acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

PrimeSeeker: Capability-Oriented Supervision for Deep Search Agents

Abstract

Large language model search agents are often trained with synthetic questions whose difficulty is increased through larger evidence graphs, additional hops, and longer trajectories. These global properties, however, are only indirect proxies for the local retrieval capabilities required during search. To address this mismatch, we introduce latent anchor reasoning, which consists of resolving an unnamed retrieval anchor from descriptive specifications and transferring the recovered anchor into a subsequent information demand. This primitive retrieval unit decomposes deep search into chains of coupled operations and enables direct supervision of the two constituent operations, anchor resolution and relation transfer, without prescribing a canonical search path. Based on this formulation, we propose PrimeSeeker, a capability-oriented framework that constructs web-grounded anchor structures and jointly derives a question and a reference evidence skeleton. The skeleton guides expert generation through extractive highlights, is removed before supervised fine-tuning, and finally reused to audit reference-step coverage during reinforcement learning. We construct 9,221 expert trajectories, training a 30B search agent. Across five deep-search benchmarks, PrimeSeeker achieves strong performance, while reference-step optimization further improves the supervised policy. The resulting trajectories exhibit low retrieval redundancy, and fixed-budget evaluation shows strong solution coverage with substantially fewer tool calls than long-horizon systems.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM-based agents, search agents, synthetic data, reinforcement learning, post-training, tool augmentation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_ef8TOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PrimeSeeker, a capability-oriented framework for training deep search agents. Instead of constructing questions based primarily on global complexity, it introduces latent anchor reasoning, consisting of anchor resolution and relation transfer. The framework jointly constructs questions and reference evidence skeletons, which are reused for evidence-guided expert generation and reference-step rewards during reinforcement learning. Experiments on five benchmarks demonstrate competitive performance and improved search efficiency under fixed interaction budgets.

Critical strengths
  1. Capability-oriented formulation. The paper introduces a meaningful perspective on search-agent supervision by focusing on latent anchor resolution and relation transfer rather than relying solely on question complexity.
  2. Reusable evidence supervision. The reference evidence skeleton provides a unified mechanism for guiding expert generation and rewarding intermediate evidence discovery during RL.
  3. Useful experimental analysis. The paper includes controlled comparisons of expert guidance and RL rewards, as well as search-efficiency evaluations under shared interaction budgets.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient validation of capability-oriented supervision. The paper lacks a controlled comparison demonstrating that latent anchor reasoning improves training over conventional multi-hop question construction.
  2. Unclear reliability and effectiveness of reference-step rewards. The LLM-based evidence auditor is not independently validated, and fixed reference skeletons may overlook alternative valid search paths. Moreover, Dq-based RL underperforms outcome-only RL on BrowseComp-ZH (42.3% vs. 47.5%), raising concerns about reward reliability and robustness.
  3. Oracle-assisted efficiency evaluation. The budgeted evaluation stops when an answer matches the ground truth, which does not reflect realistic deployment without an oracle.
  4. Limited statistical reliability. BrowseComp evaluations use only 200 questions per language, without confidence intervals or significance tests. Given the high variance of search benchmarks, the reliability of small improvements remains unclear.
Questions for authors
  1. Capability-oriented supervision. Could the authors provide a controlled comparison or capability-specific evaluation to demonstrate the advantages of latent anchor reasoning over conventional multi-hop question construction?
  2. Reward reliability and robustness. How accurate is the LLM-based reference-step auditor, especially when agents follow alternative valid search paths? What explains the performance degradation on BrowseComp-ZH compared with outcome-only RL?
  3. Practical search efficiency. How does PrimeSeeker perform without ground-truth-based stopping? Could the authors report accuracy and inference costs under a realistic stopping criterion?
  4. Statistical significance. Could the authors report confidence intervals or statistical significance tests for the performance improvements, particularly on the 200-question BrowseComp subsets?
Reviewer_bL7SOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PrimeSeeker, a capability-oriented framework for training deep search agents. The authors introduce latent anchor reasoning, which decomposes deep search into latent anchor resolution and relation transfer. Based on this formulation, PrimeSeeker constructs web-grounded questions and reference evidence skeletons. The skeletons are used to guide expert trajectory generation through extractive evidence highlighting and to provide reference-step coverage rewards during reinforcement learning. The authors construct 9,221 expert trajectories and train a 30B search agent. Experiments on five deep search benchmarks show competitive performance, improvements from reference-step rewards, and strong solution coverage with fewer tool calls under a shared interaction budget.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper presents a coherent framework that reuses intermediate evidence across question construction, expert trajectory generation, and reinforcement learning. The shared reference evidence skeleton provides additional supervision for both expert generation and policy optimization.

  2. The experiments cover five deep search benchmarks and show competitive performance. In particular, the shared-budget evaluation in Table 2 shows higher solution coverage with fewer tool calls than the compared systems.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The methodological novelty seems limited compared with existing work. Latent anchor resolution and relation transfer are closely related to bridge-type multi-hop reasoning and entity traversal in previous QA construction methods, including MuSiQue [1], WebSailor-V2 [2], and OpenSeeker [3]. E-GRPO [4] and Search-P1 [5] have also explored intermediate supervision and process rewards. The main contribution appears to be reusing a shared evidence skeleton for expert generation and RL. It remains unclear what fundamentally new retrieval capability this formulation introduces.

  2. Several important comparisons with existing methods are missing. The paper does not compare capability-oriented QA construction with conventional graph-based multi-hop QA construction, so the benefit of the proposed construction strategy itself is unclear. The reference-step reward is only compared with outcome-only RL, without comparisons against existing process reward methods such as E-GRPO [4] and Search-P1 [5]. The expert generation experiments also lack stronger baselines, such as question-aware evidence extraction without reference skeletons. These comparisons are needed to establish the advantages of the proposed components over existing approaches.

