- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a framework called Counterfactual Constraint Diffusion (CCD) for compositional text to image generation. Although the paper formulates a latent level guidance update rule, it is left unimplemented.
Critical strengths
NA
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper is an unfinished work with circular and tiny scale experiments. The core latent level guidance method described in Section 3.4 and Figure 1 is not implemented or tested at all. The actual experiments only test 12 and 20 toy prompts on a single model (SDXL Turbo). In Table 2, the only positive quantitative result is completely circular: candidate images are selected by maximizing the CLIP counterfactual margin score, and then evaluated using that exact same margin score. Picking the maximum of three numbers naturally yields a higher average than picking the first or a random number, which provides no evidence of improved image quality. Furthermore, the external human evaluation in Section 4.5 is merely a blank template with zero collected data, and no standard compositional benchmarks (such as T2I-CompBench or TIFA) or basic CLIP reranking baselines are evaluated.
-
Severe formatting errors and fabricated or duplicated references make the manuscript unacceptable for publication. On Page 3, Figure 1 and half of Figure 2 are pasted together as a single image with baked in captions, followed by a duplicate LaTeX caption underneath. Figure 2 is then pasted again on Page 5 with double captions. Even worse, none of the 45 references are cited anywhere in the main text. The reference list itself contains massive duplications (for example, Rombach et al. appears three times as [1], [26], and [30], and pairs like [2]/[28], [3]/[27], [8]/[35], [9]/[36], [10]/[39], [11]/[38], and [12]/[37] are duplicates) alongside clear AI hallucinations and wrong authors.
Questions for authors
Why was this manuscript submitted to a top tier conference in such an unfinished state? Submitting an incomplete draft without basic proofreading shows a lack of respect for the peer review process and wastes reviewers' time.