acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

WORLD MODELS WITH PREDICTABLE LONG-HORIZON MARGINALS

10 views

Abstract

Accurate one-step predictions do not ensure that a world model's rollouts retain the data distribution. We make the model's decoded stationary law explicit by learning a decoder of a fixed Gaussian reference and constraining the behaviour-averaged transition to preserve that reference. For controlled systems, a joint transition uses a conditional action chart to preserve behaviour occupancy without requiring invariance at each fixed action. Joint state–action rotations and parallel Gaussian noise give an exactly preserving transition with a tractable conditional density. We derive an absolute convergence bound from finite initialization banks and control departure from the reference through conditional action-space divergence. Across fitted pixel checkpoints on twelve control tasks, the occupancy model with a reference mixture retains every evaluated chain at steps in all task–seed cells, with a rollout-minus-reference energy-statistic difference of (training-seed standard error). Each of the four nonpreserving comparison arms loses chains, although the Gaussian arm is more accurate at ten steps. An offline DreamerV3 reference also achieves better short-horizon accuracy. These results distinguish three properties of a world model: the distribution it approaches, the rate of approach, and the conditional dynamics it learns.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
World Models, Marginal Stability, Stationary Distributions, Gaussian-Preserving Transitions, Occupancy Preservation, Long-Horizon Rollouts, Model-Based Reinforcement Learning, Conditional Density Estimation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_pdNnOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a world-model architecture whose transitions exactly preserve a standard Gaussian latent reference under a specified behavior policy, making its long-horizon observation distribution accessible through static sampling. The method combines conditional action transformations, joint state–action mixing, and Gaussian noise while retaining a tractable conditional density. The authors derive finite-initialization convergence bounds and bounds on marginal departure under policy changes. Validation includes controlled dynamical systems and 216 recurrent pixel-model checkpoints across twelve control tasks. The primary model maintains complete numerical survival at 100,000 steps, with marginal statistics matching static-reference predictions. The experiments also demonstrate that these guarantees do not necessarily yield better short-horizon prediction or planning performance.

Critical strengths
  • Controlled preserving architecture: The joint state–action construction preserves the Gaussian reference under the behavior policy while allowing action-dependent dynamics and a tractable conditional density.
  • Computable marginal guarantees: The finite-initialization bounds accommodate empirical starting-state banks, while the policy-deviation analysis relates departure from the reference to changes in action distributions.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited demonstrated practical value: The guarantees characterize convergence to the model’s own reference distribution, rather than accuracy relative to the environment. The occupancy model has higher ten-step MSE than the Gaussian baseline (0.1271 versus 0.0708) and fails in 19 of 36 CEM planning settings. These results leave unclear when the proposed guarantees provide a useful benefit for dynamics modeling or control.
  • Incomplete positioning against closely related methods: Although the paper cites DySLIM and PFNN, it provides limited substantive comparison with their approaches to invariant-measure learning and long-term dynamics. Generative Markov state models with explicit stationary distributions also warrant discussion.
Questions for authors

Q1: What is the underlying cause of the nineteen CEM planning failures, and how does this relate to the assumptions or entropy contraction required by your guarantees?

Q2: Which modeling capabilities or theoretical guarantees are newly enabled by your construction compared to PFNN and generative Markov state models with explicit stationary distributions?

Reviewer_iMapOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies whether a world model’s long-horizon marginal distribution can be estimated through static sampling. It constructs a latent transition that exactly preserves a standard Gaussian reference under the behaviour-averaged dynamics, using conditional action charts, joint state–action mixing, and parallel Gaussian noise. The construction provides a tractable conditional density, finite-initialization convergence bounds, and policy-deviation bounds. Decoding the reference identifies the model’s long-run observation law, while matching that law to data remains a learning problem. Experiments include synthetic systems and 216 recurrent pixel-model fits across 12 control tasks. The proposed model retains all evaluated chains at 100,000 steps, with terminal statistics agreeing with the static reference, but does not establish superior short-horizon prediction or planning.

Critical strengths

The paper combines exact behaviour-averaged preservation, a tractable conditional density, and finite-initialization convergence bounds in a controlled world model, enabling static estimation of its long-run distribution.

Synthetic experiments, 12 control tasks, and multiple ablations support agreement between long-rollout and static-reference statistics, while distinguishing marginal fidelity, conditional prediction, and planning performance.

Critical weaknesses

The 100,000-step survival metric measures numerical survival rather than dynamical accuracy. Gaussian predictions are better at short horizons, and the proposed model fails in 19 of 36 primary planning evaluations, leaving task-relevant benefits of the guarantees unestablished.

