acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Emergent Symbolic Organization in Sparse Binary Visual Representations

Abstract

Symbolic organization is often associated with language, but whether it can emerge within visual recognition without linguistic supervision remains unclear. By imposing a sparse binary bottleneck on ResNet-50, we represent each image as a set of active bits from a shared vocabulary of 2048 binary visual units and show that symbolic organization can emerge from image-level supervision alone. The binary representation activates only 24.63 bits per image on average, corresponding to 98.8% sparsity, while retaining 78.54% Top-1 accuracy on ImageNet. This shared vocabulary exhibits systematic reuse, category-structured combinations, and a broad Zipf-like regime in its rank–frequency curve, together with functionally differentiated contributions to recognition. To probe the semantics of individual bits, we map the 2048 bits to learnable embeddings and use them to condition a frozen Stable Diffusion 1.5 model. The experiments show that complete active-bit sets generate semantically recognizable visual content. Some individual bits produce stable semantic effects, including concepts beyond the ImageNet label taxonomy, and independently probed bits can combine into coherent configurations beyond observed ImageNet compositions. At least a subset of the learned visual bits therefore exhibits multiple properties characteristic of symbolic units, providing an empirical setting for studying how symbolic organization can emerge in perceptual neural systems. Code will be made publicly available.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
sparse binary representations, symbolic representation learning, visual recognition

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_FsTZOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces a hard-threshold binarization bottleneck into the layer of a ResNet-50, representing each ImageNet image using only about 25 active bits, while maintaining a Top-1 accuracy of 78.5%. The authors observe that the usage frequency of these bits follows a Zipf-like heavy-tailed distribution. Also, images belonging to the same class exhibit highly overlapping bit-activation patterns, and removing critical bits significantly impairs recognition. So, the authors learn an embedding for each bit and feed these into a frozen Stable Diffusion model. They find that individual bits can consistently trigger the generation of specific content, while combinations of two bits can produce novel, composite imagery.

Critical strengths

I think the idea is interesting and the generative probing offers a new approach: by mapping each discrete bit to an input embedding for CLIP, which is then fed into a frozen Stable Diffusion decoder, one can directly visualize the semantics of individual visual units. This includes concepts that lack corresponding terms in the CLIP vocabulary, providing an intuitive new tool for the interpretability of current vision models.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The first thing comes into my mind is none of the emergent properties are compared against a standard ResNet-50, for example, a ResNet-50 without retraining, simply by taking the top-k or applying thresholding. So, it cannot be proven that these properties stem specifically from the binary bottleneck rather than being general attributes of the penultimate layer of a CNN.

  2. I think the bit embeddings in the paper are, in essence, a form of Textual Inversion trained using diffusion loss. The resulting semantics and compositional effects are likely derived from Stable Diffusion/CLIP itself, rather than demonstrating that bit inherently possesses these semantics or compositional capabilities. Also, the semantic evidence consists of only a few selected bits and lacks comprehensive, quantitative statistics.

Questions for authors
  1. I am thinking if taking a standard, pre-trained ResNet-50 (without a binarization bottleneck), apply the same top-25 selection or thresholding to its GAP features, and then conduct the exact same analyses, and the same Stable Diffusion-based generative probe, how would the results compare to those of the authors' model? If the differences are minimal, how do the authors justify the claim that these properties emerge specifically from the binarization bottleneck, rather than being inherent to the CNN representations themselves?

  2. The recognition component performs a linear summation of a set of unordered active bits, which essentially serving as a bag of features. Furthermore, the evidence in the paper that comes closest to demonstrating compositionality, for example, "statue cake" from a "statue" and a "cake", is derived from Stable Diffusion. Based on this, I feel this compositional capability may be an inherent property of Stable Diffusion’s own pretraining. Given that the paper’s claim is the emergence of symbolic organization within visual recognition systems, the evidence should be sought within the recognition model itself, rather than by leveraging the capabilities of Stable Diffusion. Could the authors provide evidence from the recognition model itself that supports the assertion of symbolic organization?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response To Reviewer FsTZ

Response To Reviewer FsTZ

We invite you to read the "To all reviewers" responses first, which clarify the motivation, organization, and contributions of this work and present additional experiments quantifying bit generation success rates.

