acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

FineStyler: Towards Detail-Preserving Video Stylization

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Reference-based video stylization transfers the style of a reference image to an input video while preserving its content and motion. Existing video diffusion methods often rely on overly compressed style representations and coarse structural conditioning, leading to washed-out micro-style details, reference content leakage, and temporal drift of fine structures. We present FineStyler, a single-stage inference framework for high-fidelity, temporally stable video stylization with a single style reference image. First, Content-Anchored Style Modulation aligns learned style embeddings to a natural-image feature domain, encouraging fine-grained texture encoding while suppressing instance-specific content leakage. Second, High-Frequency Adapted LoRA injects input-video high-frequency cues into DiT self-attention through a parameter-efficient adapter, preserving thin edges and local geometry beyond silhouette-level controls. Third, a style reference image curation pipeline synthesizes style-aligned yet content-mismatched references from paired raw and stylized videos using image stylization models, then selects high-quality references through automatic scoring to enable training that matches the inference interface. Extensive experiments demonstrate that FineStyler improves style faithfulness, content preservation, and temporal stability over prior diffusion-based baselines, producing sharper structures and higher perceptual quality in challenging content-mismatched reference settings.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Video Stylization, Controllable Generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_5vosOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces FineStyler, a reference-based video stylization framework built upon a pretrained video Diffusion Transformer (DiT). It consists of two main components: Content-Anchored Style Modulation (CA-SM), which aims to learn fine-grained, content-invariant style representations through cross-content stylization supervision and natural-image latent alignment, and High-Frequency Adapted LoRA (HF-LoRA), which injects high-frequency features from the source video into DiT self-attention to preserve local geometric structures and fine details.

Critical strengths

This work clearly distinguishes two key challenges in video stylization: style representation learning and content structure preservation, and proposes targeted solutions to address the limitations of existing methods. For CA-SM, the authors thoughtfully combine cross-content stylization supervision with natural-image latent alignment to encourage the learning of fine-grained, content-invariant style representations. For HF-LoRA, the authors introduce a lightweight, high-frequency-aware LoRA branch that injects structural cues from the source video into DiT self-attention, aiming to preserve fine details and local geometry. Overall, the paper is well-motivated and clearly presented, with a coherent methodology that directly addresses the identified challenges. The experimental results demonstrate promising improvements in style fidelity and content preservation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. In the experiments section, authors compare the proposed method with StyleCrafter, StyleMaster, and AnyV2V. Although the Related Work section mentions FreeViS, DreamStyle, and TeleStyle, the experimental section lacks a sufficient comparison with them.
  2. CA-SM is essentially an image-based style representation learning module. The paper does not explicitly discuss whether CA-SM achieves superior style representation compared to existing approaches in image style transfer, or it just simply applies a reasonable image-based style extraction strategy to the context of video stylization.
  3. Authors claim that CA-SM can learn content-invariant style representations. But there isn't enough evidence showing that style tokens do not contain content information. The existing results only prove that CA-SM improves style fidelity.
  4. There is a clear trade-off in the Ablation Study: "HF-LoRA only" has lower subject consistency, while the combined method yields even lower DINO scores than "HF-LoRA only." Although the authors claim that HF-LoRA improves temporal consistency, the ablation results do not consistently support this claim. The authors didn‘t explain this in the paper.
  5. The statistical analysis and protocol reporting regarding the user study are insufficient.
Questions for authors
  1. The experimental section lacks sufficient comparison with FreeViS, DreamStyle, and TeleStyle. The authors should either conduct additional experiments or provide a convincing explanation as to why these baselines were not included in the comparison.
  2. Authors are recommended to include a comparison and discussion regarding existing style representation methods and isolate the specific contribution of the mechanism they claim to be novel.
  3. Authors are suggested to add more experiment results to show that CA-SM can learn content-invariant style representations
  4. The authors need to clearly explain the trade-off involved in the ablation and provide a more direct assessment of temporal consistency.

If the authors provide sufficient evidence demonstrating: 1) the work's SOTA performance compared to other existing baselines; 2) the advantages of CA-SM over other style representations; 3) whether CA-SM achieves the content invariance claimed in the paper; 4) an explanation of the trade-offs observed in the ablation studies, I will raise my score accordingly.

Reviewer_EUN6OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a reference-based video stylization framework called FineStyler, which aims to improve style fidelity while preserving content details and temporal consistency. FineStyler consists of three key components: Content-Anchored Style Modulation (CA-SM) for learning fine-grained style representations, High-Frequency Adapted LoRA (HF-LoRA) for preserving local structures, and a style reference image curation pipeline for constructing content-mismatched training references.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper aims to address the loss of fine-grained style details and structural inconsistencies in video stylization, which are meaningful and challenging problems.

  2. The proposed method combines content-anchored style learning with high-frequency structural guidance to improve style fidelity and content preservation.

  3. Extensive experiments, including quantitative comparisons, ablation studies, and a user study, are conducted to evaluate the performance of the proposed method.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The scale of the constructed style reference image dataset is not reported. Although the paper describes the data generation and filtering pipeline in Section 3.3, it remains unclear how many reference images are included in the final training set and how many different styles are covered. More detailed statistics of the constructed dataset should be provided.

  2. Only three baseline methods are selected for comparison, which is insufficient. More recent video style transfer methods, such as UniVST [1], DreamStyle [2], and FreeVis [3], are not included in the experiments.
    [1] UniVST: A unified framework for training-free localized video style transfer. TPAMI 2025.
    [2] DreamStyle: A Unified Framework for Video Stylization. CVPR 2026.
    [3] FreeViS: Training-free Video Stylization with Inconsistent References. ICLR 2026.

