- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents TRAJFOUNDRY, a framework for generating multimodal agent trajectories by retaining production experience across rounds while keeping the producer model fixed. The framework consists of three mechanisms: compositional reuse of executable task families, validation reuse skills, and target artifact recovery. In experiments, TRAJFOUNDRY produces 591 grounded unique trajectories per 1k normalized cost, compared with 480 for static production and 497 for EnvScaler-adapted. The main contribution is kind of a meta policy for trajectory/experience synthesis, to get high-quality generated data in a more efficient way.
Critical strengths
The framework addresses trajectory synthesis in a more efficient way. The paper does not rely solely on generating more accepted trajectories. It evaluates downstream learning with matched training tokens and a fixed training recipe, and removes production-time Skill cards from student examples.
Critical weaknesses
-
I highly doubt the figure is purely AI-drawn without human adjustment, especially Figure 2. The drawing lines and arrows are messy, and there are very small images inside the figure. The writing and experiment analysis part also require human revision.
-
The improvement over other baselines is not that much, but the task itself is very costly. And the novelty of this work is limited. This is just an extension of previous trajectory synthesis methods from the trajectory level to the meta level.
Questions for authors
-
In the appendix, the authors do not provide an example to show how the framework can efficiently improve the synthesis. Only from the text, I cannot tell it from previous works. I think an example might also help to clarify the novelty. Can the authors provide one or two examples?
-
What are the adoption rate and negative-transfer rate among families that actually receive a new Skill?