- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces WanPE, a prompt enhancement model that transforms user requests into detailed, temporally structured prompts for text-to-video generation. It constructs SFT pairs by reverse-generating user requests from captions of 1.05 million real-world videos, then applies semantic-consistency GRPO to improve requirement preservation. Experiments with 4B–397B models on WanPEval, covering 5–30-second videos, report improvements in semantic fidelity and downstream video quality.
Critical strengths
-
The paper studies model scaling from 4B to 397B, showing generally stronger semantic fidelity and downstream video performance at larger scales.
-
The paper constructs a large-scale, video-grounded SFT dataset from approximately 1.05 million real-world clips, providing supervision for diverse cinematic content and both single-shot and multi-shot structures.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method novelty appears limited, as the approach largely combines existing data construction techniques, supervised fine-tuning, and GRPO. The paper should more clearly distinguish its contributions from closely related prompt enhancement methods. Moreover, this paper does not conduct a system and qualitative comparison with this method and existing PE methods.
-
The paper claims “director-level cinematic planning,” but evaluates it only indirectly through semantic fidelity and overall video preference. Separate assessments of shot organization, pacing, and audiovisual coordination are needed to establish better planning than strong rewriting baselines.
-
The paper does not analyze whether the reverse-generated requests resemble real user requests in distribution, including token length and category coverage. Also, the training requests and PE text are insufficiently analyzed, with no statistics on token-length distributions, expansion ratios, category and vocabulary distributions, or diversity in phrasing.
-
No data-scaling experiments are reported. Consequently, it is unclear how much of the dataset is necessary, whether performance saturates with substantially less data, or whether reverse construction offers better data efficiency than forward construction.
-
Although the paper includes a Gemini-based direct rewriting baseline, its inference configuration is not sufficiently documented. The complete system prompt, reasoning settings, and decoding parameters are needed to assess and reproduce this comparison.
-
The demonstrations primarily compare generation with and without WanPE. It is no wonder for me that w/o PE performs worse than w/ PE, so the demonstration is weak. Paired examples showing both the rewritten text and generated videos from direct LLM rewriting (or, Forward-target SFT) versus WanPE would make the method-specific improvements easier to inspect.
-
The training ablations are incomplete: the paper does not report forward-target SFT followed by the same SC-GRPO procedure. This would help determine whether the advantage of reverse construction persists after both models receive equivalent semantic-consistency training.
-
The two semantic evaluators (Gemini and GPT) disagree substantially about the final model’s reliability: the reported perfect-score rates are 85.5% and 7.2%. Although both evaluators support improvements from RL, this discrepancy requires explanation and human adjudication.
-
The human evaluation lacks important statistical and annotation details, especially confidence intervals and the number of judgments per pair.
Questions for authors
- Why not use Qwen as Direct rewriting Baseline?
- Does the SFT training data contain CoT?
- Will this paper release the SFT training data and RL prompts?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer VFWS (Part 2/5)
W2: Separate assessments of shot organization, pacing, and audiovisual coordination
A: We thank the reviewer VFWS for this suggestion!
