- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on an important problem: what information is important for a competent decision-maker? The authors formulate the notion of a competent agent and provide a complete characterization, a random-walk analysis, and an analysis of a state cap.
Critical strengths
-
The paper focuses on a really important question: what information of the environment is very important for an effective decision-maker?
-
The paper studies this problem from a theoretical view. The claimed results are interesting and novel.
Critical weaknesses
- The most critical weakness of this paper is the poor writing. As a paper submitted to the learning theory track, it is expected to define the important quantities and provide mathematically rigorous statements of the main results. The following quantities are not mathematically defined:
-
The communication of the environment.
-
The native goal.
-
Depth and width
-
Private randomness.
-
The papers contain too many new concepts without definition. Thus, it is very hard to check the correctness of the proof.
-
The following results should be stated mathematically rigorously:
-
Theorem 3.6
-
Theorem 5.1
Questions for authors
Please provide the precise definition of all the important quantities and results.
We strongly disagree with W3. The observation that “answering these queries correctly already requires predicting the target cylinder probabilities” misses the point of the paper. This is a theoretical paper about the information identifiable from competent behavior. Its central question is precisely which environment quantities a behavioral competence condition forces an agent’s choices to reveal. The contribution is a sharp: on the full admissible class, we establish recovery of the random-walk law and a matching converse ruling out any universally recoverable information beyond it. Extending this characterization to fixed positive loss below one half is the central technical result. W3 does not engage with that result.