1. Comparison with post-hoc binary bottlenecks

We thank you for suggesting this important comparison. The suggested top-k and hard-thresholding procedures are also binary bottlenecks. The key distinction is that they apply binarization after training, whereas our method trains the recognition network with the binary bottleneck in place.

We provide the following direct comparison:

MethodTop-1 accuracy (%)Mean active bits
Top-25 selection67.3325.00
Post-hoc thresholding69.0724.87
Our method78.5424.63

At comparable active-bit counts, both post-hoc binary bottlenecks achieve approximately 10% lower Top-1 accuracy. Directly converting a pretrained continuous representation into a binary set therefore reduces discriminative quality, whereas end-to-end training under the binary constraint preserves strong recognition performance.

The post-hoc procedures also produce different organizational structures. Top-25 selection activates a fixed number of bits for every image, whereas our threshold-based representation allows the set size to vary with the input. Furthermore, their rank–frequency curves are shifted, with elevated rather than suppressed high-frequency heads and substantially lower fitted slopes (0.45). The overlap gap between same-class and different-class images is also reduced. These results indicate that post-hoc binarization changes both the quality and organization of the resulting binary vocabulary. We will include these comparisons and clarify this distinction in the final version.

Our contribution is therefore not simply to convert continuous features into binary sets, but to learn an effective binary bottleneck that preserves strong recognition performance and provides a meaningful basis for studying the organization of sparse visual units.

2. Textual Inversion and the role of the generator prior

The learned embeddings resemble Textual Inversion in that they are optimized through a diffusion objective with the generator frozen. The distinction lies in how the training images are associated with each embedding. Rather than assigning a token to a manually selected concept image set, our probe uses bit identities and activation patterns determined by the independently trained recognition model. Each embedding is shared across images in which its bit is active, allowing it to capture the bit's existing visual associations.

Our representation shares the order-independent aggregation of bag-of-features representations, but records binary membership of learned global units rather than conventional local-word frequency counts.

Stable Diffusion and CLIP provide the pretrained visual prior through which these associations are rendered. However, this prior alone does not determine a stable bit-specific semantic effect. If a bit is activated by statistically heterogeneous visual content, its embedding receives inconsistent signals and is not expected to converge to a stable, concept-specific direction. Stable generation therefore depends on the statistical regularity of the visual content associated with the bit, while the frozen generator provides the mechanism for making that association visually inspectable.

3. Recognition-model evidence and the role of the probe

The semantic-generative probe is not the sole source of evidence for symbolic organization. Sections 4.3 and 4.4 provide large-scale statistical and intervention analyses directly on the recognition representation, including vocabulary usage, category-structured active-set combinations, and counterfactual deletion. These experiments reveal structured frequency usage, greater active-set overlap within classes than across classes, and larger recognition changes under targeted deletion than under random deletion, all without using Stable Diffusion.

Section 4.5 addresses a complementary question at the individual-unit level. Its selected examples are intended to visualize and inspect the semantic effects of particular bits, rather than to replace the population-level analyses in Sections 4.3 and 4.4. The same probing procedure can be applied to every visual bit, while the reported examples cover distinct probing regimes, including the highest activation frequencies, the strongest lexical matches, and interpretable visual effects without matching lexical neighbors. Thus, the recognition-model experiments provide the global structural and functional evidence, while the semantic-generative probe provides a new individual-unit readout. The two sources of evidence are complementary, and the compositional images from Stable Diffusion are not the sole basis for our claims about the organization of the recognition representation.

Reviewer_jirMOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This work studies the emergence of symbolic properties in learned representations within a purely visual task by implementing a binarization bottleneck on a visual backbone. They use these binary representations as probes for conditioning image generation on a pretrained Stable Diffusion model. They empirically show that these learned representations exhibit many properties which seem to suggest a linguistic like organization by analyzing the distributions of active bits, the ability to compose different representations and how correlated the active sets are with the classes present in the dataset.

Critical strengths
  • This paper introduces a novel and interesting framework to study symbolic behavior in learned representations. The methods used to measure the usefulness and systematicity of the learned representations, particularly the semantic probing of the generated tokens, are incredibly innovative and yield very insightful results. This is my main takeaway from this work, and I believe this experimental setup is valuable and unique, and should be adopted by the community.