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we report separate assessments on these aspects using PEBench [1], a third-party benchmark that directly evaluates enhanced prompts. We report all nine Directorial Creation (DC) criteria and their aggregate. Shot organization corresponds to Storyboard and Timing Completeness (STC), pacing to Editing and Transition Design (ETD), and audiovisual coordination to Sound Design Integration (SDI). The remaining criteria are Camera Design Specificity (CDS), Lighting and Color Specification (LCS), Narrative Development and Engagement (NDE), Core-Intent Focus (CIF), Subject and Performance Specificity (SPS), and Visual Style Specification (VSS). The results for T2V PE tasks are as follows:
| Method | STC ↑ | CDS ↑ | ETD ↑ | LCS ↑ | NDE ↑ | CIF ↑ | SDI ↑ | SPS ↑ | VSS ↑ | Overall ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RAPO | 0.00 | 1.40 | 1.80 | 2.40 | 1.40 | 14.40 | 1.00 | 3.60 | 4.20 | 0.93 |
| Prompt-A-Video-OS | 1.00 | 19.00 | 14.40 | 30.80 | 22.40 | 86.80 | 9.60 | 37.40 | 54.40 | 18.99 |
| Prompt-A-Video-Cog | 0.60 | 23.00 | 21.00 | 58.20 | 48.40 | 83.80 | 14.60 | 65.20 | 71.20 | 29.66 |
| VPO | 0.40 | 25.20 | 27.40 | 64.20 | 48.80 | 89.60 | 6.60 | 75.20 | 70.00 | 33.07 |
| SCMaPR | 6.20 | 55.20 | 41.60 | 48.60 | 61.00 | 99.20 | 13.20 | 74.80 | 70.60 | 49.18 |
| LingBot-Video-PE | 40.60 | 62.80 | 46.20 | 35.60 | 60.20 | 65.80 | 4.60 | 77.80 | 70.40 | 48.66 |
| LTX-2.5-PE | 2.40 | 76.60 | 36.40 | 66.80 | 65.40 | 94.20 | 61.20 | 82.60 | 77.40 | 57.69 |
| H3-Context-IR | 12.20 | 89.00 | 55.40 | 76.80 | 76.40 | 94.00 | 93.60 | 86.40 | 73.60 | 76.73 |
| WanPE-35B | 59.80 | 80.20 | 63.60 | 75.60 | 66.60 | 94.20 | 83.00 | 80.40 | 78.60 | 78.15 |
| WanPE-397B | 66.60 | 81.00 | 63.20 | 80.20 | 68.60 | 91.20 | 77.60 | 81.60 | 82.20 | 78.97 |
The results show that WanPE-397B attains the highest overall score. Among them, H3-Context-IR is the native PE of the commercial system MiniMax-H3, accessible only through its API, and its implementation and training details are not disclosed. We also compared WanPE with H3-Context-IR on H3-Base as the same downstream generator, where WanPE achieved higher human preference (Table 2(iii)).
[1] Shao, Yawen, et al. "Towards Unified Evaluation of Prompt Enhancers for Video Generation." arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.11736 (2026).
Response to Reviewer VFWS (Part 3/5)
W3: The paper does not analyze whether the reverse-generated requests resemble real user requests in distribution.
A: We thank the reviewer VFWS for raising this concern.
We believe that generalization across diverse categories of user inputs is a primary consideration when developing native PEs for modern commercial video generation systems. Therefore, we include stylistically diverse data in both data construction and evaluation, as detailed below.
training data construction.
SFT data. Video-grounded targets are derived from real-world videos spanning ten content categories, each captioned with a category-specific instruction (Appendix B). The few-shot demonstrations used for reconstruction are drawn from a 2K human-written request pool stratified by category, covering granularities from one-sentence intents to detailed shot-level instructions. We report statistics of and over the full SFT set below.
-
Statistics of video-grounded targets :
- Category and language: ten content categories; captions are written in Chinese (50.8%) or English (49.2%), and each is reconstructed in the language of its caption.
- Length: min 275 tokens, mean 1,683, median 1,515, max 6,809.
- Duration: median 14.0 s; ≤5 s 3.4%, 5–10 s 12.5%, 10–15 s 37.5%, 15–20 s 21.6%, 20–30 s 25.0%.
- Speech: 60.3% of targets contain speech transcribed verbatim from the source audio, covering 25 languages: en 40.6%, zh 35.7%, ja 4.5%, ru 2.9%, es 2.1%, tr 1.8%, ko 1.7%, fr 1.5%, de 1.4%, tl 1.0%, it 1.0%, ar 0.8%, pt 0.7%, id 0.5%, nl 0.5%, vi 0.5%, th 0.5%, pl 0.4%, ms 0.4%, fi 0.4%, cs 0.3%, sv 0.3%, da 0.3%, hu 0.2%, ro 0.2%.
