- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DecoGen for cross-style industrial anomaly generation when only source-style defect examples and normal images from target styles are available. The method constructs a structured anomaly prompt bank through defect-region clustering and attribute descriptions. It combines appearance and spatial tokens, attribute- and prototype-level alignment losses, prototype aggregation at inference, and mask-guided diffusion sampling to transfer defects to unseen styles. The paper evaluates generation quality and downstream anomaly detection on ZJU Leaper and MVTec AD, together with component ablations.
Critical strengths
1.The paper tackles a practical problem in industrial anomaly detection: generating defects for new product styles when no real defect samples are available. DecoGen combines structured defect attributes, prototype alignment, and mask-guided generation to transfer defects across styles. I find this design interesting because it allows the generated defects to be controlled in terms of their characteristics and locations.
2.The experiments on real target data are convincing. Table 3 evaluates the benefit of synthetic augmentation across eight unseen styles and three detectors. Table 12 further reports positive average gains in both image-level and pixel-level AUROC for every target style. Although some individual results decline, the overall improvements across different styles and detectors support the practical value of the method.
Critical weaknesses
1.The paper lacks a direct comparison with existing generators under the same zero-shot cross-style setting, and the downstream adaptation setup needs further clarification. Table 3 only compares detector performance with and without DecoGen augmentation. It is also unclear whether Tables 1 and 2 use the same source-target splits, data access conditions, and number of generated samples. The current results show that DecoGen's synthetic data is useful, but they do not clearly establish its advantage over existing generators for cross-style defect generation.
2.The claimed disentanglement of physical defect mechanisms is not directly demonstrated. The attribute and prototype prediction losses encourage semantic consistency, but this does not necessarily mean that defect attributes are independent of source textures or mask geometry. The ablations in Table 4 mainly examine whether the differences between generated and normal images align with the given defect masks. They do not directly evaluate the accuracy of physical attributes, possible contamination from source textures, or the effect on detecting real target anomalies. It therefore remains unclear how much of the reported improvement comes from the proposed disentanglement mechanism.
Questions for authors
Q1. Do all the generators in Tables 1 and 2 follow the same target-anomaly-free setting as Table 3? Could the authors clarify the source-target splits, what images and masks each method can access, where the masks come from, and how many synthetic samples are generated? It would also help to explain whether the normal reference images overlap with the final test set.
Q2. How exactly are the generated anomalies and masks used in PatchCore and WinCLIP? PatchCore normally relies on a memory bank of normal features, while WinCLIP uses text matching or normal reference features. Were their training procedures, memory banks, or anomaly scoring methods modified? Also, do Base and +Ours use the same target normal images?
Q3. Could the authors compare other generators and the ablated variants in Table 4 on real target test data under the same zero-shot setting and synthesis budget? Is there also an independent evaluation of defect attribute accuracy and source-texture contamination, without relying on the attribute aligner used during training or the image-residual scoring method?