  • The experiments are extensive and dutifully documented, with interesting and surprising results.

Critical weaknesses
  • The main contribution, gap or problem that this work tackles remains unclear. The authors claim that the aim of the work is to study whether symbolic like organization can emerge through visual tasks alone, a problem that is underexplored in the literature. However, most of the paper is dedicated to the use of these representations to perform conditioned image generation, being even included in the definition of the method. This would not be an issue if it were part of the objectives set up by the authors, but in the introduction and abstract they position this as a form of evaluation. Furthermore, many of the discrete representation learning schemes they cite use no language supervision to train, so the claim that this is the novelty of the method is unjustified.
  • Many decisions in designing the method and evaluation are unjustified within the work, such as the need to shuffle the bits, how targeted interventions for counterfactual robustness are performed, and what certain metrics actually entail (more details in my questions). Related to my previous point, the introduction seems to suggest that this work falls in the emergent language area, but, save for the Zipfian distribution of the active bits, no metrics from this area are applied, and there are no comparisons to related baselines. Furthermore, the strong claim of compositionality is backed only by qualitative examples, but no metrics are provided.
Questions for authors

As I mentioned in the weaknesses section, my main issue is the lack of justification / clarity as to what the main contributions are. I think the methods and results in this work are very interesting and valuable to the community, but (in my opinion) need to be reframed. First, I have a few questions:

  • What is it that makes this method unique? To my understanding, this is the unordered set of active bits as a representation, but in the introduction and conclusions you suggest that it is the emergence of linguistic like properties through only visual supervision. Many works in emergent languages and discrete representations do this as well, so perhaps I am misunderstanding the distinction.
  • Why is it necessary that the set of active bits be unordered? The shuffling in the method is currently rather jarring, and I think deserves more explanation or justification.
  • I am curious what makes the representations tend towards sparsity. As far as I can see, you did not explicitly punish dense bit sets. Could you provide some intuition as to why the representations organize this way?
  • The generation experiments are incredibly interesting, and indeed seem to suggest comositionality. However, this would be much more clear if you used compositionality and disentanglement metrics from the emergent languages literature, such as topographic similarity or usefulness for downstream generalization (do the representations allow for OOD generalization?).
  • Additionally, some results don't have a clear takeaway, such as the binary entropy of the activated bits or the noise prediction loss in section 4.5. Why are these results important?

Additionally, I have a few suggestions to make the contributions more clear. These are not requirements for me to increase my score, but I think they would help with readability:

  • Add a contributions section to the introduction, this will help the reader understand exactly what the paper is about.
  • I am not convinced that the main takeaway is that symbolic organization emerges from image level supervision alone. Image level supervision is used in many of the related works you cite, and I would frame the novelty around representations as unordered sets of bits, which is unique.
  • Sections 3.2, 3.3 and 3.4 are a bit hard to understand as part of the method. Are they used during training? If they are only used for evaluation, I would not include them in the method definition. Equation (8) is hard to follow, What is E\mathcal {E} ? How is it different from E?
  • Most of section 3.3 seems to be just the classic SD inference process (unless I am mistaken). I would suggest just keeping the changes made by this framework, or making it clear that the steps being described are just following the typical SD framework.

I really think the results and method you have are quite interesting, and would be happy to update my score if my concerns are addressed.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer jirM (Part 1)

Response to Reviewer jirM (Part 1)

1. Clarification of the contributions and the role of the probing framework

We invite you to read the "To all reviewers" responses first, which clarify the motivation, organization, and contributions of this work and present additional experiments quantifying bit generation success rates. In brief, the absence of language supervision is only our experimental setting, not the claim of methodological novelty. Our methodological contributions are the global unordered binary-set representation and the semantic-generative probe used to study its organization.

The probe is designed to reveal the statistical visual associations of individual bits. Recovering a stable bit-specific meaning requires recurring visual regularities across images in which the bit is active. Because a bit's embedding is shared across these images, it can learn their common visual content and express it through generation. If the associated content lacks statistically consistent semantics, there is no consistent bit-specific meaning for the embedding to recover. Agreement between the generated content and the original bit's visual responses supports the probe's interpretation. The semantic-generative probe is not merely an auxiliary evaluation procedure, but a methodological tool for studying the semantic stability and composition of the learned binary vocabulary.