-
Statistics of reconstructed requests :
- The four tables below show that spans a broad range of lengths and constraint types, with diversity comparable to human-written prompts.
| Token length | mean | median | max | ≤10 | ≤50 | ≤200 | ≤500 | ≤1,000 | >1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 223 | 93 | 1,817 | 2.5% | 25.8% | 64.0% | 88.9% | 96.3% | 3.7% |
| Expansion ratio (median) | all | ≤50 tok | 51–200 | 201–500 | >500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14.2× | 72× | 18× | 4.8× | 2.2× |
| Constraint type | all | ≤50 tok | 51–200 | 201–500 | >500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scene | 79.9 | 55.2 | 80.8 | 95.4 | 99.3 |
| Temporal order | 56.8 | 7.7 | 52.4 | 95.6 | 99.4 |
| Dialogue | 55.7 | 16.1 | 49.2 | 89.7 | 93.6 |
| Style | 49.6 | 22.6 | 47.7 | 64.8 | 84.6 |
| Camera | 43.9 | 7.7 | 39.9 | 63.8 | 97.3 |
| Sound | 41.3 | 6.7 | 30.4 | 69.3 | 96.6 |
| Lighting | 28.4 | 3.1 | 27.0 | 35.5 | 76.4 |
| On-screen text | 11.7 | 0.9 | 5.4 | 17.7 | 44.6 |
| Duration | 6.3 | 0.6 | 2.3 | 15.2 | 13.4 |
| Aspect ratio | 4.7 | 0.9 | 2.9 | 11.6 | 4.1 |
| # types per request (mean) | 3.8 | 1.2 | 3.4 | 5.6 | 7.1 |
| zh | en | |
|---|---|---|
| Vocabulary size (types) | 78,369 | 98,058 |
| Hapax ratio | 32% | 24% |
| Requests with a unique opening 5-gram | 53.7% | 63.2% |
| Distinct-2 / 3 / 4, token-budget-matched (reconstructed ) | 0.142 / 0.410 / 0.647 | 0.312 / 0.578 / 0.801 |
| Distinct-2 / 3 / 4, token-budget-matched (human-written prompts) | 0.161 / 0.445 / 0.646 | 0.349 / 0.632 / 0.767 |
The table above shows that the reconstructed requests are diverse in vocabulary and phrasing, with diversity broadly comparable to that of human-written prompts.
SC-GRPO data. The SC-GRPO prompts are written by human annotators. We report their statistics below.
- Token length: mean 428, median 223, max 5,597. Cumulative distribution ≤10: 0.5%, ≤50: 6.8%, ≤200: 46.3%, ≤500: 75.8%, ≤1,000: 89.5%, >1,000: 10.5%.
- Language: 36 languages. zh 48.1%, en 43.0%, ru 2.0%, ar 2.0%, fa 1.1%, fr 0.7%, hi 0.4%, bn 0.4%, es 0.4%, pt 0.3%, ko 0.2%, ja 0.2%, ur 0.2%, de 0.1%, te 0.1%, id 0.1%, uk 0.1%, vi 0.1%, it 0.1%, tr 0.05%, mk 0.03%, tn 0.02%, ms 0.02%, bg 0.02%, th 0.02%, pl 0.02%, sw 0.02%, mr 0.02%, az 0.01%, hu 0.01%, tl 0.01%, nl 0.01%, sn 0.01%, da 0.01%, yo 0.01%, kk 0.01%.
- Speech: 15.9% of prompts contain speech specified verbatim by the annotator, covering 25 languages: zh 53.7%, en 33.1%, ar 1.8%, ja 1.7%, nl 1.3%, fr 1.0%, es 1.0%, tl 0.8%, id 0.8%, de 0.7%, tr 0.5%, ms 0.5%, pt 0.4%, da 0.4%, cs 0.4%, fi 0.4%, pl 0.3%, ru 0.3%, it 0.3%, ko 0.3%, sv 0.2%, vi 0.2%, ro 0.1%, hu 0.1%, th 0.05%.
Evaluation on WanPEval.
