- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents GRONav, a unified topology-based framework for long-range language-conditioned visual navigation. It consists of three main components: (1) action-grounded target retrieval, which combines visual-semantic similarity with trajectory-action matching; (2) semantic-grounded keyframe selection, which considers visual changes and semantic entropy to construct compact topological maps; and (3) spatially grounded navigation, which employs depth-feature alignment and gated attention to improve waypoint prediction.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is clear, and the problem is meaningful.
- The reported results are strong. GRONav achieves high retrieval accuracy, substantial map compression, and improved real-world navigation performance.
- The paper reports inference latency and provides useful ablation studies on the navigation policy, supporting the effectiveness of its design choices.
Critical weaknesses
- Although the problem is interesting, the individual technical contributions appear relatively incremental. The paper would benefit from a clearer discussion of its methodological novelty compared with existing approaches, such as LM-Nav, DynaNav, and related works.
- Although several recent baselines are included, the strongest baseline in Table 2 remains ViNT (CoRL 2023). Comparisons with more competitive recent methods would further strengthen the evaluation.
- The action-grounded retrieval module is a key contribution, but its individual design choices are not sufficiently ablated.
Questions for authors
- Why do all diffusion-based baselines achieve 0% success in Table 2? The authors mainly attribute these failures to inference latency, but this explanation lacks sufficient experimental evidence. Could the authors provide further analysis?
- Could the authors provide a more controlled comparison of visual backbones? Some ablated variants already achieve performance comparable to competing methods. Although the appendix explores different encoders, backbone-matched comparisons would help disentangle the contributions of pretrained visual representations from the proposed architectural designs.
- Could the authors clarify the SPL values in Table 11? Several reported SPL values exceed the corresponding success rates, which is theoretically impossible under the standard SPL definition.
I am willing to raise my score if the authors can adequately address most of my concerns.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer r458 - Part 2
W2&Q1: Weak performance on diffusion-based baselines and stronger baselines.
Although several recent baselines are included, the strongest baseline in Table 2 remains ViNT (CoRL 2023). Comparisons with more competitive recent methods would further strengthen the evaluation.
Thanks for your question, Our evaluation includes several recent visual navigation methods. Table 2 in the main text includes several recent methods (EffoNAV, NaviBridge, and NaviDiffusor, all 2025) covering both transformer-based and diffusion-based policies. Recent visual navigation work mainly either incorporating additional input modalities beyond RGB (e.g., depth, lidar) or using diffusion models to predict multimodal trajectory distributions.
Our work addresses a different bottleneck, which is the robustness and efficientness of visual navigation over long ranges in topological environments. Thanks to its generalizable architectural design, VINT remains the best performing baseline. Furthermore, since DynaNav is not open source, we cannot compare it directly; the comparison results in Table 15 are quoted directly from the paper of DynaNav.
Why do all diffusion-based baselines achieve 0% success in Table 2? The authors mainly attribute these failures to inference latency, but this explanation lacks sufficient experimental evidence. Could the authors provide further analysis?
This is a very interesting question. In fact, similar phenomena have been observed in many recent studies on end-to-end visual navigation, where diffusion-based methods perform worse than transformer-based methods [1–3]. We attribute this to the following two points.
(1) Task setting. All methods in our work use the same velocity limits (1.5 m/s and 0.8 rad/s), which are higher than the common setting in prior image-goal navigation work (0.2 m/s and 0.4 rad/s) because our tasks span much longer distances. This setting requires the model to correct itself promptly when it deviates, but the longer latency of diffusion methods hinders this process. To illustrate, we re-evaluate the diffusion-based baselines in Town02 (SR/SPL) with the limits reduced to 0.2 m/s and 0.4 rad/s, scaling the time budget accordingly. As shown in the table, although the success rate increases after adjusting the setting, it remains far behind the SR of the transformer-based method.
| Method | 1.5m/s, 0.8rad/s | 0.2m/s, 0.4rad/s |
|---|---|---|
| NoMaD | 0.0/17.2 | 6.7/38.2 |
| NaviBridge | 0.0/19.8 | 13.3/41.5 |
| NaviDiffusor | 0.0/22.3 | 18.3/45.7 |
(2) Limited generalization of diffusion-based action generation. Recent work on manipulation found that diffusion-based action heads perform well on specific tasks but generalize worse than MLP- or transformer-based heads [4]. We believe this conclusion also applies to navigation tasks. In our task, we only finetune the model on a small dataset (30 minutes in Town01), and there remains a large gap between training and testing scenarios (Figure 8). With limited data, diffusion-based methods may quickly fit to the specific scenario bias while losing general navigation skills.
We have added the relevant discussion to the main text (page 8). Thank you again for your question, which has prompted us to think further about this phenomenon.
[1] Zhou, Changqing, et al. "UniNav: A Unified World-Action Diffusion Model for Visual Navigation." arXiv preprint arXiv:2608.03244 (2026).
[2] Guerrier, Maeva, et al. "Can vision foundation models navigate? zero-shot real-world evaluation and lessons learned." arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.25937 (2026).
[3] Shen, Wangtian, et al. "EffoNAV: An effective foundation-model-based visual navigation approach in challenging environment." IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters 10.7 (2025): 6824-6831.
[4] Ye, Jinhui, et al. "StarVLA-α: Reducing complexity in vision-language-action systems." European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2026.
Response to Reviewer r458 - Part 3
W3:Ablation on action-grounded retrieval.
The action-grounded retrieval module is a key contribution, but its individual design choices are not sufficiently ablated.
Thank you for this question. We further refined the ablation experiments related to action-grounded retrieval and added the relevant results to following Table. The table shows retrieval accuracy under different combinations.
