- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors show that classical neural networks can violate Bell-like inequalities in certain settings. The authors' explanation for this phenomenon is that during the training procedure the network effectively "couples" hidden neurons which directly supply nonlocal correlations to the network. The authors suggest this should only happen when the capacity of the network is limited, forcing the training procedure to couple these hidden neurons, and then perform numerical experiments to validate this hypothesis.
Critical strengths
The paper is an interesting application of ideas from quantum physics to understanding the performance of classical neural networks. I find the authors' combination of analysis and empirical study convincing and I agree with their conclusions. I also find the work novel; most previous work which studies contextual correlations and their implications for machine learning, e.g., Quantum 10, 1976 (2026) and npj Quantum Inf. 11, 127 (2025), focus on understanding the limitations of classical networks. This paper offers an interesting complementary perspective by showcasing settings where naive intuition from this previous line of work can yield incorrect conclusions.
Critical weaknesses
The authors' work is not the first to identify whether classical neural networks exhibit quantum contextual correlations; the authors cite arXiv:2603.04451, but there is also, e.g., Quantum 10, 1976 (2026) and npj Quantum Inf. 11, 127 (2025). The authors should cite these previous studies linking contextuality to machine learning.
Another weakness is that, while the authors make an interesting observation, they do not suggest any interesting implications for their observation. What should the main takeaway of the authors' work be in terms of model design?
I think even with these weaknesses the novelty of the work does enough to justify its inclusion, and I recommend acceptance.
Questions for authors
Does the authors' observation suggest any actionable advice in neural network design?
What are some implications of the authors' work on prior work (e.g., Quantum 10, 1976 (2026) and npj Quantum Inf. 11, 127 (2025)) showing that contextual correlations can be used to bound the performance of classical neural networks?