For composition, we deliberately selected the unusual statue–cream-cake pairing to explore whether independently characterized visual concepts could form coherent configurations beyond familiar combinations. We will supplement this example with more common combinations in the Appendix to examine behavior across different pairings.

We also provide direct baselines based on selecting the top-25 activations and hard-thresholding the original network. At comparable active-bit counts, these baselines achieve 67.33% and 69.07% Top-1 accuracy, respectively, compared with 78.54% for our method. Further details on these baselines, including their recognition performance and organizational differences, are provided in Section 1 of our response to reviewer FsTZ.

In the final version, we will revise and strengthen the Introduction and add a dedicated contribution paragraph.

2. Clarification of the Method organization and notation

We agree that the original organization did not make the two training stages sufficiently clear. Section 3.1 describes how the binary recognition model is learned, while Sections 3.2–3.4 describe a separate post-hoc probing framework for studying the learned representation. Training proceeds in two stages. First, the classification network is trained using the method in Section 3.1. Second, the generator and trained classification network are frozen, while embeddings for the visual bits are learned as described in Sections 3.2–3.3. Section 3.4 then provides the lexical readout of the learned visual-token embeddings. Thus, Sections 3.2–3.3 form a separate probe-training stage rather than additional training objectives for the recognition model.

To improve readability, we will reorganize Section 3 as follows:

3 Method
  3.1 Sparse Binary Visual Representation
  3.2 Semantic-Generative Probing Framework
    3.2.1 From Unordered Bit Sets to Visual-Token Embeddings
    3.2.2 Probing Visual-Token Embeddings with Frozen Stable Diffusion
    3.2.3 Lexical Alignment of Visual Tokens

The Stable Diffusion component follows the standard Stable Diffusion procedure. The framework-specific modification is that the active-bit set is serialized and mapped to learnable visual-token embeddings, with only the embedding matrix optimized during probe training. In the final version, we will explicitly state that the diffusion steps described here follow the standard SD framework and are included only to define the probe and its training objective.

In Equation (8), E∈R2048×768E \in \mathbb{R}^{2048 \times 768} is the learnable embedding matrix containing embeddings only for the 2048 visual bits indexed from 0 to 2047. It does not include the BOS or EOT tokens. The BOS and EOT embeddings are directly taken from the original CLIP vocabulary and remain fixed during probe training. For mathematical precision, we use E(⋅)\mathcal{E}(\cdot) to denote the lookup operation that maps the serialized token IDs to their corresponding embeddings.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer jirM (Part 2)

Response to Reviewer jirM (Part 2)

3. Why are the active bits shuffled?

Each bit indicates only whether a learned visual feature is present. The representation is therefore an unordered set of present features, with no defined order among active bits. However, conditioning Stable Diffusion through CLIP requires serializing this set into a sequence. A deterministic ordering could introduce systematic correlations between bit identity and sequence position, allowing the probe to exploit positional cues that are not part of the intended representation. We therefore randomly shuffle the active bits to reduce this positional bias and encourage the probe to learn from feature presence rather than an imposed order.

4. Why does the representation become sparse?

We control sparsity through the binarization threshold τ\tau (Tab. 2), rather than using an explicit sparsity loss or penalty. A higher threshold requires a stronger feature response to activate a bit, so fewer bits are activated and the representation becomes sparser. The classification objective encourages the network to retain task-relevant information under this constraint.

5. Quantitative combination structure and uncommon semantic combinations

Section 4.3 already tests the statistical correspondence between semantic similarity and representation similarity. A natural hypothesis is that images from the same class share more semantic content and should therefore have more similar binary representations than images from different classes. Our class-wise Jaccard analysis provides a category-level statistical analogue of this relationship. We test it using 500,000 same-class and 500,000 different-class image pairs. The mean Jaccard overlap is 0.4983 for same-class pairs and 0.0191 for different-class pairs. Thus, category-level semantic similarity is reflected in the similarity of the learned bit sets, providing quantitative evidence for structured combinations in the representation.

Section 4.5 complements this statistical analysis by exploring semantic combinations at the individual-unit level. We deliberately selected the unusual statue–cream-cake pairing to examine whether independently characterized visual concepts could be expressed coherently in an uncommon joint configuration through the generative probe. The resulting coherent images provide exploratory evidence for this possibility.

