acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Tracing Compositional Instability: Temporal Dynamics of Attribute-Object Correspondence in Diffusion Transformers

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Modern text-to-image diffusion models achieve remarkable visual fidelity, yet can fail even on simple compositions in which two objects must each realize their respective attribute. We study how such failures emerge in multimodal diffu- sion transformers (MMDiTs), where text and image representations are jointly updated throughout generation. Evaluation based only on the final generated im- age cannot reveal how these failures develop internally: is the requested com- position already incorrect from the beginning, or does it change as denoising proceeds? This requires controlled generations in which the same semantic con- stituents lead to different compositional outcomes. We therefore introduce a con- trolled compositional benchmark that systematically varies attribute-object com- positions and the conditions under which different bindings compete. Analysing token-representation geometry across blocks and denoising time, we trace how attribute-object bindings evolve internally. For the state-of-the-art MMDiT mod- els SD3.5 and FLUX.1-dev, we find that the requested binding can be supported at earlier stages of the generative computation but become unstable as information is transformed across model depth and denoising time. Finally, we show that these internal signals are functionally actionable and introduce a test-time steering ap- proach toward the requested binding that reduces generation failure. Together, our results characterize compositional binding not as a fixed property of the prompt representation, but as dynamically evolving throughout the generation.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Diffusion Transformers, Text-to-Image Generation, Attribute-Object Binding, Compositionality, Denoising Dynamics, Representation Steering

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_rGLwOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how attribute binding evolves across model depth and denoising time in mmdits. Under a controlled two-object color-binding experiment, the author shows that in some cases the binding is initially correct before shifting to competing assignment. They further propose a training-free approach to penalize deviations from the initial correct bindings during the denoising process.

Critical strengths
  1. The finding that some binding failures are initially generated correctly but became inverted during the generation process is interesting. This also offers insights for other subfields, for example, a new explanation for why t2i models can improve binding capabilities through rl on GenEval.
  2. The observed geometry also supports a targeted intervention, and the intervention works well on sd3.5
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited cross-model effectiveness. Gains are substantial on sd3.5 but relatively marginal on flux.1 ( −0.2 on t2i-compbench++) color (Appendix C.3). Evaluation on newer mmdits such as z-image or flux.2 klein would strengthen the generalization evidence.
  2. The analysis evaluated only on color binding with two-object prompts, which is too narrow. It remains unclear whether these findings generalize to other attributes (like texture/shape/size), or multi-object cases.
  3. FID against imagenet is difficult to interpret for this narrow set of compositional prompts. A human-preference reward like hpsv3 is better for evaluating image quality.
  4. Presentation issues. Some figures (e.g. Fig. 5), are blurry and difficult to inspect. Table captions (e.g., Tab.1 ) appear below the tables, which is against to the iclr requirements
Questions for authors
  1. How can you explain the substantially weaker gains on flux.1?
  2. What is the inference-time overhead of scout-and-replay steering relative to the baseline?
Reviewer_9b3QOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This work focuses on compositional failures, specifically color/attribute binding in MMDiT based text-to-image diffusion models. Specifically, how attribute binding failures emerges across transformer model's depth and time-steps. To this aim, first a controlled benchmark is introduced focusing on color binding of two object in a format of "A1 N1 and A2 N2". Concretely, authors analyze hidden representation of tokens before QKV attention layers to trace where/when the compositional failures happen. Building on this a simple inference time intervention is proposed to steer the representation and preserve the correct intended binding.

The paper first claims that some failures occur in later timestemp while are correct initially. The experiments include FLUX.1-dev and SD3.5 on the constructed controlled benchmark and T2I-CompBench++. Results shows significant improvement on SD3.5 on Controlled benchmark while moderate improvement or comparable results on T2I-CompBench++ and FLUX model.

Critical strengths
  • [S1] The paper is overall well-written and easy to follow.

  • [S2] the paper studies compositional failures, and the focus on depth/timestemp evolving behavior is very interesting and can provide important information regarding compositional behavior of models

Critical weaknesses
  • [W1] The benchmark and analysis are extremely narrow. While I understand that studying compositional failures requires some simplification, the paper focuses on two-object color binding ("A1 N1 and A2 N2") and is very small (includes only 26 configurations). Previous works have studied more diverse compositional scenarios, like other attribute types, spatial relations, and action-based relations. It remains unclear whether the main finding and metho (e.g. finding that initially correct assignments can become incorrect later in generation) is valid to these settings. I suggest evaluating additional compositional scenarios.

  • [W2] Limited comparison with related methods.

  • The steering method is compared primarily against the pretrained models, without direct comparisons to existing established inference-time correction approaches, such as Attend-and-Excite, R2F its effectiveness remains unclear. R2F is particularly relevant because it addresses rare compositions through interventions across denoising steps by alternating among rare/freq prompts.

  • [W3] Effectiveness of the proposed intervention. While the method improves success by 19.8 percentage points on the SD3.5 Controlled Benchmark, the gain on T2I-CompBench++ Colour is only 1.3 points. On FLUX, improvements are limited on the controlled benchmark, with a slight regression on T2I-CompBench++ Colour. These results raise concerns about generalization across models and prompt distributions. Evaluation on a more diverse model, (e.g Qwen-Image) and compositional settings could help

Questions for authors
  • The paper mentions the Threshold is calibrated on base model. What prompts are used? are the prompt same as the test prompts or there are held out set? If the same prompts are used please report the results on a separate held out set

  • Does the observed instability generalize beyond color binding to other compositional scenarios?

