- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates a temporal alignment problem in script-driven joint audio-video generation. While existing models can produce synchronized audio and visual content, they often fail to follow the precise shot boundaries and dialogue intervals specified in structured scripts. The authors identify this missing alignment between script timing and generated modalities as a key limitation of current approaches.
To address this issue, the paper proposes Temporal Context Routing (TCR), which explicitly maps the temporal intervals of individual script prompts to the corresponding positions in video and audio generation. Specifically, TCR introduces duration-normalized temporal biases into the video-text and audio-text cross-attention logits, enabling independent temporal control of potentially overlapping shot and dialogue prompts. The method is implemented on LTX-2.3 without introducing additional learnable parameters in the routing mechanism. The authors also develop a coarse-to-fine data construction pipeline that combines Gemini-generated script annotations with shot detection and speech alignment to provide refined temporal supervision.
Experiments on 200 test scripts demonstrate substantial improvements in temporal accuracy. Compared with LTX-2.3, TCR reduces Shot Boundary MAE from 1.11 s to 0.042 s and improves Dialogue [email protected] from 28.3% to 84.1%, while maintaining competitive visual quality and audio-visual synchronization. Controlled comparisons, ablation studies, and human evaluations further support the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
Critical strengths
-
The paper identifies an important distinction between audio-video synchronization and script-level temporal alignment. The motivation is convincing and establishes a clear connection between the identified limitation and the proposed solution.
-
The method's additive formulation is simple, parameter-free, and compatible with the existing joint generation architecture. The independent routing of shot and dialogue prompts is also well suited to scenarios where their temporal intervals overlap.
-
The reported results demonstrate substantial improvements. The coarse-to-fine data construction pipeline addresses an important practical challenge: obtaining sufficiently accurate temporal annotations for training. The improvements in temporal accuracy do not appear to come at a substantial cost to visual quality or audio-visual synchronization.
Critical weaknesses
-
Potential limitations of center-decayed temporal routing for long-range consistency. TCR applies a center-decayed temporal bias to all prompts, which may weaken their influence beyond the assigned intervals. However, some events have persistent effects across subsequent shots. For example, if a character changes clothes in one shot, the new appearance should remain consistent in later shots, even as the corresponding prompt is suppressed. Similarly, Global prompts may require consistent influence throughout the video rather than stronger guidance near the temporal center.
-
Insufficient analysis of routing strength and the relative contributions of the temporal design choices. The routing strength β is fixed to 5 based on a heuristic endpoint-retention interpretation. However, the paper does not provide a systematic sensitivity analysis of this parameter. Since TCR uses a center-peaked temporal profile, the guidance of a prompt is substantially attenuated near its assigned boundaries.
-
Incomplete coverage of closely related recent work. The paper overlooks MAVIN (ECCV 2026), a highly relevant prior work on script-driven multi-shot audio-video generation. MAVIN introduces boundary-aware token routing to explicitly control shot transitions and dialogue intervals through temporal constraints in cross-attention. This is closely related to the central motivation and mechanism of TCR. Furthermore, the paper does not discuss recent evaluation frameworks such as MSAVBench (2026), which specifically targets multi-shot audio-video generation and addresses the reliability of automatic shot segmentation.
-
Insufficient transparency and verifiability of the human evaluation. Figure 8 appears to be a manually composed or illustrative interface rather than an actual screenshot of the user study, raising concerns about the verifiability of the evaluation procedure. In particular, the figure consists of individually editable elements, suggesting that it was constructed using a drawing tool rather than directly captured from a functional user-study interface. Moreover, it does not clearly show functional video playback or interactive rating controls.
-
Potential confounding factors in the main baseline comparisons. The main comparison reports a substantial improvement over the original LTX-2.3 model. However, TCR is trained using LoRA adaptation on 57,022 curated examples with refined temporal annotations. It is therefore difficult to determine how much of the improvement comes specifically from the proposed routing mechanism rather than from task-specific adaptation and additional training data.