6. Clarification of the deletion intervention

For an image xx, let y^(x)\hat{y}(x) denote the Top-1 prediction and y2(x)y_2(x) the runner-up class. For each active bit ii, we define its contribution to the predicted-versus-runner-up logit margin as

Ii(x)=Wy^(x),i−Wy2(x),iI_i(x)=W_{\hat{y}(x),i}-W_{y_2(x),i}.

Because the classifier is linear, deleting bit ii changes this margin by exactly −Ii(x)-I_i(x). For a deletion ratio pp, we remove np(x)=⌊pK(x)⌋n_p(x)=\lfloor pK(x)\rfloor active bits. Targeted deletion removes the bits with the largest Ii(x)I_i(x), namely those that most strongly distinguish the current prediction from its runner-up. Random deletion removes the same number of active bits uniformly at random. The difference between these conditions therefore measures the counterfactual effect of removing the most discriminative visual bits.

7. Clarification of the binary entropy and diffusion loss

The binary-entropy analysis provides an intuitive quantitative measure of the information capacity retained by the visual vocabulary. The entropy of each bit measures how variably it is used across images, while the summed marginal entropy provides a compact measure of the overall usage diversity of the binary representation.

The diffusion noise-prediction loss serves as a training diagnostic for the semantic-generative probe. It indicates that the learned visual-bit embeddings provide a usable conditioning signal for the frozen Stable Diffusion model and that probe training converges to a meaningful solution.

Reviewer_ycFjOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates whether symbol-like organization can emerge in sparse binary visual representations learned through image-level classification supervision. A binary bottleneck in ResNet-50 achieves 78.54% ImageNet Top-1 accuracy with an average of 24.63 active bits. Vocabulary statistics, deletion interventions, and a frozen CLIP–SD1.5 generative probe examine token reuse, functional differentiation, and semantic composition.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear research question and simple framework. The paper translates an abstract question about symbolic organization into observable properties, including reuse, category structure, functional contributions, and semantic behavior.

  2. Complementary evidence. Frequency statistics, class-wise overlap, deletion experiments, and generative examples provide multiple perspectives. The threshold sweep also characterizes the sparsity–accuracy trade-off.

  3. Precise functional analysis. The linear classifier permits exact attribution of logit contributions, while matched random and targeted deletions demonstrate differentiated roles among bits.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The specific contribution of binarization remains unclear. Without matched continuous and alternative sparse-representation baselines, the experiments cannot isolate which observed properties arise from the binary bottleneck rather than classification training more generally.

  2. Generative semantics are difficult to attribute. The outputs reflect the combined effects of visual bits, learned embeddings, and pretrained generator priors. The experiments do not clearly separate their contributions to semantic stability and composition.

  3. Compositional evidence has limited coverage. Semantic examples cover eight selected bits, while two-bit generation examines only one pair. Overall success rates and systematic compositional evaluations are absent, and the claimed novelty relative to training compositions lacks a documented verification procedure. Broader claims about symbolic organization and compositional generalization therefore remain tentative.

Questions for authors

See the weaknesses.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ycFj

Response to Reviewer ycFj

We invite you to read the "To all reviewers" responses first, which clarify the motivation, organization, and contributions of this work and present additional experiments quantifying bit generation success rates.

1. The contribution of binarization and the choice of baselines

One of our contributions is an effective, compact binary set representation that preserves strong recognition performance under extreme sparsity.

Continuous and many existing sparse representations retain activation magnitudes and require binarization before the same set-based analyses can be applied. Our representation uses only the presence or absence of visual units, making shared elements, overlap, and reuse directly measurable. Reviewer jirM also identified this unordered active-bit representation as distinctive. As discussed in Section 2, prior sparse-representation work primarily emphasizes efficiency, optimization, or computation. Here, we investigate the organization of binary visual sets, without additional sparsity penalties, concept annotations, or concept-discovery losses.

We provide two baselines that directly sparsify the original network's features at comparable active-bit counts. Both baselines achieve accuracies approximately 10% below ours at comparable sparsity, supporting our method's ability to preserve strong discriminative quality in an extremely sparse binary representation. Further details on these baselines and their effects are provided in Section 1 of our response to reviewer FsTZ.