  • One of the paper's central claims is that failed generations can initially exhibit correct assignment before shifting toward an incorrect correspondence (L093). However, the paper does not provide any/sufficient quantitative analysis while some plots are provided mainly in the supplement. How frequently this transition occurs across individual generations? Across what type of inputs (align, swapped, wrong) these plots look like? more importantly does this hold across other compositional failures (e.g. spatial, shape binding, etc) ? Note that this is important to analyze other types of compositions as the coarse-to-fine behavior --i.e. early timestemps models focus on coarse parts of the image (e.g. spatial, shape) while later the fine-grained (e.g. color) appear. Hence, this claim needs to be tested on other settings.

  • Could the authors clarify why the projection in Eq. (8) reliably measures attribute-object binding? The representation is still heavily influcenced by the text embedding which may naturally be closer to the common object (e.g. yellow for bannana) especially in earlier layers. For example, earlier layers (e.g. first layer/block) before attention the text/image tokens may have not interacted yet. How can their geometric proximity be interpreted as attribute-object binding rather than semantic similarity inherited from the text embeddings?

  • How are the 26 benchmark configurations selected (including predefined attributes)? is it manual or automatic? Also, the filtering is conducted after the incorrect and swap pairs are constructed ?

  • Also, the paper centeral contribution is analysis "desnoising step" and transformer depth. However, no layer-wise, depth-wise analysis are provided in the main paper. Could you please clarify what layers were more related to the compositional failures?

Some other points:

  • minor Additionally, while related work has discussed many compositional generation methods, it would be beneficial for readers that related work discuss the compositional generation/generalization papers e.g. [1-5] and layout based papers

  • minor: Also, although Sec.4.1 introduces the construction, important details about filtering and evaluation are mainly in the appendix. This requires the reader to constantly back-and-forth between main and appendix as this is an integral part of the paper. The paper also does not clearly explain how the final configurations are selected from the eligible combinations or whether all valid combinations are included. Given that the benchmark is a core contribution, these details should be clearer in the main paper.

[1] Skews in the phenomenon space hinder generalization in text-to-image generation, ECCV 2024 [2] Getting it right: Improving spatial consistency in text-to-image models, ECCV [3] Debiasing Framework For Attribute Binding In Diffusion-Based Text-To-Image Generation] [4] Role Bias in Diffusion Models: Diagnosing and Mitigating through Intermediate Decomposition, NeurIPS 2025 [5] Attribute-centric compositional text-to-image generation

Reviewer_F4btOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper tackles the problem of compositional binding in MM-DiTs, where generations fail with attributes being wrongly applied to the objects or being not generated. This paper propose a new benchmark that tries to isolate the relational failure, by single-object screening, and build a four categorized prompt setups: aligned, counter-prior, reciprocal competitor and homogeneous. The authors also analyze and track how the noun representations are organized relative to the attributes. They observe that attributes and their corresponding nouns are aligned properly early in generation, and failures occur when the alignment is broken, with another noun being more aligned to an attribute (swap). To overcome this problem, the authors propose to use a scout-and-replay strategy, where the model is run shortly as a pilot run, and see if it is at risk for the collapse, based on a predefined threshold. Then, if the run is at risk, the image tokens are steered so that the nouns stay on the appropriate side of the attribute axis.

Critical strengths
  • The proposed benchmark seems to isolate the defined problem properly, and could stand as a good benchmark for compositional binding.
  • The 'swap' observation is interesting, and the subsequent solution sounds sensible.
Critical weaknesses
  • The 'swap' observation is not quantitatively verified. The authors visualize and show that the 'swap' part is where the compositional failure occurs, but they never show quantitatively if it's 100% of the time that swap and the failure occurs, or if it's 90%. Without these numbers, it cannot be said that this is a general phenomenon, since it may be coming from a few cases, not always. The evaluation results support my concern. To name a few, the aggregate failure rate is reduced by 56% on the custom benchmark, but if this phenomenon occurs most of the time, I believe the failure rate should have been dramatically reduced, and on the existing T2I-Compbench++ benchmark, the gain is extremely marginal, by only 1.3%.

  • Concerns on evaluation

    • Qwen3-8B for VQA: Qwen3-8B is a LLM, without a vision capability. Thus I wonder how the authors conducted VQA with this model.
    • FID: needs a more thorough evaluation. FID has been known to be noisy in evaluation [1], and the results could change with the number of samples used in evaluation [2,3]. The problem is especially critical with small number of samples, and the current evaluation with roughly 5k samples could make the evaluation unreliable. I suggest to use CMMD[2] or KID[4].

[1] Dufour et al., The FID Lottery: Quantifying Hidden Randomness in Generative-Model Evaluation, arXiv 2606.20536

[2] Jayasumana et al., Rethinking FID: Towards a Better Evaluation Metric for Image Generation, CVPR 2024

[3] Chong et al., Effectively Unbiased FID and Inception Score and Where to Find Them, CVPR 2020

[4] Bińkowski et al., Demystifying MMD GANs, ICLR 2018

Questions for authors
  • I wonder how the attributes are handled in homongeneous setting?
  • I wonder the computation cost / overhead of using the scout-and-replay approach especially with respect to the entire generation process.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Reviewers,

We appreciate your considerable effort in evaluating our work. We have taken your concerns seriously and are working on extensive additional experiments regarding benchmark extensions to other attribute types, comparison to baseline intervention methods, and image quality metrics. Unfortunately, this has not worked out in time for the rebuttal, but thanks to your input will make for a much stronger submission at a future venue.

Thank you for your constructive and helpful feedback!

Sincerely, The Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.