- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a new aerodynamic prediction network, FSAN, which adaptively divides the 3D geometric surface into multiple potential-flow states, allowing different regions to exhibit different feature modulations based on global inflow conditions, thereby improving the accuracy of surface pressure predictions.
Critical strengths
- The paper notes that most current methods apply operating condition parameters as global conditions to all surface points in the same way. However, these global conditions can affect different geometric regions differently. As a result, different surface regions may need to handle operating condition information in their own ways. This insight offers a fresh perspective on how to combine geometry and operating conditions.
- The paper introduces an attention mechanism designed for combining geometry and condition information. It uses soft assignment and weighted aggregation of point features, along with cross attention. This approach allows different latent states to interact with condition information separately, enabling region-specific conditioning.
Critical weaknesses
- At present, the division of latent states and the conditioning of operating conditions are mainly learned through predictive tasks using data, without direct physical supervision. As a result, current experiments do not clearly show whether performance improvements come from the model learning effective adaptive division and conditioning, or if they are mainly due to the more complex attention structure. It is also possible that simply making the model structure more complex leads to better predictive performance.
- The main module described in the article is structurally very similar to existing methods. Both FSA and Transolver's physics attention use similar ideas, such as soft allocation, weighted aggregation, and feature backpropagation [1]. What sets FSA apart is its use of condition tokens and the way it conditions latent states through cross-attention. This means its main innovation is in the conditional mechanism within the latent state interaction framework, rather than in how regions are divided. Other related methods, like Graph Transformer [2], also use similar structures. The paper should explain more clearly what makes FSA a significant improvement over existing methods.
References:
[1] Wu, Haixu, et al. "Transolver: A fast transformer solver for pdes on general geometries." ICML 2024.
[2] Janny, Steeven, et al. "Eagle: Large-scale learning of turbulent fluid dynamics with mesh transformers." ICLR 2023.
Questions for authors
- The ablation experiments show that FSA performs better than the other fusion mechanisms tested. How can we tell if this improvement comes from adaptive state partitioning and working condition modulation, or if it is mainly due to the more complex attention structure?
- FSA and Transolver both use similar physics attention methods, such as soft allocation, weighted aggregation, and feature backpropagation. Could you explain more clearly what the main innovations of FSA are compared to Transolver? Also, what specific benefits do condition tokens and cross attention bring?
- The paper uses data-driven learning through prediction tasks to achieve latent state partitioning. Besides showing visual results and their link to flow characteristics, what other evidence can show that the model has truly learned adaptive state partitioning that changes with operating conditions, and that this is a key reason for better performance?
- The paper has not yet included specific geometric OOD or operating condition OOD tests. Without these results, how do you assess FSA’s ability to generalize to new geometries and operating conditions? Is it necessary to further verify its advantages over existing methods through targeted out-of-distribution experiments?
2 comments
Official Comment by Reviewer KFSE
I thank the authors for the additional experiments and clarifications. The fixed-partition ablation provides useful evidence for the benefits of adaptive state partitioning. However, I remain unclear about the methodological novelty of FSAN beyond existing physics-attention mechanisms such as Transolver, particularly whether condition tokens and cross-attention constitute a sufficiently substantial advance. Additionally, the lack of targeted OOD evaluations on unseen geometries and operating conditions leaves its generalization advantages unverified. Therefore, I maintain my original rating.
Thank you for recognizing the motivation and design of our work, and for raising questions about the method, experimental evidence, and generalization. We respond to each point below.
1. How do we verify the role of adaptive state partitioning?
To further verify the role of adaptive state partitioning, we trained a fixed-partition control model whose soft assignments are computed solely from geometric features and therefore do not vary with operating conditions. The Emmi-Wing results for FSAN and the fixed-partition model are as follows:
The fixed-partition model performs worse on all four metrics, indicating that allowing the state partition to vary with operating conditions improves prediction performance.
2. What are FSAN’s innovations and advantages over Transolver?
The original Transolver does not have a dedicated flow-condition encoding and interaction branch. When adapting it to this task, one can broadcast the global flow conditions to every point and concatenate them with the point features. This places semantically different information—local geometric coordinates and global operating parameters—in the same point-feature representation. The model must then learn to distinguish these inputs and determine how to combine the global conditions with geometric features from different regions. The concatenated conditions also enter subsequent point-feature processing and soft partitioning, coupling geometric grouping with condition information from the outset and making it harder to learn effective partitions and region-specific responses to conditions.
FSAN encodes flow conditions separately as condition tokens and uses cross-attention to interact with the geometric latent states. Each latent state can select and integrate relevant information from the condition tokens based on its own geometric features, enabling region-specific condition modulation. The soft partition can also be formed from geometric features first, without simultaneously processing geometric coordinates and global operating parameters during partitioning.
3. What evidence shows that the partition varies with operating conditions and that this variation improves performance?
FSAN computes its soft assignments from features that have interacted with the operating conditions. Thus, the same geometry can produce different partitions under different conditions. The fixed-partition control lacks this condition dependence; as shown in the results under Question 1, it performs worse on all four prediction metrics. This supports our view that allowing state partitions to adapt to operating conditions is an important factor in FSAN’s performance gains.
4. How do we assess generalization to out-of-distribution geometries or operating conditions?
We agree that targeted OOD tests are important for assessing generalization to unseen geometries and operating conditions. However, publicly available aerodynamic datasets remain limited in geometric coverage, operating-condition ranges, and data quality, making it difficult to construct reliable and representative OOD evaluations. Therefore, our results support FSAN’s performance only on the distributions covered by the current datasets; they do not establish stronger generalization to unseen geometries or operating conditions. Developing high-quality OOD benchmarks and conducting systematic evaluations are important directions for future work.
We thank the reviewer again for the suggestions, which have helped us clarify the contributions of our method and the scope of the conclusions supported by our experiments.