- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
WINGS addresses object removal and hole completion in 3D Gaussian Splatting scenes. Instead of generating one or more 2D inpainted reference images and fitting the 3D scene to them, it uses the pretrained TRELLIS generative model as a 3D-native prior.
Critical strengths
-
The 3D-native fomulation is genuenly useful. Generating the missing content directly in a learned 3D latent representation is well positioned to solve the inconsistent completions across views of 2D-based inpainting methods. The method is technically coherent and the human study suggests that this architectural change produces perceptually meaningful improvements.
-
The 3D-native formulation that generates the missing Gaussians conditioned directly on the retained scene context in TRELLIS’s latent space is in my opnion very clever. This avoids relying on independently inpainted 2D views and naturally promotes multi-view consistency.
-
Strong experimental breadth and component validation. The paper evaluates three benchmarks, four methods, automated and human metrics, runtime, failure cases, and detailed ablations. The attention masking, structure completion, axis alignment, and decoder adaptation each receive empirical support.
Critical weaknesses
-
The strongest generalization claim is not convincingly tested. The structure completion model is trained on samples filtered to favor geometry inferable from nearby context. Although the external benchmarks are not subject to this filtering, performance is not analyzed by geometric complexity, leaving generalization to irregular or semantically ambiguous holes unclear.
-
The gains over Inpaint360GS are modest on most automated metrics. The stronger user-study result is promising, but participant details and statistical uncertainty are limited. The evaluation also uses clean predefined masks, so robustness to realistic segmentation errors remains unclear.
-
The paper's novelty is somewhat limited. Its contribution is primarily an engineering adaptation of existing 3D latent inpainting techniques to photorealistic 3DGS scenes, rather than a fundamentally new formulation.
Questions for authors
-
Since TRELLIS already supports RePaint-style regional editing, and VoxHammer and InpaintSLat also edit structured 3D latents, could you clarify WINGS’s key technical novelty and provide a direct comparison under the same scenes and masks?
-
How does WINGS perform on irregular structures that do not satisfy the training-data curation criteria, or when the input 3D mask is imperfect? A breakdown by geometric complexity or mask quality would help establish generalization.
-
Can WINGS support controllable editing tasks (i.e. Xiao et al., “Localized Gaussian Splatting Editing with Contextual Awareness,” WACV 2025.) such as changing an object’s color or inserting a specified object? If not, is the current method limited to unconditional completion after object removal?
3 comments
Part 2/2 - Response to Reviewer NCFv
In order to provide equivalent comparison with the other inpainting methods reported in our paper, we used LaMa for inpainting the reference image provided to the TRELLIS flow models and . We finally performed decoding to 3DGS and merged with the original scene in an identical way to our WINGS pipeline. However, we were not able to obtain satisfactory results on photorealistic 360° 3D Gaussian splatting scene inpainting with VoxHammer, highlighting the challenges of adapting latent inpainting techniques to scene-level environments.
Q2: How does WINGS perform on irregular structures that do not satisfy the training-data curation criteria, or when the input 3D mask is imperfect?
We thank the reviewer for their question. As an example of irregular structure, we suggest to look at results for scenes cone_red and cone_yellow from the Inpaint360 dataset. The former's masked region lies in the corner of a beveled square structure, while the latter's spans steps of a staircase. WINGS is competitive with the strongest baselines on these two representative examples, with respectively 75% and 45.5% preference over Inpaint360GS. It is nonetheless true that the majority of existing benchmark datasets for 3D Gaussian splatting inpainting mostly involve geometrically regular underlying structures and we propose to list the construction of a more challenging benchmark as a relevant future work. We encourage the reviewer to evaluate the qualitative results for those representative examples in the electronic supplemental. Additionally, our structure completion network is robust to geometrically complex holes, as reported in Figure 12.
Our evaluation protocol considers the user-provided 3D masks as a strict geometric constraint, and are assumed to contain the entirety of the unwanted content. As creative applications progressively become more 3D-native, we decided to focus on evaluating inpainting performance against masks with no important irregularities or imperfections: however, our isolated voxel filtering mechanism described in the supplementary material (Appendix B.1, Context encoding) is able to discard floating artifacts at encoding time, improving the robustness of our method to potential 3D mask imperfections.