2. Attribution of generative semantics

The probe is designed to read out recurring visual associations of the corresponding bit. Each bit's embedding is shared across training images in which it is active. When a bit consistently responds to statistically related visual content, the embedding can learn this association and express it through generation. Conversely, for a bit without a consistent visual association, embedding learning alone does not guarantee a stable, concept-specific readout.

Importantly, evidence for these visual associations already exists in the recognition model before probing. High-response images, spatial responses, and classifier associations reveal recurring visual regularities associated with selected bits. The probe provides an additional semantic readout whose generated content closely matches these source-side observations. This agreement strengthens the interpretation that the learned embeddings capture visual associations already present in the recognition bits, while the frozen generator provides the pretrained visual prior through which these associations are expressed. Joint generation further examines whether independently characterized semantic associations can be coherently expressed together through the probe, with the generator's pretrained prior also contributing to the resulting composition.

3. Coverage of compositional evidence

The evidence for combination structure extends beyond the two-bit generation example. Section 4.3 quantitatively examines how visual units are combined across images, using 500,000 same-class and 500,000 different-class image pairs. The mean Jaccard overlap is 0.4983 within classes and 0.0191 across classes. Different instances of a category therefore repeatedly select similar combinations, while different categories select substantially different combinations from the shared vocabulary. This provides large-scale statistical evidence for category-structured combinations.

Sections 4.3 and 4.4 characterize vocabulary structure and functional roles statistically, while Section 4.5 complements these analyses with individual semantic interpretations. The eight examples were deliberately selected to illustrate distinct probing regimes, including the most frequently activated bits, those with the strongest lexical matches, and bits expressing non-label concepts or coherent visual content without matching lexical neighbors. They are representative examples of these different behaviors, intended to make individual units interpretable and inspectable.

For semantic composition, we deliberately selected the statue–cream-cake pair to examine whether independently characterized visual concepts could form coherent configurations even in an unusual pairing. The generated samples illustrate this possibility. Together, Sections 4.3 and 4.5 examine combinations from two complementary perspectives, large-scale active-set statistics and individual semantic effects. We will add further examples of bit combinations to the Appendix to broaden the coverage.

Regarding the rarity of the selected combination, we manually inspected all training images from the ten ImageNet classes associated with these bits and found no images depicting a fusion of cake and statue elements within this audited subset.

Comments on the paper

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

To all reviewers: Overall clarification of the motivation, organization, and contributions

To all reviewers: Overall clarification of the motivation, organization, and contributions

We thank all reviewers for their careful reading and constructive feedback. Despite concerns about positioning and evaluation, the reviewers recognized the value of the proposed framework and results.

Specifically, reviewer jirM identified the unordered active-bit representation as a distinctive aspect of the work. Reviewer ycFj highlighted that the framework translates the abstract question of symbolic organization into observable properties. They also appreciated the complementary analyses, including token reuse, class-wise active-set overlap, deletion interventions, and functional contributions. Reviewers jirM and FsTZ highlighted the semantic-generative probe as an innovative approach to studying learned visual units. Reviewer jirM further described this experimental setup as valuable and worth adopting by the community. These comments highlight the value of both the representation framework and the tools developed to study it.

This work was motivated by a basic question about visual representation. Humans describe visual experience by selecting a small number of words from a shared vocabulary, and multimodal models acquire a related capability by aligning visual and linguistic modalities. This raises a natural question: Can a visual recognition model develop a highly sparse binary representation for each image through image-level classification supervision alone, without language supervision or concept annotations? If so, what kind of organization would emerge in the resulting visual vocabulary?

To address the first question, Section 3.1 introduces an STE-based method for learning highly sparse binary representations. The resulting model achieves 78.54% Top-1 and 93.67% Top-5 accuracy on ImageNet while activating only 24.63 of 2048 bits per image on average. This establishes that the sparse binary sets retain substantial discriminative information, demonstrating their effectiveness as image representations. Our first contribution is therefore an effective, compact binary set representation that preserves strong recognition performance under extreme sparsity.

