- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
MADField predicts physically scaled equilibrium adsorbate density fields with a Boltzmann-residual 3D Swin U-Net, pre-trained on ~566k PC-SAFT cDFT fields and LoRA-adapted to GCMC density labels. Uptake is obtained by integration. The predicted fields are also used to warm-start cDFT, recover failed labels, and screen ARC-MOF (CH₄ working capacity) and MOSAEC-DB (CO₂ at 0.15 bar).
Critical strengths
The dataset and solver-in-the-loop pipeline are useful; recovered labels must be solver-verified rather than taken from network outputs. The work has a clear physical motivation. The controlled CH₄/Xe model includes framework-bootstrap CIs and fine-tuning seeds (Table 18). These experiments are fairly credible.
Critical weaknesses
-
- The central control is confounded. The key evidence for “density supervision beats scalar regression” is Table 14 (7.47 vs 1.31) and Table 15 (7.531 vs 1.996). Per lines 1350–1352, the scalar head mean-pools the final tokens, replaces the voxel decoder, and drops the Boltzmann-residual parameterization. This changes the readout, decoder/physics prior, and supervision at once. The density-supervised “w/o Boltzmann residual” variant reaches 1.55, close to 1.31, so the main confound is mean-pool readout without a decoder versus density supervision. The authors acknowledge (lines 1357, 1406) that the variants compare complete target/head schemes.
Treating uptake as a spatial integral of local pore contributions is itself a strong inductive bias, independent of whether density labels are used. Please add an integral-readout, scalar-supervised control on the same backbone and decoder. If density labels still add a substantial gain over this control, the central claim holds and I would raise my score to 3; otherwise, the title and abstract should reposition the contribution around the dataset and multi-fidelity transfer.
On related work: SpatialRead (Zou et al., ICLR 2026, “From atom to space: a region-based readout function for spatial properties of materials”) also formulates adsorption as a spatial integral of local contributions learned from scalar labels. This overlaps with the integral-readout part of MADField and reduces its novelty; the distinct contribution then rests on density supervision, which is what the control in point 1 should isolate. A comparison with SpatialRead, or the equivalent integral-readout control, would separate the two.
-
The CO₂ results do not support the thesis and use privileged inputs. The CO₂ extension ends with a scalar amplitude head (exp(2tanh(·)), range ≈0.14–7.4×) trained mainly on an uptake loss; an ablation is needed to show how much of the CO₂ accuracy comes from this head. The CO₂ density itself is poor (relative L1 61.8%; Tanimoto 0.634). Only MADField receives REPEAT charges and electrostatic channels (Table 12 caption). This differs from the setting of the other compared methods and may confound the contribution of the method with that of the extra information.
-
The screening results lack the model pretrained only on cDFT. cDFT ranks single-pressure CH₄ uptake with Spearman 0.999 against GCMC at 27 s/state (Tables 24–25). I think cDFT is still much slower than a neural network, so it may not be a suitable baseline, but I am curious about the results of the model pretrained only on cDFT. Recall–budget curves are needed for MADField-cDFT without GCMC adaptation.
-
Uncertainty remains unclear. Only the controlled CH₄/Xe model has intervals. The main tables, PRAM transfer (138 states; the “AC” family has 3 states yet carries 1/4 of the mean weight) and the complete-recovery budgets need intervals. That said, the improvements in the tables are fairly clear, so omitting intervals is largely reasonable, but confidence intervals would make the results more rigorous. The multi-fidelity gain is 7.2% at full labels and 41% at 10% labels; the abstract should state it this way.
Minor comments
-
- The main tables report no run-to-run variance for the baselines or MADField. The margins are large enough not to change the conclusions, but please run them several times and report means and standard deviations.
- Table 3's GCMC mean mixes a 967-framework CH₄/Xe test with a 90-MOF CO₂ test.
- The gate is called h_θ in Eq. 7 but g_θ in Eq. 20.
- The “Mat. ✓” entry in Table 1 should say zero-shot.
The dataset and solver-in-the-loop pipeline are valuable, but the key claim that density supervision improves uptake prediction is not yet supported by an unconfounded control. I would raise my score to 3 if the integral-readout, scalar-supervised control clearly shows a substantial gain from density labels and the CO₂ amplitude-head ablation is added. The overlap with SpatialRead also lowers my assessment of novelty somewhat, and this is reflected in the score.