Q3: Can WINGS support controllable editing tasks [...] such as changing an object’s color or inserting a specified object?
WINGS is designed for reference-free object removal inpainting in 3D Gaussian splatting scenes, and does not currently support controllable editing tasks, due to the design choices of our method: (1) our structure completion network is explicitly trained to predict plausible geometric content in the masked region, and (2) our conditional latent sampling procedure promotes context consistency rather than novel appearance in generated voxels.
Extending WINGS to controllable editing tasks would require modifications to both of these components, allowing prompt-controlled geometry generation by retaining the original TRELLIS flow model and performing SLAT generation based on conditioning text or images. Our proposed scene-specific decoder adaptation mechanism could be retained to promote perceptual consistency at the boundary between existing and novel content. We consider the reviewer's comment a particularly interesting future work direction, allowing 3D-native generative models to be used for editing of photorealistic 3D Gaussian splatting scenes.
[3] Xiang J, Lv Z, Xu S, Deng Y, Wang R, Zhang B, et al. Structured 3D Latents for Scalable and Versatile 3D Generation. In: 2025 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR) [Internet]. 2025 [cited 2026 Sep 26]. p. 21469–80. Available from: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/11094803 doi:10.1109/CVPR52734.2025.02000
[9] Lugmayr A, Danelljan M, Romero A, Yu F, Timofte R, Van Gool L. RePaint: Inpainting using Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models. In: 2022 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR) [Internet]. 2022 [cited 2026 Sep 26]. p. 11451–61. Available from: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9880056 doi:10.1109/CVPR52688.2022.01117
[10] Li L, Huang Z, Feng H, Zhuang G, Chen R, Guo C, et al. VoxHammer: Training-Free Precise and Coherent 3D Editing in Native 3D Space. In. IEEE Computer Society; 2026 [cited 2026 Sep 26]. p. 1281–92. Available from: https://www.computer.org/csdl/proceedings-article/3dv/2026/731200b281/2gPtTdhIemA doi:10.1109/3DV69130.2026.00126
[11] Chung J, Lee S, Lee KM. InpaintSLat: Inpainting Structured 3D Latents via Initial Noise Optimization [Internet]. arXiv; 2026 [cited 2026 Sep 7]. Available from: http://arxiv.org/abs/2605.00664 doi:10.48550/arXiv.2605.00664
Maintain my rating of 3.
Thanks for the clear responses. I will maintain my rating of 3.
Part 1/2 - Response to Reviewer NCFv
We thank Reviewer NCFv for their constructive remarks and feedback.
Q1: Since TRELLIS already supports RePaint-style regional editing, and VoxHammer and InpaintSLat also edit structured 3D latents, could you clarify WINGS’s key technical novelty and provide a direct comparison under the same scenes and masks?
Our method performs inpainting of 3D Gaussian splatting scenes by operating in the latent space of the TRELLIS generative prior. It differs from existing 3D latent inpainting techniques such as TRELLIS's RePaint [3, 9], VoxHammer [10] and InpaintSLat [11] in several aspects:
In addition, we report in Table (j) automated perceptual metrics for the original TRELLIS RePaint-style editing and VoxHammer (we were unable to find a peer-reviewed manuscript or published code for InpaintSLat).
Table (j): Average metrics with equal-scene weighting, Ours, TRELLIS, VoxHammer
Table (j) demonstrates that TRELLIS and VoxHammer, while effective latent inpainting methods, are not competitive with existing 3D Gaussian splatting inpainting methods for object removal in photorealistic scenes. Qualitatively, we observed a strong perceptual mismatch between existing and generated Gaussians as well as unwanted geometry in the target region. Notably, TRELLIS is outperformed by all ablated components of WINGS (see Tables 3 and (c)), supporting the effectiveness of our proposed mechanisms for axis-alignment, structure completion, conditional latent sampling and scene-specific decoder adaptation.
We also note that VoxHammer required substantial adaptation of the publicly available codebase to perform inpainting of 3DGS scene editing: as the published framework requires a 3D asset and a mask mesh as input, we adapted the code to accept the same SLAT representation encoded by WINGS and associated mask. [... to be continued in Part 2/2]