- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RAGE-I2P for image-to-point cloud registration in changing environments. It uses normal-derived geometric embeddings to improve coarse- and fine-level correspondence reliability, and introduces two benchmarks for evaluation. Experiments show consistent improvements over recent baselines in correspondence quality and registration recall.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practically relevant problem. Image-to-point cloud registration under changing environments is important for long-term localization and robotic perception. The paper clearly motivates why appearance similarity alone can become unreliable when objects are moved, removed, or newly introduced.
- The experimental evaluation is reasonably comprehensive. The method is evaluated on both a synthetically modified benchmark and a newly collected real-world dataset, with ablation studies and efficiency analysis. The proposed method also shows consistent improvements over several recent baselines in correspondence quality and registration recall.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty appears relatively limited. The proposed framework mainly extends an existing coarse-to-fine I2P registration pipeline by introducing normal-derived geometric embeddings, geometric compatibility weighting, and an additional embedding loss. Although these components are reasonable, the overall technical advance appears incremental rather than fundamentally different from existing geometry-aware correspondence learning approaches. This is the main factor limiting my overall assessment.
- The evidence for generalization to diverse real-world changing environments is still limited. The real-world ASIMLab benchmark contains only seven scenes and is restricted to tabletop regions, while Changing RGBDScenesV2 is constructed through synthetic image editing. Therefore, although the reported improvements are encouraging, it remains unclear how robustly the method generalizes to more diverse and complex real-world scene changes.
Questions for authors
- Clarification on methodological novelty: Could the authors clarify more explicitly what the key technical distinction is between RAGE-I2P and existing geometry-aware or normal-guided correspondence learning methods? In particular, which component should be regarded as the main methodological contribution beyond incorporating normal-derived geometric information into a coarse-to-fine registration framework?
- Clarification on the source of performance gains: Table 3 shows that adding DSINE normals to 2D3D-MATR already improves RR substantially from 25.8% to 44.2%, while the full RAGE-I2P further improves it to 49.8%. Could the authors clarify how much of the overall improvement should be attributed to the proposed reliability-aware geometric modeling rather than to the strong pretrained normal prior itself?