WanPEval requests are written by human annotators to cover practical use cases of varying complexity. No selection was made with respect to request format or structure. Their statistics are:
- Token length: mean 171, median 99, min 29, max 1,061. Cumulative distribution ≤50: 10.4%, ≤200: 69.1%, ≤500: 95.6%, ≤1,000: 99.6%, >1,000: 0.4%.
- 12.4% of requests contain speech specified verbatim, in en 48.4%, zh 38.7%, ja 3.2%, fr 3.2%, tl 3.2%, de 3.2%.
- The requests are written in en 56.2%, zh 36.1%, fr 2.0%, de 1.6%, ja 1.6%, ko 1.6%, and tl 0.8%. During evaluation, each request is also provided to the experts in a translation into their preferred language.
Response to Reviewer VFWS (Part 1/5)
We thank the reviewer VFWS for the careful and constructive comments. We will try our best to answer all your questions. Please let us know if you still have further concerns, or if you are not satisfied with the current responses, so that we can further update the response ASAP.
W1: method novelty and qualitative comparison
A: We thank the reviewer VFWS for raising this concern for these.
To the best of our knowledge, we are the
firstto openly investigate how to train native prompt enhancers in modern commercial video generation systems. These systems incorporate a native PE and a video generator. When the official system APIs are called, user requestsfirst pass through the native PE and then to the video generator. However, the training methods and details of such native PEs remain largely undisclosed. We identify two core challenges in native PE design for modern DiTs, and address them through video-grounded reverse SFT and SC-GRPO. More broadly, as video DiTs continue to advance, we believe that the PE shouldevolvefrom an optional auxiliary module into anindispensable directorfor fine-grained, holistic planning.Reviewer qcA3 recognized that “the video-grounded reverse SFT design is novel and well motivated,” while Reviewer DjxV described it as “an interesting alternative for learning video-grounded cinematic planning.”
System and qualitative comparison.
We compare along two axes: (i) native PEs of modern commercial video generation systems, and (ii) previous general-purpose PE methods.
(i) Native PEs of modern commercial systems.Compare with the PE deployed in the production version of Wan3.0. To further validate the effectiveness of our native PE training approach, we report a previously completed internal evaluation. We invited 100 participants, including short-video creators, short-drama professionals, and general users, to test our system. We randomly sampled 2,400 prompts from their test inputs and compared
WanPEwith thenative PE deployed in the productionversion of Wan3.0 (2026-08-27), following the human blind-evaluation protocol in Section 2.4. We compared two settings: (i) enhancing user prompts with a locally deployed WanPE-397B and submitting them to the Wan3.0 official API with the production PE disabled; and (ii) submitting the original user prompts to the same API with the production PE enabled. WanPE performedcomparablyto the PE deployed in production, with preference scores S of 51.29% and 50.02%, respectively. This comparison demonstrates the effectiveness of our approach for training native prompt enhancers.Compare with the native PEs of MiniMax-H3 and LTX-2.5. In Section 3.3, we have compared WanPE against H3-Context-IR and LTX-2.5-PE on the same video generators, H3-Base and LTX-2.5-Base, respectively. The results in Table 2 demonstrate WanPE’s strong transferability.
For other commercial systems, the native PEs are not independently accessible.
(ii) Previous General-purpose PE methodsIn the initial version, we did not compare against excellent prior PE methods such as RAPO, VPO, Prompt-A-Video and SCMAPR because we considered such a comparison unfair to them:
Following the reviewer’s suggestion, we compare baselines on Wan3.0’s video generator with the 30-second subset of WanPEval, and on H3-Base with the 15-second subset due to its maximum generation duration, following the blind evaluation protocol in Section 2.4. Each baseline is compared with WanPE-9B (parameter is comparable to those of the trainable baseline PEs) in a separate 1v1 battle, and baselines are not compared against each other. The preference scores S are as follows:
The results show that WanPE-9B leads across all categories. We have also updated the
demo pagein the anonymous link, which directly visualize the comparison with prior methods.