Questions for authors
(1) What is the error of the integral-readout, scalar-supervised control? (2) What is the CO₂ MAE without the amplitude head, and with charge inputs given to the baselines? (3) What are the recall curves of MADField-cDFT without GCMC adaptation? (4) What are the seed or bootstrap intervals for the main tables and the screening budgets?
6 comments
W2 / Q2. : density supervision, amplitude head, and charge inputs
To address this concern, we ran three controlled experiments isolating density supervision, the amplitude head, and framework-charge inputs. The results show that MADField's high accuracy compared to other baselines is not explained by the amplitude head or unequal access to charge information, while density supervision retains a substantial benefit under matched inputs and architecture. Specifically, (i) with identical charge inputs and architecture, density supervision reduces MAE by 37.0% (Table R1), (ii) removing the amplitude head leaves accuracy unchanged (Table R2), and (iii) scalar baselines given the same charge information stay at 20.99 MAE or above, compared with 8.76 for MADField (Table R3).
(i) Density supervision under matched inputs. The scalar-integral control and MADField receive the same charge inputs and have the same architecture, including the amplitude head. Density supervision reduces MAE from 13.554 to 8.542 (37.0%, last column of Table R1). Although remains the most challenging density-prediction task (relative L1 61.8%), the matched control shows that density supervision still substantially improves uptake prediction.
(ii) Amplitude head. We retrained MADField without the global amplitude head that rescales the predicted density field.
Table R2 (Appendix I.9). uptake MAE (↓) in .
| With amplitude head | Without amplitude head | |
|---|---|---|
| MADField, retrained (2 seeds) | 8.542 ± 0.328 | 8.348 ± 0.299 |
Removing the amplitude head does not degrade uptake accuracy (paired 95% CI of the difference [−1.297, 0.773]).
(iii) Charge inputs for the baselines. is a quadrupolar adsorbate whose uptake depends on electrostatic interactions with the framework. The GCMC reference labels are themselves generated with REPEAT framework charges and a charged model. To directly address the concern that MADField may benefit from privileged electrostatic information, we matched the charge information available to the scalar baselines (RetNet, Uni-MOF, and MOFTransformer) in two ways (details in Appendix I.9):
- Charge adapter. Per-atom charges are embedded and added to the atom embeddings of Uni-MOF and MOFTransformer. For RetNet, which takes voxel grids, the electrostatic potential computed from the charges is added after its first convolutional layer.
- Electrostatic field. The electrostatic interaction between the framework charges and a molecule is computed on a grid, encoded, and given to each model as an additional input.
The added modules have about 12.47M parameters, matching MADField's charge-related modules. Each "without charge" control has identical modules with the charge inputs set to zero.
Table R3 (Appendix I.9, Table 27). uptake MAE (↓) in , mean ± SD over three seeds. Charge gain is defined as MAE(without charge) − MAE(with charge).
| Model | How charges are given | Without charge | With charge | Charge gain, paired 95% CI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RetNet | Charge adapter | 28.003 ± 0.462 | 21.376 ± 0.312 | [2.809, 11.090] |
| RetNet | Electrostatic field | 28.058 ± 0.431 | 21.466 ± 0.374 | [2.446, 11.299] |
| Uni-MOF | Charge adapter | 23.878 ± 0.385 | 23.414 ± 0.632 | [−0.738, 1.574] |
| Uni-MOF | Electrostatic field | 22.343 ± 0.164 | 23.305 ± 0.961 | [−1.603, −0.334] |
| MOFTransformer | Charge adapter | 22.972 ± 0.220 | 22.748 ± 0.228 | [−0.193, 0.673] |
| MOFTransformer | Electrostatic field | 21.616 ± 0.203 | 20.992 ± 0.511 | [−0.126, 1.486] |
Charge-aware retraining improves RetNet, while producing small or inconsistent changes for Uni-MOF and MOFTransformer. Importantly, the best charge-aware scalar baseline still has an MAE of 20.992, compared with 8.763 for MADField.
