- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the trade-off between reasoning accuracy and inference efficiency in large language models and proposes ORQA, a hybrid reasoning framework that combines a full-precision target model with its low-bit quantized counterpart, rather than relying on an independent small reasoner. The framework addresses three key challenges. First, Weight Infusion introduces a unified weight encoding scheme that enables lossless reconstruction of the original model weights while supporting quantized inference, reducing the memory overhead of maintaining both models. Second, Quant-ifier estimates the probability of quantization-induced reversals in the ranking of the top-two candidate tokens based on calibrated hidden-state error statistics, and accumulates this risk to determine when the full-precision model should intervene. Third, KV Transplant enables the two models to share a KV cache pool, allowing the quantized reasoner to reuse KV states computed by the full-precision model while the full-precision model recomputes and overwrites the reasoner-generated KV entries upon intervention, thereby eliminating the need for a separate reasoner cache and improving inference quality. The quantized reasoner is further improved through reasoning-oriented calibration and scale-only distillation. Experiments on AIME, GPQA-Diamond, and LiveCodeBench show that ORQA achieves up to 2.9× higher token throughput than full-precision inference, with relatively small accuracy degradation on the 32B model and no additional peak GPU memory usage in the evaluated settings, while offering a favorable accuracy–throughput trade-off compared with the evaluated hybrid reasoning baselines.
Critical strengths
S1. Practical system design. ORQA addresses a real deployment challenge in hybrid reasoning: an additional reasoner normally requires extra model weights and KV cache. Using a quantized version of the target model, together with shared weight encoding and KV storage, provides a concrete way to reduce this overhead. The paper also describes the runtime weight reconstruction and KV refresh procedures.
S2. Promising accuracy–efficiency results. The Qwen3-32B results are encouraging. On AIME, ORQA increases throughput from 18.8 to 55.1 TPS while accuracy changes from 78.3% to 75.6%. On GPQA, throughput rises from 19.2 to 49.1 TPS with almost no accuracy loss. Peak GPU memory is also lower than target-only inference in the reported setting. These results show practical potential beyond a purely conceptual proposal.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Missing comparisons with standalone quantization. The paper mainly compares ORQA with full-precision inference and hybrid systems using separate small reasoners, but not with simply running a 4-bit or 8-bit version of the same target model. Without these baselines, it is difficult to judge whether ORQA offers enough benefit in accuracy, speed, and memory to justify its additional complexity.
W2. Unclear connection between routing decisions and actual benefit. Quant-ifier decides when to invoke the full-precision model based on the predicted risk of reversing the top-two token rankings. Yet a reversal may have little effect on the generated answer. For example, if two tokens have probabilities of 0.5001 and 0.4999, a tiny change can reverse their order while leaving the sampling distribution almost unchanged. The paper does not directly show that positions with higher routing scores are the ones where full-precision intervention improves final-answer accuracy.
W3. Incomplete evaluation protocol and uncertainty reporting. The paper specifies the datasets, decoding settings, and scoring rules, but does not clearly state how many responses are sampled per question or how they are aggregated. The main results also lack standard errors or confidence intervals. These details are important for interpreting the smaller accuracy differences between methods.
W4. Limited router baselines. The paper compares Quant-ifier with entropy-based routing, but does not evaluate simpler alternatives such as top-two logit-margin routing or fixed-interval interventions. Comparing these methods under similar inference costs would help show whether Quant-ifier's more elaborate error model is needed.
W5. Missing end-to-end time-to-answer evaluation. The paper reports token throughput but not the time needed to complete each problem or the lengths of the generated reasoning traces. ORQA and the full-precision model may produce different numbers of tokens, so higher TPS does not necessarily mean faster answers. Per-question wall-clock times and output lengths would better establish the practical speedup.
Questions for authors
Q1. Inconsistent Qwen3-8B AIME operating points. Table 1 reports 63.3% AIME accuracy with an 18.4% target-LLM token ratio for Qwen3-8B ORQA, whereas the final ORQA row in Table 2 reports 66.7% accuracy with an 8.2% ratio. Could the authors clarify the experimental differences underlying these results (e.g., routing thresholds, decoding samples or settings) and how the operating points were selected?