With this representation established, we investigate its organization. Section 4.3 examines adaptive set size, hierarchical token reuse, and category-structured combinations, with substantially higher active-set overlap within classes than across classes. Section 4.4 examines functional differentiation through counterfactual deletion. These analyses investigate whether the discrete units develop structured reuse and distinct functional roles, properties associated with symbol-like organization.

To further examine what individual bits represent, Sections 3.2–3.4 introduce the semantic-generative probe and lexical readout. We learn embeddings for the visual bits to test whether individual bits consistently evoke particular visual content. Section 4.5 examines these generations alongside high-response source images and lexical readouts. Together, these analyses support stable semantic interpretations for selected bits. Joint activation further explores whether independently probed bits can produce coherent combinations. The same procedure can be applied to every bit in the vocabulary, providing a general tool for probing individual visual units and studying network interpretability, which is our second contribution.

Our contributions can therefore be summarized as follows:

  1. We introduce an STE-based method that represents each image as a sparse, unordered set of active visual bits, achieving 78.54% ImageNet Top-1 accuracy with only 24.63 active bits per image on average, corresponding to 98.8% sparsity.
  2. We introduce a semantic-generative probe that learns shared embeddings from bit-activated images and provides a statistical readout of the semantic associations of individual bits, offering a new tool for unit-level interpretability in visual recognition models.
  3. We provide evidence that sparse binary representations exhibit systematic reuse, category-structured combinations, differentiated functional roles, and stable semantic effects for selected bits, indicating the emergence of symbol-like organization.

In the final version, we will explain the research motivation more fully and add a dedicated contribution paragraph to the Introduction, making the scientific question, methodological contributions, and empirical findings more explicit.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

To all reviewers: Statistical analysis of bit-conditioned generation success rates

To all reviewers: Statistical analysis of bit-conditioned generation success rates

To quantify generation success, we generate 1,024 images per condition using SD and feed them back into the recognition model. A single-bit generation succeeds if its conditioning bit is activated; otherwise, it fails. For two-bit generation, success requires both conditioning bits to be activated simultaneously.

Conditioning bitsSuccessful images / 1,024Success rate (%)
Bit 184644643.55
Bit 167265764.16
Bit 15621,02299.80
Bit 6251,01899.41
Bit 81,02399.90
Bit 22699497.07
Bits 8 and 22615114.75
Bit 21,01899.41
Bit 394792.48
Bits 2 and 386284.18

Single-bit success rates vary substantially. Bits 1562, 625, 8, and 226 exceed 97%, whereas bits 1846 and 1672 achieve 43.55% and 64.16%. Higher rates indicate greater consistency between an embedding's generative effect and the original recognition feature, providing a quantitative measure of readout reliability.

We additionally evaluate bits 2 and 3, associated with chair-like objects and infant-related content, respectively. Their individual success rates are 99.41% and 92.48%, and their joint success rate is 84.18%. Most jointly generated images depict an infant sitting on a chair, a relatively common configuration. By comparison, the unusual statue–cream-cake pairing achieves only 14.75% joint success despite individual rates of 99.90% and 97.07%. This rare pairing can still produce coherent images, but simultaneous recovery of both recognition features is less frequent.

These results show that reliable individual readouts do not guarantee equally reliable combinations. The contrast between the familiar chair–infant configuration and the unusual statue–cream-cake pairing suggests greater difficulty for the latter. Together, these batch-level statistics complement the qualitative examples and quantify variation in individual readout reliability and joint-generation success.


To extend the selected-case analysis above to the full active vocabulary, we generated 128 images for each of the 1,931 visual tokens that were activated at least once during recognition training. For each token, a generated image was counted as successful when the frozen ResNet-50 reactivated the conditioning token.

For 1,616 tokens (83.69%), at least one generated image reactivated the conditioning token, while 1,538 tokens (79.65%) achieved success rates of at least 1%. A total of 1,001 tokens (51.84%) achieved success rates of at least 50%, and 511 tokens (26.46%) exceeded 90%. At the two endpoints, 315 tokens had a 0% success rate, whereas 107 tokens were reactivated in all 128 generated images. These results provide a vocabulary-wide validation of single-token readout while also showing that readout reliability varies across visual tokens.

We have updated the manuscript PDF to incorporate the revisions described above, with all modified and newly added content highlighted in red.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.