EEG representations with multimodal semantics. Experiments on EAV and MDMER demonstrate improvements in EEG-only emotion recognition.
Critical strengths
1.The use of audio-visual information to guide EEG learning during training, while requiring only EEG at inference, has practical value. The method aligns the student with the teacher at both the regional-relation level and the decision-space level, potentially helping the student acquire richer emotion-related information.
2.Rather than directly matching teacher and student features, TRD aligns their region-dependency structures. This may reduce the effects of cross-modal feature discrepancies and inter-subject variability on distillation.
Critical weaknesses
1.The experimental evaluation needs to be more comprehensive. For example, why was LaBraM chosen rather than REVE, which was pretrained on more data? Similarly, why was iTransformer selected rather than more recent state-of-the-art sequence models? Dataset coverage is also limited, with no evaluation on other multimodal EEG datasets compatible with this setting, such as MAHNOB-HCI.
-
The methodological validation needs greater rigor. In the Cross-Modal EEG Refinement module, it is unclear whether the audio-visually refined features genuinely preserve region-specific information. Audio-visual information may simply be broadcast across regions, making them appear similar because of a shared cross-modal component. This could alter existing EEG semantics rather than provide meaningful regional information, and the paper does not appear to include an ablation examining this possibility. Moreover, because TRD explicitly optimizes the student graph to match the teacher graph, the graph alignment shown in Figure 4 is, to some extent, an expected consequence of the training objective. I recommend comparing teacher graphs constructed with and without audio-visual refinement and reporting results across multiple random seeds to strengthen the evidence.
-
Sections 4.4.1 and 4.4.2 could place less emphasis on reiterating the method and algorithmic design, and provide more analysis of what the model learns and how this supports the claimed benefits.
Questions for authors
1.Equation (2) does not specify the architecture of the Cross-Modal EEG Refinement function (f_{\mathrm{ref}}). How does audio-visual information refine individual EEG regions, and how does the module avoid broadcasting an identical cross-modal component to every region? Could the authors compare teacher graphs before and after refinement to establish whether the gains come from meaningful multimodal relational knowledge?
-
Is there a standardized data-splitting protocol for the compared methods on these datasets? If not, the authors’ choice of a uniform 6:2:2 or 8:1:1 split requires further explanation, as the results may depend on the particular partition. Please provide more justification for this choice or conduct experiments using multiple splits.
-
Could the authors clarify why only LaBraM was considered among pretrained EEG foundation models, without including additional models such as REVE,CBraMod? What motivated the selection of iTransformer (2024) as the time-series baseline, and were more recent state-of-the-art alternatives considered? Were other multimodal EEG datasets, such as MAHNOB-HCI, considered alongside EAV and MDMER, and what criteria guided the dataset selection? I consider these issues major concerns regarding the rigor of the experimental evaluation.
-
Table 4 reports only point estimates, without clarifying whether it uses the same random seeds as the main experiments, and provides neither variability estimates nor significance tests. Given that Shuffled Graph also improves Macro-F1 from 38.57 to 39.28. Therefore, additional experimental results seem necessary to support this conclusion.In particular, the graph alignment shown in Figure 4 is, to some extent, a direct consequence of optimizing the training objective. More convincing evidence is needed to demonstrate that this alignment translates into meaningful benefits from multimodal information.