- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tackles the problem of how to denoise and generate the observation in interactive world models when a new action is received during the rollout within an ongoing chunk. First, I question the fundamental motivation of this paper, as it appears to formulate a problem that lacks necessity. In interactive world models, generation naturally proceeds sequentially. The model receives an action, completes the rollout conditioned on it, and subsequently awaits the next input. I fail to see any practical justification for interrupting or altering the action during the rollout within an ongoing chunk.
Furthermore, the manuscript suffers from severe presentation issues. To point a few (the paper has many other issues):
-
The proposed method is inadequately described in the main text. Specifically, both the training pipeline and the inference usage of the "CORRECTOR" module remain largely incomprehensible.
-
The model (HY-World 1.5) is referred to interchangeably and inconsistently throughout the text (e.g., using terms like "WorldPlay" and "HY-WorldPlay" without clarification).
-
The paper repeatedly mentions the 'HY-WorldPlay benchmark', yet fails to clearly define what it is or provide citations.
-
The authors discuss and compare methods in "Inference-time reuse and acceleration." This entire line of literature is completely orthogonal to the problem the paper claims to solve.
In conclusion, this submission falls far below the standards of peer review. I recommend an unequivocal Reject, and I strongly recommend the Program Committee to strictly punish such irresponsible, unpolished submissions to preserve the integrity of the review process.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
None