Questions for authors
-
Since center-decayed temporal bias may weaken the influence of prompts beyond the assigned intervals, how does TCR preserve such long-range dependencies and global consistency? The authors are encouraged to provide further analysis or experiments addressing this concern.
-
Since systematic analysis of strength β is not included, it would be useful to investigate how the routing strength affects shot transitions, dialogue onset and offset accuracy, and overall generation quality.
-
Could the authors clarify whether Figure 8 represents the actual interface used by the 28 participants? Providing authentic interface screenshots or anonymized participant-level responses would help substantiate the reported user study results.
-
Could the authors clarify the novelty of TCR compared with MAVIN (ECCV 2026), particularly regarding their temporal routing mechanisms for shot and dialogue control? A direct comparison with MAVIN, if feasible, would help establish the advantages of TCR. Additionally, the authors are encouraged to discuss MSAVBench (2026) and consider its evaluation protocol to further validate the reliability of the reported temporal accuracy.
-
Please provide an evaluation which would include an LTX-2.3 baseline fine-tuned on exactly the same refined dataset, using the same LoRA configuration and optimization schedule, but retaining the temporal information only in the textual prompt. This would more directly isolate the benefits of explicit temporal routing.
5 comments
Response to Reviewer RcJH(2/2)
We continue with related work, the user study, and the matched LoRA baseline.
Q4 / Weakness 3: MAVIN and MSAVBench
Thank you for highlighting these closely related works. We will cite and discuss both MAVIN and MSAVBench in the revised manuscript, explicitly explaining their relationship to TCR.
MAVIN and TCR both use temporal information in text attention, but their routing operators differ. MAVIN uses binary temporal visibility through an additive log-mask: permitted tokens remain visible, while excluded tokens receive zero attention. TCR instead introduces a finite, smooth, duration-normalized temporal bias, evaluated on the physical timelines of both video and audio.
TCR's contribution is this soft temporal operator and its integration into joint generation. Our matched hard-mask ablation compares the binary-routing principle with TCR on the same backbone and training setup: Shot B-MAE improves from 0.108 s to 0.042 s, while Dialogue [email protected] is 83.7% and 84.1%, respectively. This is an operator comparison; a direct comparison with the complete MAVIN system requires its implementation and checkpoints, which its official repository currently lists as forthcoming.
We will discuss MSAVBench as a recent benchmark currently under review, particularly its analysis of shot-segmentation reliability. Its official GitHub repository still lists evaluation-code release as pending.
To address your concern about segmentation reliability, we additionally evaluate raw TransNetV2 cuts without VLM boundary correction, using one-to-one cut matching within a 0.2 s tolerance:
| Method | Cut [email protected] ↑ |
|---|---|
| Native LTX-2.3 | 10.05% |
| TCR | 95.31% |
This metric accounts for both missed and extra cuts. Scores are averaged over 188 scripts where F1 is defined; the remaining 12 contain neither requested nor detected cuts. The substantial improvement provides additional evidence that TCR follows the requested shot timeline using a different boundary detector, without relying on VLM boundary correction.
Q3 / Weakness 4: User-study interface and procedure
Figure 8 depicts the interface used in the actual user study. The study involves 28 participants and 16 randomly sampled cases, with eight comparisons against LTX-2.3 and eight against JoyAI-Echo. Each participant completes all 16 comparisons.
Videos are presented anonymously as A/B, with balanced side assignment. Participants independently select A, Tie, or B for shot timing, dialogue timing, script fidelity, audio-visual synchronization, and overall preference. Ties remain in the denominator when reporting vote shares.
We will clarify the figure caption and add direct interface screenshots showing video playback and the rating controls, making the operational study setup explicit.
Q5 / Weakness 5: Separating LoRA adaptation from temporal routing
The “Intervals as text” baseline is LoRA-fine-tuned using exactly the same refined dataset, LoRA configuration, and optimization schedule as TCR. It retains shot and dialogue timestamps in the textual prompt and applies no explicit temporal routing.