  3. The qualitative results are not very satisfactory. As shown in Figure 5, the generated results in the first and fourth examples exhibit noticeable style differences from the corresponding reference images. Moreover, the colors of the generated results generally appear oversaturated.

  4. The evaluation of temporal consistency is not convincing enough. Although the paper emphasizes preserving fine-grained details across frames, the adopted VBench metrics cannot directly measure temporal flickering or structural drift. More specific temporal consistency metrics, such as optical-flow-based warping error, should be considered.

  5. Some implementation details are unclear. For example, Eq. (6) retains the low-frequency component, while the subsequent description states that the low-frequency component is removed. The authors should clarify the exact high-frequency filtering strategy and provide more details about the relevant hyperparameters.

  6. The user study involves only 18 participants and 10 questions per criterion, which may be insufficient to support the claimed improvements in human preference.

Questions for authors

Please see Weaknesses.

Others:

What is the time efficiency of different methods? Some evaluations regarding this should be conducted.

Reviewer_32HkOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents FineStyler, a reference-image-guided video stylization framework built on Wan2.1. It introduces Content-Anchored Style Modulation (CA-SM), which combines natural-image latent reconstruction with cross-content stylization supervision, and High-Frequency Adapted LoRA (HF-LoRA), which injects source-video high-frequency features into self-attention. The authors also construct content-mismatched style references for training. The framework uses two training stages and single-stage inference. Experiments report improvements in style similarity and content similarity over the evaluated baselines.

Critical strengths
  • The reported aggregate results are promising. Compared with StyleMaster, FineStyler improves CSD from 0.352 to 0.419 and DINO similarity from 0.286 to 0.422. The user study also reports a preference for FineStyler. These results suggest practical potential on the evaluated benchmark, although they do not establish the claimed fine-grained preservation capabilities.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Claim–Result Inconsistency: The supplementary results do not sufficiently support the claimed content and fine-structure preservation. In demo 4, the hand approaching the mouth is incorrectly reconstructed. In demo 5, utensils and hand–object relationships disappear, changing the visual interpretation of the eating activity. In demo 9, the children’s body shapes are substantially altered and eyeglasses are lost. Mouth movements and facial expressions are also modified in demos 1, 3, and 10. These failures affect semantic content and local geometry, beyond reasonable changes in rendering style. This discrepancy is particularly concerning because preserving these details is the central motivation of the paper.
  2. Content–Style Disentanglement Validation: The reconstruction loss in Eq. (2) constrains the transformed image latent, but does not directly prevent the style tokens from retaining reference content. Therefore, the claimed connection between natural-image reconstruction and content-invariant style representations remains insufficiently justified. The current CA-SM ablation does not isolate the reconstruction loss from changes in architecture and supervision. An otherwise identical model trained without this loss, together with direct evaluation of reference-content leakage, is necessary to establish the proposed mechanism.
  3. High-Frequency Conditioning Validation: HF-LoRA introduces an additional source-conditioning branch compared with standard LoRA. The improvement could therefore come from access to source-video information rather than its high-frequency components specifically. Comparisons with full-latent and low-frequency conditioning under the same adapter architecture are missing. Moreover, Eq. (6) retains the low-frequency term in FH,αF^{H,\alpha}, whereas the subsequent text describes constructing h=zH,αh=z^{H,\alpha} by removing low frequencies. The claimed timestep-adaptive injection is also unclear because the gate’s dependence on the denoising timestep is not specified.
  4. Experimental Alignment and Ablation Validity: The reported metrics do not adequately establish preservation of source-video details and motion. Higher Dynamic Degree does not necessarily indicate more faithful motion, and output temporal consistency can remain high despite consistently incorrect expressions or structures. Table 2 further shows that HF-LoRA alone decreases Subject Consistency from 0.948 to 0.915, which requires reconciliation with its claimed temporal benefits. Additionally, it is unclear whether all ablation variants use identical backbone versions, training data, curated references, and training budgets. These ambiguities weaken the attribution of improvements to the proposed modules.
  5. Contemporary Competitiveness and Novelty: The comparison omits TeleStyle, despite its public release of image/video inference code and pretrained models in January 2026. TeleStyle’s video module uses Wan2.1-1.3B, making its complete stylization pipeline a particularly relevant baseline. Its reliance on a stylized first frame is not a sufficient reason for exclusion, since AnyV2V is already evaluated using a first-frame editing stage. DreamStyle’s unavailable implementation can reasonably explain its omission, but this explanation does not apply to TeleStyle. Without comparison against recent methods addressing the same content-preservation and style-consistency problems, the paper does not clearly establish its incremental contribution. Furthermore, the practical advantage of single-stage inference remains unsubstantiated without end-to-end runtime and memory comparisons.
  6. Backbone Choice and Comparison with General-Purpose Models: The evaluation is restricted to Wan2.1-T2V-1.3B, leaving it unclear whether the identified limitations and the benefits of the proposed modules persist with stronger backbones such as Wan2.2. The choice of backbone and the scope of the conclusions require better justification. Moreover, MiniMax H3-Base-Ref2VA supports image/video reference conditioning and source-video editing, making it a relevant general-purpose baseline for reference-guided video stylization. The paper does not establish whether its specialized style modulation and high-frequency adapters offer advantages over the capabilities of such models. A comparison using the same source videos and style references, with the model configuration and inference costs clearly reported, would help establish the method’s practical contribution.
Questions for authors

See weakness.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.