  3. The quality of the reference evidence skeletons and the reliability of the LLM-based rewards are not sufficiently evaluated. The paper does not provide an independent evaluation of whether the automatically generated intermediate steps are correct, necessary, or complete. The construction, reference-step auditing, and final-answer evaluation all rely on Qwen3-30B-A3B-Instruct-2507. In particular, the outcome reward during RL and the final benchmark evaluation use the same LLM judge. This raises concerns about potential reward hacking and evaluation bias. The paper does not provide independent evaluation to rule out these risks. The reference-step reward may also favor predefined intermediate evidence over alternative valid search paths.

References

[1] MuSiQue: Multihop Questions via Single-hop Question Composition. TACL 2022.

[2] WebSailor-V2: Bridging the Chasm to Proprietary Agents via Synthetic Data and Scalable Reinforcement Learning. ICLR 2026.

[3] OpenSeeker: Democratizing Frontier Search Agents by Fully Open-Sourcing Training Data. arXiv 2026.

[4] Repurposing Synthetic Data for Fine-Grained Search Agent Supervision. ICLR 2026.

[5] Search-P1: Path-Centric Reward Shaping for Stable and Efficient Agentic RAG Training. ACL 2026.

Questions for authors
  1. What distinguishes latent anchor reasoning from existing bridge-type multi-hop QA construction, and can the authors compare capability-oriented construction with conventional graph-based construction under the same training pipeline?

  2. How does the proposed reference-step reward compare with existing intermediate supervision methods, such as E-GRPO [4] and Search-P1 [5], when applied to the same SFT checkpoint and RL training data?

  3. Which expert models were used to generate the 9,221 SFT trajectories, and can the authors compare D_q-guided generation with question-aware evidence extraction that does not use reference skeletons?

  4. Have the authors independently evaluated the correctness and completeness of the reference evidence skeletons and the accuracy of the reference-step coverage auditor, including its treatment of alternative valid evidence paths?

  5. Since the outcome reward and final benchmark evaluation rely on the same LLM judge, how do the authors rule out potential reward hacking and evaluation bias, and do the improvements remain consistent under an independent judge or human evaluation?

Reviewer_gFuiOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PrimeSeeker, a framework for training deep search agents through capability-oriented supervision. The method formulates deep search as a composition of latent anchor resolution and relation transfer, and constructs web-grounded questions together with reference evidence skeletons. These skeletons are subsequently reused to guide expert trajectory generation and to provide reference-step coverage rewards during reinforcement learning. Experiments on five deep-search benchmarks demonstrate performance improvements and relatively efficient tool usage.

Critical strengths
  1. Incorporating the evidence found along the retrieval path as part of the rubric is indeed a sound and reliable approach.

  2. The proposed pipeline integrates question construction, expert trajectory generation, and policy optimization through a shared evidence representation. Reusing construction-time information across these stages is a practical and well-motivated design.

  3. The evidence-guided trajectory generation and reference-step rewards generally improve performance over the corresponding baselines. The fixed-budget experiments also demonstrate competitive search efficiency, suggesting that the framework has practical value.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main components appear closely related to existing approaches for synthetic search-task construction and fine-grained supervision. In particular, E-GRPO [1] already reuses intermediate entities from synthetic data to provide partial rewards for unsuccessful trajectories, while Search-P1 [2] introduces reference-path coverage rewards for agentic retrieval. OpenSeeker [3] also explores web-grounded question construction and auxiliary guidance during expert trajectory synthesis. PrimeSeeker offers a reasonable integration of these ideas, but the methodological advances beyond prior work appear relatively incremental.

  2. A central contribution is the reference-step coverage reward based on the evidence skeleton. Compared with entity-level [1] or reference-path-based reward shaping [2], the proposed approach additionally requires evidence grounding in retrieved observations, which is a potentially useful distinction. However, the paper does not provide controlled comparisons showing that this additional complexity leads to meaningful improvements. The current comparison against outcome-only RL establishes the usefulness of intermediate supervision, but does not establish the superiority of the specific reward design over existing fine-grained alternatives.

[1] Zhao, Y., Li, K., Wu, X., et al. Repurposing Synthetic Data for Fine-grained Search Agent Supervision. ICLR 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.24694 [2] Xia, T., Xu, M., Hu, L., et al. Search-P1: Path-Centric Reward Shaping for Stable and Efficient Agentic RAG Training. Proceedings of ACL 2026, Industry Track, pp. 517–534. https://aclanthology.org/2026.acl-industry.36/ [3] Du, Y., Ye, R., Tang, S., et al. OpenSeeker: Democratizing Frontier Search Agents by Fully Open-Sourcing Training Data. arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.15594, 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.15594

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors compare the proposed reference-step coverage reward with simpler entity-level rewards, such as E-GRPO, or path-centric rewards, under the same SFT checkpoint, training data, and RL budget? In many existing synthetic QA pipelines, questions are already constructed from explicit supporting evidence and intermediate entities or relations. Therefore, it remains unclear how much additional benefit the proposed fine-grained evidence-level supervision provides over simpler node-level reward mechanisms. A controlled comparison would help clarify whether the additional complexity of evidence extraction and auditing is justified by meaningful performance gains.

  2. Could the authors provide a controlled ablation of the capability-oriented QA construction strategy, ideally comparing it against conventional graph-based question construction while keeping the subsequent training pipeline unchanged? Such a comparison would help isolate the contribution of the proposed latent anchor reasoning formulation and establish whether it offers substantive advantages over existing synthetic data construction approaches.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.