- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors introduce NVCode, an EEG-to-fMRI synthesis model trained using a two-stage approach:
-
Training ROI-specific EEG encoders (for 6 pre-selected brain ROIs, and one global signal), in order to learn latent EEG representations per ROI. This is done using supervised EEG-fMRI pairs recorded simultaneously.
-
Jointly train: (i) an EEG-representation projector on the concatenated learned EEG hidden features from Stage-1, to generate a “NeuroVascular code”; and (ii) an fMRI generator from noise using stochastic interpolation, conditioned on the learned “NeuroVascular code”. This stage generates the final fMRI signal.
The authors claim to learn a good representation of EEG, that supports high-accuracy fMRI generation. The model’s performance is evaluated on eight datasets separately, under both inter-subject and intra-subject settings. However, only separate components of the method (their EEG encoders, and the conditional generator) are compared against previous methods. Their end-to-end fMRI prediction from EEG (which is the stated goal of this model) is never compared against any of the competing methods.
Critical strengths
- The paper introduces “neurovascular codes” to condition fMRI generators.
- Evaluation and comparison of subcomponents of the architecture.
Critical weaknesses
- Important details and critical references are missing:
-
The fact that the mean fMRI signals of only 6 brain ROIs (+ one global) are being recovered by the proposed method is not mentioned explicitly anywhere in the main paper. It is implicitly hidden in Figs. 3 and 5 (using the strange term “target”, instead of “brain-ROI”). Note that recovering only 6 (+1) ROIs is in sharp contrast to previous full-brain SotA EEG2fMRI methods (e.g., UnEBOLT – see [1] below), which simultaneously predict fMRI activations of all brain-ROIs (up to 256). These full-brain methods are neither mentioned in the current paper, nor compared against.
-
The current method trains a separate EEG Encoder model for each of the 6 ROIs (+global signal). While this is feasible for 7 targets, it is unclear how this design will scale up to full brain settings with 64, 128 or 256 brain ROIs. Moreover, the claimed contribution of the authors regarding their NVcode being an important shared EEG representation across the 6 ROIs seems somewhat overstated, given that the full-brain EEG-to-fMRI methods learn a shared representation across all brain-ROIs.
-
Important missing/unclear details: (i) The EEG window size is not specified anywhere in the main paper. (ii) The exact definition of an “fMRI target” is never defined in the main paper. In particular, it is never mentioned that each “target” is a regional BOLD signal corresponding to a selected brain ROI, and that “N targets” is only N = 7, consisting of 6 ROIs plus one global signal. (iii) The experimental setting is very unclear – it is not clear from the main paper whether the Mean Pearson Correlation R in Table-1 is computed across time or not, nor what it is averaged across -- across targets? across subjects? splits? datasets? random seeds? Such important details must appear in the main body of the paper and cannot be hidden somewhere in the appendix.
- Lack of empirical comparison to prior work: There is no comparison of the full EEG-to-fMRI prediction accuracy of the proposed model against previous EEG-to-fMRI methods. Only partial/individual components of the model are ablated/compared, but not the end-to-end EEG2fMRI prediction. Without such a comparison, it is impossible to assess the performance of the method or the importance of the proposed NVcode. For this paper to be published, such end-to-end results vs. state-of-the-art competitive models (on the same datasets and configurations) must be added.
[1] UnEBOLT: A Unified Model for EEG-to-BOLD Translation and Functional Connectivity Reconstruction Yamin Li, Ange Lou, Chang Li, Shiyu Wang, Haatef Pourmotabbed, Ziyuan Xu, Shengchao Zhang, Dario J. Englot, Soheil Kolouri, Daniel Moyer, Roza G. Bayrak, Catie Chang Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Medical Imaging with Deep Learning, PMLR 315:2338-2351, 2026.
Questions for authors
-
Please compare NVCode’s end-to-end fMRI prediction with UnEBOLT (Li et al., 2026), NeuroBOLT (Li et al., 2025), and other recent end-to-end EEG-to-fMRI methods, under the same dataset and training/evaluation configuration used by these prior methods.
-
Could you clarify your claim about broader “cross-modal representation learning” capability? How is this demonstrated? Since the EEG representations are learned using fMRI prediction and then evaluated again on EEG-to-fMRI generation, do you have evidence that these representations transfer to a different task, dataset, or modality?
-
Did you experiment with jointly training your model on all 8 datasets together? How do these results compare to the results of your individually-trained models per dataset, which you then average across all models?
-
Did you evaluate zero-shot or transfer-learning generalization across datasets or tasks? If so, how well do the learned representations transfer without retraining or with limited fine-tuning? (such results are reported in previous EEG2fMRI papers).