- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PrimeSeeker, a capability-oriented framework for training deep search agents. Instead of constructing questions based primarily on global complexity, it introduces latent anchor reasoning, consisting of anchor resolution and relation transfer. The framework jointly constructs questions and reference evidence skeletons, which are reused for evidence-guided expert generation and reference-step rewards during reinforcement learning. Experiments on five benchmarks demonstrate competitive performance and improved search efficiency under fixed interaction budgets.
Critical strengths
- Capability-oriented formulation. The paper introduces a meaningful perspective on search-agent supervision by focusing on latent anchor resolution and relation transfer rather than relying solely on question complexity.
- Reusable evidence supervision. The reference evidence skeleton provides a unified mechanism for guiding expert generation and rewarding intermediate evidence discovery during RL.
- Useful experimental analysis. The paper includes controlled comparisons of expert guidance and RL rewards, as well as search-efficiency evaluations under shared interaction budgets.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient validation of capability-oriented supervision. The paper lacks a controlled comparison demonstrating that latent anchor reasoning improves training over conventional multi-hop question construction.
- Unclear reliability and effectiveness of reference-step rewards. The LLM-based evidence auditor is not independently validated, and fixed reference skeletons may overlook alternative valid search paths. Moreover, Dq-based RL underperforms outcome-only RL on BrowseComp-ZH (42.3% vs. 47.5%), raising concerns about reward reliability and robustness.
- Oracle-assisted efficiency evaluation. The budgeted evaluation stops when an answer matches the ground truth, which does not reflect realistic deployment without an oracle.
- Limited statistical reliability. BrowseComp evaluations use only 200 questions per language, without confidence intervals or significance tests. Given the high variance of search benchmarks, the reliability of small improvements remains unclear.
Questions for authors
- Capability-oriented supervision. Could the authors provide a controlled comparison or capability-specific evaluation to demonstrate the advantages of latent anchor reasoning over conventional multi-hop question construction?
- Reward reliability and robustness. How accurate is the LLM-based reference-step auditor, especially when agents follow alternative valid search paths? What explains the performance degradation on BrowseComp-ZH compared with outcome-only RL?
- Practical search efficiency. How does PrimeSeeker perform without ground-truth-based stopping? Could the authors report accuracy and inference costs under a realistic stopping criterion?
- Statistical significance. Could the authors report confidence intervals or statistical significance tests for the performance improvements, particularly on the 200-question BrowseComp subsets?