W3 / Q3. Screening with MADField-cDFT (no GCMC adaptation)
To directly assess how much of the screening performance is obtained from cDFT pretraining alone, we added MADField-cDFT to the recall-budget curves in Appendix I.12, Figure 11. Here, MADField-cDFT denotes the model pretrained only on cDFT densities, while MADField-GCMC denotes the model after GCMC adaptation. The cDFT-only model provides strong ranking performance, whereas screening improves substantially after GCMC adaptation.
Table R4 (Table 31). working-capacity screening on the original 254,198-candidate pool: number of top-ranked candidates that must be evaluated to recover each fraction of the 166 targets with working capacity ≥200 (↓).
| Ranking method | 60% recall | 80% recall | 100% recall |
|---|---|---|---|
| MADField-cDFT | 1,390 | 2,206 | 11,666 |
| MADField-GCMC | 175 | 723 | 16,600 |
MADField-GCMC requires substantially fewer screened candidates at 60–80% recall than MADField-cDFT. At 100% recall, MADField-cDFT requires fewer candidates, reflecting a small number of tail cases that are ranked lower after GCMC adaptation. Overall, however, MADField-GCMC provides the better recall–budget trade-off across the screening curve.
Table R5 (Table 32). screening at 0.15 bar, same quantity as Table R4. The pool is all 17,152 frameworks held out from training, with 18 targets (true top 0.1%). The paper’s seven-model comparison uses the 15,572 of these that every baseline can process, with 16 targets.
| Ranking method | 60% recall | 80% recall | 100% recall |
|---|---|---|---|
| MADField-cDFT | 15,445 | 16,459 | 16,737 |
| MADField-GCMC | 15 | 29 | 166 |
For , MADField-cDFT retains much of the screening performance, indicating that the cDFT-pretrained density model captures a ranking signal that transfers well to the GCMC target. In contrast, the ranking improves substantially after GCMC adaptation. This difference is consistent with the lower cDFT–GCMC agreement for than for observed in Table 25.
Notably, the benefit of cDFT pretraining is not limited to reproducing cDFT rankings. In the controlled /Xe experiment (Table 17), its uptake-MAE reduction grows from 7.2% with all GCMC labels to 41.0% when only 10% of GCMC labels are available.
We thank the reviewer for the careful and constructive review. We ran the requested integral-readout control, the CO2 amplitude-head ablation, charge-aware baselines, and the MADField-cDFT screening comparison, and added confidence intervals. The results are given below and in the revised manuscript, where changes are marked in red.
W1 / Q1. Isolating the effect of density supervision
We agree that the original scalar-head comparison changed both the supervision target and the readout. We therefore trained the requested control, “Scalar integral” in Table R1, which uses the same backbone, decoder, Boltzmann-residual parametrization, and integral readout as our model, “Density MADField.” The only difference is the supervision: Scalar integral is trained solely on scalar uptake labels, whereas Density MADField additionally receives density-field supervision. Under this controlled comparison, density supervision reduces uptake MAE by 37.0–60.2% relative to scalar uptake supervision.
Table R1 (Appendix I.8, Table 26). Controlled scalar-supervision ablation. Uptake MAE (↓) is reported in cm3(STP)/g. The MAE reduction is computed relative to Scalar integral, with 95% confidence intervals obtained by paired bootstrap over matched test samples. The CO2 column follows the training protocol of the submitted model and reports mean ± SD over two seeds.
Relation to SpatialRead. The integral readout is not our claimed contribution. SpatialRead (Zou et al., ICLR 2026) shows that spatially integrating learned local contributions can itself provide an effective inductive bias for adsorption-property prediction from scalar labels. Our new Scalar integral control therefore directly tests whether this inductive bias alone explains MADField’s gain. Table R1 shows that, even when the spatial-integral architecture is held fixed, direct density supervision still reduces uptake MAE by 37.0–60.2%.
Our contribution instead centers on learning the physical, unnormalized adsorption density as a common prediction target across simulation fidelities. This enables abundant, scalable cDFT density labels to pre-train the model before adaptation to much more expensive GCMC density labels, reducing the amount of high-fidelity density supervision required. The predicted field also determines uptake by integration and directly supports spatial adsorption analysis and cDFT solver initialization. We now cite and discuss SpatialRead in Section 2.2 and Appendix I.8.