7 comments
Response to Reviewer Htci (2/5)
(W2) Unclear connection between Quant-ifier's routing decisions and actual benefit: a top-2 reversal (e.g., 0.5001 vs. 0.4999) may barely change the sampling distribution or final-answer accuracy.
We thank the reviewer for this point. We agree that Quant-ifier estimates the risk of a reversal, not its downstream effect. We answer in two parts: the end-to-end benefit, and the reviewer's example.
1. End-to-end benefit (Table 2). In the ablation, the row "+Calibration recipes" uses the entropy-based router, and the next row "+Quant-ifier" changes only the router. Accuracy rises from 58.9% to 66.7% on AIME and from 50.3% to 52.5% on GPQA-Diamond, while the LLM ratio (the fraction of tokens generated by the target LLM) falls from 11.4% to 8.2% and from 17.3% to 13.8%. Quant-ifier thus reaches higher final-answer accuracy with 20–28% fewer target interventions.
2. The 0.5001 / 0.4999 example. The example assumes that when the quantized reasoner is nearly tied between two tokens, the target LLM is nearly tied as well, so invoking it changes little. We tested this assumption directly.
Setup. For each of Qwen3-8B and Qwen3-32B, we used 192 reasoning traces (985K and 920K tokens) with the target LLM and its 2-bit quantized reasoner. At every token, both models receive the same prefix, and we compare their sampling distributions (T = 0.6, top-p 0.95, as in our experiments) by L1 distance (0 = identical, 2 = no overlap). For scale, 0.50 / 0.50 versus 0.55 / 0.45 has an L1 distance of 0.1.
(a) When the reasoner is nearly tied, the target LLM usually is not. We take every token where the reasoner's top-2 probabilities are within 0.02 of each other (a near-tie) and look at the target LLM at the same token. The analysis results are shown in Table R28.
Table R28. Target-model sampling behavior at reasoner near-ties.
| At reasoner near-ties | Qwen3-8B | Qwen3-32B |
|---|---|---|
| Share of all tokens | 0.24% | 0.22% |
| Target LLM's probability gap between the same two tokens (median) | 0.48 | 0.52 |
| L1 distance 0.1 | 91% | 93% |
| Target LLM prefers the reasoner's second token | 48.8% | 48.6% |
Near-ties are rare, and at them the target LLM typically separates the two tokens clearly (e.g., 0.74 vs 0.26). This follows from Eq. 10: when the reasoner's margin , the target LLM's margin is determined by the quantization error , which is not small for a 2-bit reasoner. Target intervention therefore replaces a near-uniform draw between two tokens with the target LLM's distribution. The last row also shows that Quant-ifier's estimate is accurate here: it assigns (Eq. 13) at near-ties, and the target LLM indeed reverses the pair in about half of them.
(b) The reviewer's scenario is a negligible share of target interventions. We count target interventions that occur at a reasoner near-tie and change the sampling distribution by an L1 distance below 0.1. Table R29 shows that the near-ties take 0.1% to 0.22% of the total target interventions, empirically validating that the scenario is rare.
Table R29. Proportion of target interventions at reasoner near-ties with minimal sampling-distribution changes.
| Tokens routed to the target LLM | 5% | 10% | 15% | 20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-8B | 0.23% | 0.17% | 0.14% | 0.10% |
| Qwen3-32B | 0.22% | 0.13% | 0.11% | 0.08% |
In summary, Table 2 shows that Quant-ifier's routing decisions yield higher benchmark accuracy with fewer target interventions. The near-tie case raised by the reviewer is rare. When it does occur, the target LLM's sampling distribution clearly differs from the reasoner's in over 90% of cases.
Response to Reviewer Htci (3/5)
(W3) Report standard errors, inference settings for Table 1.
We report additional experimental results with standard errors across three runs in Table R4. As for the inference setting, ORQA and other hybrid reasoning baselines generate one response per question using standard autoregressive decoding. Each response is evaluated directly, without aggregation across multiple responses.