Both use 57,022 refined examples, LoRA rank/alpha 128/128, and the same learning-rate schedule and 7,000-step checkpoint. The results reported in the paper are:
| Conditioning method | Shot B-MAE ↓ | Dialogue [email protected] ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| LoRA baseline (Intervals as text) | 0.601 s | 43.8% |
| TCR | 0.042 s | 84.1% |
TCR reduces shot-boundary error by 93.0% and improves dialogue accuracy by 40.3 percentage points over direct LoRA training on timed scripts. This comparison demonstrates gains beyond task-specific adaptation and refined supervision. We will make the matched training configuration explicit in the table caption and implementation details.
Official Comment by Reviewer RcJH
Thanks to the authors for the rebuttal and additional experiments. While most of my technical questions have been addressed, I still have two remaining concerns:
- I am still not comfortable with Figure 8. It clearly looks like a rough mockup rather than an real screenshot of a functional interface, which should be easy to capture directly if the user study was actually run. Promising to add real screenshots later in the revision does not fully resolve my doubt about the credibility of the user study during current discussion phase. Providing anonymized participant-level response data or actual interface would be much more convincing.
- Setting the routing bias of Global tokens to zero addresses the attenuation of clip-wide context, but it still misses my main point about persistent state changes across shots (e.g., a character changing clothes in Shot 1 and keeping that new look in later shots). The recommended Evidence Sent demo only shows a static scene and appearance across cuts, without dynamic state change. More concrete analysis or examples on how TCR preserves such state changes once the earlier shot prompt decays would be helpful.
Response to Reviewer RcJH(1/2)
We sincerely appreciate your careful reading and constructive feedback, as well as your recognition of the problem's importance, the method's simplicity, and the empirical results. We address your concerns below.
We have uploaded additional supplementary demos illustrating how local temporal control interacts with shared context across shots. We particularly recommend Evidence Sent under Coordinated A/V Moments.
Its six-shot script moves from the investigator to her hands, back to her face, then to the keyboard and phone, before returning to the investigator in 6.8–10.0 s. These shots share the same office setting and green practical-light style, while typing, the Enter-key click, the send notification, and phone vibration occupy independently specified intervals. The example allows you to inspect cross-shot continuity alongside localized event scheduling.
Mechanistically, TCR modifies direct text conditioning while preserving the backbone's temporal self-attention and audio-video interaction pathways. Attenuating a local prompt does not explicitly reset the latent state or impose a barrier between successive shots. We will clarify this distinction between the temporal scope of direct conditioning and contextual interactions within the generated sequence.
For Global prompts, the original implementation assigns the entire clip interval [0, T], with a center-weighted prior. To directly examine your concern, we additionally tested setting Global-token routing biases to zero, while retaining local routing and holding model weights fixed. This makes the Global temporal prior constant while preserving query-dependent semantic attention. Across 200 scripts, changes relative to routed Global prompts in this supplementary evaluation are:
This provides a concrete implementation and evaluation of a uniform temporal prior for Global prompts combined with localized temporal routing. We will include this analysis and distinguish the roles of global context, local event timing, and persistent state descriptions.
We additionally examine routing strength through supplementary evaluations at alternative β values. We report the original paper's β=5 configuration below:
Our adopted β=5 achieves precise shot and dialogue timing while maintaining competitive visual quality. The alternative settings provide additional evidence that routing strength affects temporal adherence. We distinguish the original paper's results from the supplementary evaluations.
The endpoint-retention interpretation concerns the multiplicative temporal factor, whose endpoint-to-center ratio is approximately 8.2% at β=5. Actual normalized attention additionally depends on query-dependent semantic scores and competition among prompts.
The paper separately compares TCR, Gaussian Interval RoPE, and hard masking under matched training settings. Shot B-MAE is 0.042 s, versus 0.113 s and 0.108 s, respectively. This controlled comparison supports the complete routing design, complementing the analysis of routing strength.
Our responses to Q3–Q5 continue in Part 2.