First, Dynamic Programming (DP) enhance retrieval accuracy by selecting nodes that are reachable and spatially nearby.
Second, action grounding is essential, it leverages directional cues from the instruction to disambiguate semantically similar landmarks, which DP alone cannot guarantee—matching the retrieved node to the location described in the instructions. However, action grounding in isolation may converge to locally optimal solutions for individual sub-instructions, losing sight of the global instruction goal.
GRONav unifies the two by combining semantic matching, spatial consistency, and action grounding, thereby balancing local disambiguation with global coherence and achieving the best performance. The ablation experiments and discussion for this section have been added to the appendix (page 18).
| Method | Town02 | Town03 | Town10 | Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CLIP only | 50.0 | 37.5 | 37.5 | 41.7 |
| CLIP+DP&Regulation (used in LM-Nav) | 66.7 | 58.3 | 50.0 | 58.3 |
| CLIP+action grounding | 91.7 | 83.3 | 79.2 | 84.7 |
| GRONav (ours) | 100.0 | 87.5 | 87.5 | 91.7 |
Q2: More controlled comparison of visual backbones.
Could the authors provide a more controlled comparison of visual backbones? [...] Although the appendix explores different encoders, backbone-matched comparisons would help disentangle the contributions of pretrained visual representations from the proposed architectural designs.
Thank you for your question. We believe we have made every effort to ensure a fair comparison and to rule out the possibility that the performance gains stem from a stronger visual encoder. Below we clarify this point.
GRONav and EffoNAV share the same backbone. The 33% improvement in Table 2 is therefore attributable entirely to our architectural designs, not to a stronger visual backbone. Moreover, the ablation study in Table 3 isolates architectural contributions under a fixed backbone. The "Baseline" variant in Table~3 uses the same DINOv2+EfficientNet encoder as GRONav but removes both the gating mechanism and spatial alignment. The progression from Baseline (36.1%) to +Gate (56.4%) to +Spatial Align (60.8%) to Full GRONav (89.4%) holds the backbone fixed and disentangles the contribution of each design, which is exactly the controlled comparison the reviewer suggests.
ViNT backbone swap is structurally infeasible. ViNT fuses the current and goal images by concatenating them along the channel dimension (6-channel input) before encoding, which is incompatible with the DINOv2 encoder (pretrained on 3-channel RGB). Changing this fusion mechanism would deviate from ViNT's own architecture. We therefore keep ViNT's original EfficientNet-B0 backbone, and we believe the comparison is as fair as the model designs allow.
Q3: Metric clarify.
Could the authors clarify the SPL values in Table 11? Several reported SPL values exceed the corresponding success rates, which is theoretically impossible under the standard SPL definition.
Thank you for your careful review. We would like to clarify that there is a typo in Table 11: SPL is not suitable in this paper, since the navigation models follow trajectories in the topological map. The correct metric should be Progress Rate (PR), which is used throughout this work. We believe PR better reflects the models' navigation ability even when they do not reach the final goal. We have revised this in the updated version (page 19).
Thanks for your response. I will raise my score to 3.
Response to Reviewer r458 - Part 1
W1: Novelty clarify and comparsion with existing approaches.
Thank you for this constructive comment. We agree that the methodological novelty of GRONav and its distinctions from existing approaches should be articulated more explicitly. Our contribution is not to claim that individual techniques such as visual-language matching, keyframe selection, or attention mechanisms are new in isolation. Rather, we identify decision-specific visual evidence as a central consideration in long-range LCVN and develop three complementary mechanisms to address the distinct visual evidence requirements of target retrieval, map construction, and navigation.
(1) Action-grounded retrieval. Unlike LM-Nav [4], which primarily matches language-described landmarks to graph nodes using CLIP similarity, GRONav explicitly aligns instructed action directives with motion signatures recovered from candidate graph trajectories using DPVO and LCS matching. This introduces trajectory-level evidence to disambiguate visually similar targets.
(2) Spatially grounded navigation. Unlike DynaNav [1], EffoNAV [2], and NoMaD [3], which focus on navigation efficiency, foundation-model-based visual representations, and diffusion-based control, respectively, GRONav transfers geometric priors from a frozen DepthAnythingV2 model through feature alignment and gated attention, improving spatial awareness and efficient waypoint prediction.
(3) Semantic-grounded map compression. Unlike conventional visual-change-based keyframe selection methods, such as ORB-SLAM and AKS, GRONav combines adaptive visual variation with object-level semantic entropy from SAM 2, preserving instruction-relevant landmarks even when visual changes are small.
Beyond these individual mechanisms, GRONav integrates them into a unified long-range LCVN framework. We support this principle with qualitative results (Figures 1A, 1C, 4, 5, and 6) and quantitative results (Tables 1–6). To our knowledge, no prior work studies how visual evidence should be organized and selected at each stage of the LCVN pipeline. We have clarified these distinctions further in the revised Introduction and Related Work (page 1-3).
[1] Wang, Jiahui, and Changhao Chen. "DynaNav: Dynamic Feature and Layer Selection for Efficient Visual Navigation." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 38 (2026): 81684-81711.
[2] Shen, Wangtian, et al. "EffoNAV: An effective foundation-model-based visual navigation approach in challenging environment." IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters 10.7 (2025): 6824-6831.
[3] Sridhar, Ajay, et al. "Nomad: Goal masked diffusion policies for navigation and exploration." 2024 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA). IEEE, 2024.
[4] Shah, Dhruv, Błażej Osiński, and Sergey Levine. "Lm-nav: Robotic navigation with large pre-trained models of language, vision, and action." Conference on robot learning. pmlr, 2023.