- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes EviGuardMorph, a coarse-to-fine deformable medical image registration framework. It aims to reduce frequency aliasing caused by downsampling and prevent the propagation of matching errors.The method contains two main modules. FBE uses scale-dependent Gaussian pre-filtering, dual structure-detail branches, and invertible feature coupling to build multi-scale matching evidence. BPBM uses matching entropy and forward-backward cycle consistency to weight bidirectional matching residuals. It also retains one-way matching as a baseline. The method does not require ground-truth deformation fields for supervision. It is evaluated on four datasets: IXI, LPBA40, ACDC, and AbdomenCT. The results are competitive in terms of Dice, HD95, and ASSD. Overall, the proposed framework shows potential and achieves competitive results. However, the link between frequency suppression and improved registration performance is not sufficiently validated. The ability of BPBM to identify incorrect correspondences also requires further investigation.
Critical strengths
-
This paper addresses frequency aliasing and incorrect matching in multi-scale image registration by proposing a framework that integrates frequency-aware feature extraction with reliability-guided bidirectional refinement. The overall design is well motivated and demonstrates a reasonable degree of innovation and research value.
-
The proposed method achieves the best average Dice scores and the lowest average HD95 values across four medical image datasets. The authors also conduct comprehensive experiments, including statistical significance tests, module ablation studies, frequency analysis, and failure case analysis, demonstrating strong registration performance and a certain degree of generalization capability. Furthermore, the method does not require ground-truth deformation fields or segmentation labels during training, which enhances its practical applicability.
Critical weaknesses
1.Although pre-filtering reduces out-of-band spectral energy by 90.4%–99.7%, the resulting Dice improvement is only 0.10 percentage points. The connection between spectral suppression and actual registration performance gains remains insufficiently established. Furthermore, there is insufficient evidence to demonstrate that BPBM offers substantial advantages over simpler confidence-weighting strategies.
2.The paper uses matching entropy and forward–backward cycle errors as indicators of correspondence reliability, but it does not establish that these metrics can accurately identify incorrect matches. The effectiveness of the reliability weights therefore remains insufficiently validated by direct evidence. Meanwhile, the improvements in registration accuracy are accompanied by relatively high deformation field folding rates, reaching 0.364% on IXI and 2.411% on AbdomenCT, both substantially higher than those of some competing methods. This suggests a potential trade-off between anatomical alignment accuracy and deformation plausibility.
Questions for authors
-
The paper reports a 90.4%–99.7% reduction in out-of-band spectral energy, yet Table 8 shows that fixed pre-filtering yields only an additional 0.10 percentage-point improvement in Dice. How can the discrepancy between spectral suppression and actual registration gains be explained? Does this suggest that spectral attenuation does not effectively improve anatomical correspondence?
-
The paper constructs reliability weights using local matching entropy and forward–backward cycle errors. However, these two indicators do not necessarily imply that the correspondences are correct. Do the existing experiments demonstrate a clear correlation between the proposed reliability weights and actual registration errors, and show that the weights can effectively identify incorrect matches?
-
Does BPBM provide substantive improvements beyond a simple confidence-weighting strategy?
Response to Reviewer Gmcj
Q1. Spectral suppression versus the Dice gain.
Response. The prefilter acts on the stability of the coarse displacement fields, which we now measure directly. We trained the full model and the model without the fixed prefilter with three seeds each and shifted both input images by one voxel. An alias-free pyramid would shift its displacement fields by exactly one voxel, so the remaining deviation measures aliasing. Reduction of this deviation with the prefilter (test pairs showing a reduction in brackets):
The reduction holds at every scale and in every seed (Wilcoxon p = 1.9 × 10^-9 on ACDC, p = 0.002 on LPBA), and it is largest at S5-S3, where aliasing is strongest. The spectral suppression therefore translates into markedly more shift-stable coarse fields. The prefilter adds 0.10 DSC points on ACDC and 0.11 on LPBA (three-seed means), with the full model higher in every seed. FBE as a whole also transfers to other networks:
We now summarize the shift-consistency results in Sec. 4.3 and provide the experimental details and full results in Appendix A.2.
Q2. Whether the reliability weights identify incorrect matches.
Response. We tested this in two ways, with labels that use no entropy, cycle error or R.
Real registration errors. On the test pairs, a location is labelled incorrect when the segmentation warped by the ungated candidate disagrees with the fixed segmentation on more than half of its foreground voxels. The AUROC of 1 - R is 0.740 on ACDC and 0.759 on LPBA at S3, and 0.628 and 0.698 at S2, against 0.50 when R is shuffled. It is higher than entropy alone or cycle error alone at both scales on both datasets.
Regions without a valid correspondence. Test images are warped by a known smooth field, and 32^3 blocks of the fixed image are given no counterpart in the moving image, by shuffling their voxels (Shuffle) or inserting anatomy from another subject (Foreign). AUROC (mean ± SD, three seeds):
1 - R separates invalid from valid locations at S4 and S3 (0.70-0.96), while R randomly permuted across locations stays at chance (0.48-0.51). The response is weaker at S5 and at S2 on LPBA, indicating that the sensitivity of R depends to some extent on the anatomy and the scale.
Q3. BPBM versus simple confidence weighting.
Response. To compare BPBM with simple confidence weighting, we replaced its reliability weight with a fixed blend (R ≡ 1), entropy-only or cycle-only weighting, changing only the S5-S2 update:
Full BPBM has the highest DSC and the lowest folding on both datasets. On LPBA a fixed blend falls below the one-way baseline in DSC and raises folding, whereas the reliability weight turns the same bidirectional candidate into a gain. Neither entropy nor cycle error alone achieves this.
Folding rates. All methods were trained with the same smoothness-loss weight, not tuned per method, so the folding rates compare the architectures at a common regularization level. Against SACB-Net, the strongest baseline, our DSC advantage comes with lower folding on AbdomenCT (2.41% vs. 3.07%) and ACDC (0.016% vs. 0.070%). RDP and ModeT have lower folding on AbdomenCT (0.34% and 0.56%) but also lower DSC, by 2.07 and 6.81 points. Folding can be traded against DSC through the smoothness weight, and we will discuss this in the revision.