- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces FineStyler, a reference-based video stylization framework built upon a pretrained video Diffusion Transformer (DiT). It consists of two main components: Content-Anchored Style Modulation (CA-SM), which aims to learn fine-grained, content-invariant style representations through cross-content stylization supervision and natural-image latent alignment, and High-Frequency Adapted LoRA (HF-LoRA), which injects high-frequency features from the source video into DiT self-attention to preserve local geometric structures and fine details.
Critical strengths
This work clearly distinguishes two key challenges in video stylization: style representation learning and content structure preservation, and proposes targeted solutions to address the limitations of existing methods. For CA-SM, the authors thoughtfully combine cross-content stylization supervision with natural-image latent alignment to encourage the learning of fine-grained, content-invariant style representations. For HF-LoRA, the authors introduce a lightweight, high-frequency-aware LoRA branch that injects structural cues from the source video into DiT self-attention, aiming to preserve fine details and local geometry. Overall, the paper is well-motivated and clearly presented, with a coherent methodology that directly addresses the identified challenges. The experimental results demonstrate promising improvements in style fidelity and content preservation.
Critical weaknesses
- In the experiments section, authors compare the proposed method with StyleCrafter, StyleMaster, and AnyV2V. Although the Related Work section mentions FreeViS, DreamStyle, and TeleStyle, the experimental section lacks a sufficient comparison with them.
- CA-SM is essentially an image-based style representation learning module. The paper does not explicitly discuss whether CA-SM achieves superior style representation compared to existing approaches in image style transfer, or it just simply applies a reasonable image-based style extraction strategy to the context of video stylization.
- Authors claim that CA-SM can learn content-invariant style representations. But there isn't enough evidence showing that style tokens do not contain content information. The existing results only prove that CA-SM improves style fidelity.
- There is a clear trade-off in the Ablation Study: "HF-LoRA only" has lower subject consistency, while the combined method yields even lower DINO scores than "HF-LoRA only." Although the authors claim that HF-LoRA improves temporal consistency, the ablation results do not consistently support this claim. The authors didn‘t explain this in the paper.
- The statistical analysis and protocol reporting regarding the user study are insufficient.
Questions for authors
- The experimental section lacks sufficient comparison with FreeViS, DreamStyle, and TeleStyle. The authors should either conduct additional experiments or provide a convincing explanation as to why these baselines were not included in the comparison.
- Authors are recommended to include a comparison and discussion regarding existing style representation methods and isolate the specific contribution of the mechanism they claim to be novel.
- Authors are suggested to add more experiment results to show that CA-SM can learn content-invariant style representations
- The authors need to clearly explain the trade-off involved in the ablation and provide a more direct assessment of temporal consistency.
If the authors provide sufficient evidence demonstrating: 1) the work's SOTA performance compared to other existing baselines; 2) the advantages of CA-SM over other style representations; 3) whether CA-SM achieves the content invariance claimed in the paper; 4) an explanation of the trade-offs observed in the ablation studies, I will raise my score accordingly.