- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a new likelihood term, Uncertainty-Aware Likelihood (UAL), that takes into account the uncertainty on the forward model. Based on the knowledge of the distribution of forward models, the new likelihood can be used in existing diffusion models restoration processes. The models relies on a linearization that induces an quantified error. UAL is run on many inverse problems and diffusion frameworks and outperforms standard diffusion models run with a likelihhod that do not take into account the uncertainty of the forward model.
Critical strengths
- The UAL construction is original and provides a promishing model of the forward model uncertainties.
- The experimental comparison is made on diverse inverse problems and diffusion samplers.
Critical weaknesses
Major :
- The performance of oracle method (where the correct forward model is used to reconstruct) is not provided. The experimental results show that many diffusion models methods have unstable results with respect with the forward model. However, it is hard to conclude on the proposed method since the oracle performances are not provided.
- The paper is not well written and hard to follow. Many important paragraphs (see details below) are unclear.
- The proposed methods relies on a perfect knowledge of the distribution of forward models that is unknown in many situations.
Minor/typos:
- Page 3 line 137-139: I recommend to make a separate paragraph for Langevin samplers since it is significantly different than diffusion priors.
- page 3 line 160 : Which data-based are you refer to ?
- page 3 line 156-161 : This paragraph should be re-written. The link between sentences is unclear.
- page 4 line 201 : The notation is not well adapted since this quantity does not depend of . I suggest the notation .
- page 5 line 26 : is the singular value of what ?
- page 5 line 233 : What conditions the differentiability of and induce on or ?
- page 5 line 236 : I suggest to write the derivative of for an easier following of the transition (5) to (6).
- page 5 line 225-232 : This paragraph should be re-written, it is unclear and hard to follow. Please detail the computation and reasoning.
- page 5 line 240-252 : This paragraph is unclear and hard to follow. Especially there is many new notations in a short paragraph and many references to the Appendices without detailed explanations. Please detail it to make it clear.
- page 5 line 245 (same remark for page 14 line 752) : The second equation on is not part of the system, it is a consequence of the first equation, please re-write it.
- page 7 line 347-351 : The sampler are not provided, please complete and make the table self-contained.
- page 8 line 394 : Please do not use abbreviations without introduction such as "SE".
- page 14 line 718-725 : No details are given in the proof, please provide the complete proof.
- page 14 line 744 : I suggest to add in the beginning of the sentence "By Proposition 1 with the linearized forward model". Please recall the definition of and .
- page 14 line 744-745 : What do you mean by the sentence "A single factorization [...] ." ?
Questions for authors
- Could we adopt this method for taking into account uncertainty in the prior knowledge ?
- page 5 line 245 : Why this system admits a solution ? This solution is unique ? Why this name ?
- How to adapt the proposed method when the forward model distribution is unknown ?
- Since the Langevin samplers such as PnP-ULA are proved to be stable to forward models (see page 3 line 137), what is the practical gain of UAL for these samplers ?
- What is the additional computational cost of using UAL compare to the standard likelihood ?