- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CoFlow, which applies MeanFlow to joint trajectory generation for offline multi-agent decision making. It uses cross-agent attention to model coordination and finite differences to approximate directional derivatives in consistency training, reducing training costs. The model generates future observation trajectories in one or a few steps, then uses an inverse dynamics model to obtain actions. Experiments are conducted on MPE and SMAC.
Critical strengths
- The method is clearly structured.
- The experimental settings and implementation details are well described, and code is provided.
Critical weaknesses
The novelty of the paper is relatively limited.
Questions for authors
- MADiff [1] already uses cross-agent attention to model coordination. Could the authors clarify the specific architectural changes introduced by CVA compared with MADiff and the gains attributable to these changes?
- MeanFlow [2] already learns an average velocity field for one-step generation without distillation. Beyond the existing ablations, could the authors further clarify the contributions of the average-velocity objective, CVA, and finite differences? Could the authors also compare the total training costs required to reach the same task performance under matched datasets and backbones?
- During decentralized execution, each agent predicts trajectories for the entire team from its local information and executes only its own action. Different agents may predict inconsistent teammate plans. How does the method address this issue? Is there any targeted analysis or experiment?
If the authors address my concerns, I will increase my score.
References [1] MADiff: Offline Multi-agent Learning with Diffusion Models. [2] Mean Flows for One-step Generative Modeling.
Response to Reviewer TXrQ: CVA vs. MADiff Attention, Component Contributions, and Decentralized Execution
Thank you for your positive view of our method structure and implementation details, and for your openness to raising the score.
Q1. How does CVA differ from MADiff attention, and what does it gain? CVA differs from MADiff attention in three ways. MADiff applies multi-head attention to the U-Net skip features and replaces those features with the attention output. CVA makes three changes. (1) It adds the message back through a residual update h + γc, so each agent keeps its own features. (2) Its gate γ is learnable and initialized at zero. Training therefore starts from an independent per-agent backbone and brings in teammate information gradually. (3) It applies the same gated coupling at the bottleneck, so teammate information reaches every resolution of the U-Net. The retrained ablation in Figure 4 measures the gain. Full CVA beats independent per-agent generation on four MPE configurations: 107.2 vs. 61.9 on World Medium (+73%), 131.7 vs. 119.4 on Tag Expert, 132.4 vs. 120.8 on World Expert, and 110.1 vs. 99.4 on Spread Expert (OMAR-normalized scores).
Q2. What do the averaged-velocity objective, CVA, and finite differences each contribute, and what is the total training cost? Each component solves one problem: few-step generation, coordination, or training cost. Section 3 now opens with this mapping.
Q3. How does CoFlow handle inconsistent teammate plans under decentralized execution? CoFlow-D and CoFlow-C share one set of weights, so one model runs in both modes without retraining. Under decentralized execution, each agent generates a joint plan from its own observations and executes only its own block. Each plan predicts the teammates' trajectories explicitly, and CVA aligns the agent's own behavior with them. CoFlow-D matches or beats CoFlow-C on 6 configurations in Table 1, for example 23.5 vs. 1.3 on MPE World Random, 75.0 vs. 66.8 on Tag Md-Replay, and 10.4 vs. 8.1 on SMAC 3m Poor. Appendix B.3 now gives the execution details. Each agent samples its initial noise independently, and the N local predictions run as one batch. Making the local plans more consistent is a direction for future work.