Table R4. Accuracy with standard errors.
| Method | 32B·AIME | 32B·GPQA | 32B·LiveCodeBench | 8B·AIME | 8B·GPQA | 8B·LiveCodeBench |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Target LLM only | 78.3% 1.0% | 59.6% 0.6% | 64.3% 0.8% | 66.7% 3.3% | 57.4% 0.6% | 54.5% 1.5% |
| BERT | 43.3% 5.0% | 41.4% 1.1% | 44.8% 1.5% | 26.7% 1.7% | 36.2% 1.6% | 28.6% 2.0% |
| Causal LLM | 70.0% 1.0% | 37.4% 1.3% | 38.6% 1.9% | 58.3% 3.3% | 32.7% 1.1% | 20.7% 2.4% |
| MF | 41.7% 4.4% | 38.4% 1.8% | 38.1% 1.8% | 21.1% 2.0% | 35.4% 1.3% | 22.9% 0.7% |
| SW_RANKING | 48.3% 2.9% | 42.4% 1.8% | 42.4% 2.4% | 33.3% 0.0% | 34.8% 2.8% | 27.6% 1.3% |
| R-Stitch | 66.7% 4.4% | 54.6% 0.8% | 56.2% 2.1% | 46.7% 1.0% | 39.9% 2.0% | 37.1% 1.7% |
| R2R | 70.0% 2.9% | 60.1% 2.8% | 60.0% 1.4% | 58.3% 2.5% | 47.0% 3.7% | 43.8% 3.6% |
| ORQA (Ours) | 75.6% 3.9% | 59.4% 2.6% | 62.4% 2.7% | 63.3% 3.5% | 53.5% 2.0% | 46.7% 1.2% |
The results show that ORQA's performance improvements are substantial relative to the observed standard errors, supporting the robustness of its gains.
(W4) Limited router baselines: compare Quant-ifier with routing alternatives such as top-two logit-margin routing or fixed-interval interventions.
We conduct additional experiments comparing Quant-ifier against entropy-based, top-2 logit margin, and fixed-interval routing at comparable LLM ratios. The results show that Quant-ifier consistently achieves higher accuracy than all three baselines at comparable or lower target-LLM usage
Table R15. Accuracy and LLM usage comparison of Quant-ifier and routing baselines at comparable target-token budgets.
| AIME | GPQA | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acc. | LLM Ratio | Acc. | LLM Ratio | |
| entropy | 61.7% | 9.85% | 50.5% | 27.8% |
| top-two margin | 56.67% | 9.63% | 50.0% | 28.7% |
| fixed intervention | 56.7% | 10.0% | 49.0% | 25.0% |
| Quant-ifier | 66.7% | 8.2% | 53.5% | 26.5% |
We keep the calibrated 2-bit reasoner and KV transplant fixed across all routing methods. We sweep routing thresholds to obtain comparable LLM ratios.
Quant-ifier consistently improves accuracy over all three routing baselines on both AIME and GPQA, despite using comparable or fewer target-LLM tokens. These results demonstrate that Quant-ifier provides more effective target intervention than conventional routing methods at comparable target-token budgets.
Response to Reviewer Htci (1/5)
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback, which has helped us strengthen our manuscript. We are preparing a revised version incorporating the reviewer’s valuable suggestions, and will make it available as soon as possible. In the meantime, we would like to provide our response below.
(W1) Compare accuracy, speed, and memory with standalone, 4bit & 8bit quantized models.
→ We thank the reviewer for the valuable comment.
We additionally compare ORQA against standalone 4-bit and 8-bit quantized Qwen3-32B models using GPTQ and AWQ. The results in Table R27 show that ORQA achieves substantially higher throughput and lower end-to-end latency at comparable accuracy.
Table R27. Accuracy, TPS, latency, and memory comparison of ORQA with standalone quantized models on AIME.
Compared to 4-bit GPTQ, ORQA achieves comparable accuracy (75.6% vs. 75.0%) while providing 1.56$\times$ higher throughput and 1.57$\times$ faster end-to-end inference. Compared to 8-bit AWQ, ORQA achieves 2.15$\times$ higher throughput and 2.21$\times$ faster end-to-end inference, with a 4.4 percentage-point accuracy difference.
Standalone quantization achieves lower memory consumption by reducing the precision of the entire model. In contrast, ORQA retains the full-precision target LLM and uses a 2-bit quantized counterpart to accelerate intermediate reasoning. Thus, ORQA targets a different operating point: substantially faster inference while retaining access to full-precision target-model computation, without exceeding its original memory footprint.