Alternatives fail suite-wide fit and resource-matching criteria, preventing isolation of exact preservation’s contribution. The DreamerV3 comparison is limited, and policy transfer of fitted models is unmeasured, leaving practical advantages and generalization insufficiently supported.

Questions for authors
  1. Do existing results quantify the effect of reference refresh on autocorrelation or other temporal statistics? What does the reset-free ablation show about dynamical fidelity and conditional prediction, beyond survival and marginal discrepancies?

  2. Beyond the output-gain intervention, can existing experiments separate the contributions of exact preservation, noise/refresh mechanisms, and achieved conditional fit? Which cross-architecture conclusions can currently be attributed to preservation itself?

  3. How are environment termination and resets incorporated into the continuing process used for long rollouts? What is the supported scope under behaviour-policy changes in fitted models? Please distinguish measured evidence from conditional theoretical guarantees.

1 comment

Dear Reviewer iMap,

As the discussion deadline approaches, we would be very grateful for any further thoughts or feedback on our rebuttal and additional experiments. We sincerely appreciate the time and effort you have devoted to reviewing our work and would be happy to address any remaining concerns or questions.

Best regards,

Authors

Reviewer_8LssOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper builds world models whose latent transitions preserve a standard Gaussian under the behavior policy. This makes the model’s long-run marginal available through static sampling. The authors provide preservation and convergence guarantees, then evaluate the approach on Lorenz dynamics and pixel-based control tasks. The main message is that marginal fidelity, convergence speed, and conditional prediction are separate properties.

Critical strengths

I like the clean construction and the distinction between what distribution a model approaches, how quickly it gets there, and how well it predicts transitions. Preserving behavior occupancy also makes more sense than requiring preservation at every fixed action. The controlled examples explain this well.

I also appreciate the transparent reporting. The authors report failed rollouts and planners, acknowledge unmatched baselines, and include a stronger DreamerV3 reference. This makes the evidence easier to judge.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The headline result mostly confirms a property built into the model. With exact preservation and the default reset mixture, agreement with the reference marginal at (10^5) steps is already guaranteed. The harder questions are whether that marginal is accurate and whether useful dynamics are retained. The current experiments do not give a convincing answer.
  2. Conditional prediction is weak, and simple controls are missing. Ten-step MSE is 0.1271 for occupancy versus 0.0708 for the Gaussian arm. On four tasks, DreamerV3 reaches 0.0024 versus 0.1206 for occupancy, although capacity and context differ. An i.i.d. reference sampler and a last-frame persistence baseline would help establish how much dynamics the model actually learns.
  3. The benefit of exact preservation is not isolated. None of the alternative model families passes the matching criteria. Meanwhile, output gains of 1.001 and 1.003 break exact preservation but retain full survival. A bounded or stabilized transition would be a useful control. DreamerV3 should also be evaluated at (10^5) steps, rather than stopping at (10^3).
  4. The guarantees offer limited support for planning. They concern a specified behavior policy and an exact action chart. The KL bound becomes vacuous for deterministic action selection, and policy shifts are not tested on fitted models. Occupancy also fails in 19/36 planning cells. These results leave its value for counterfactual prediction and control unclear.
  5. The theoretical novelty needs clearer positioning. The OU refresh and its entropy contraction are standard ingredients; the constant-coefficient update also underlies the pCN proposal. The contribution is mainly their combination with controlled occupancy and finite-initialization bounds. I would like a clearer account of what this combination adds beyond existing constructions.
Questions for authors
  1. How do an i.i.d. reference sampler and a last-frame persistence predictor perform under the same prediction protocol?
  2. What causes the CEM failures? Do near-boundary actions produce large action-chart innovations?
  3. How large are the reported reference energy statistics relative to appropriately matched held-out-data comparisons and sampling variability?
  4. How do DreamerV3 and a stabilized transition perform at (10^5) steps? Can the reset-free experiment cover all twelve tasks?
  5. What coefficients (c_i(b)) are learned, and how does the contraction cap affect prediction accuracy and temporal correlations?
  6. How would the method handle episodic resets or changing behavior policies?
1 comment

Dear Reviewer 8Lss,

As the discussion deadline approaches, we would be very grateful for any further thoughts or feedback on our rebuttal and additional experiments. We sincerely appreciate the time and effort you have devoted to reviewing our work and would be happy to address any remaining concerns or questions.

Best regards,

Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.