- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents UC-Font, a few-shot font generation framework that accepts a glyph image, a radical-level ideographic description sequence (IDS-R), or a stroke-level sequence (IDS-S) as content input. Its Unified-Content Representer aligns the three input modalities using local and global contrastive objectives and reconstruction losses. A Temperature-Adjusted Style Aggregator uses target–reference content similarity to adjust attention over reference style features, while a Dual-Projection Fusion module supplies content and aggregated style features to a diffusion or flow-matching generator. The paper evaluates generation on held-out Chinese characters and fonts using quantitative metrics, visual comparisons, ablations, and several generator variants. It reports strong FID results and competitive image-level fidelity, particularly in the seen-font, unseen-character setting.
Critical strengths
-
The flexible content interface addresses a useful limitation of font generation systems that depend on a single source representation. Supporting glyph images, radical sequences, and stroke sequences within one framework is practically meaningful. Table 4 provides evidence that the unified representation improves performance over separately trained single-modality variants, especially for IDS inputs.
-
The evaluation examines more than one generator and includes held-out fonts and characters, module ablations, and qualitative examples. The results suggest that the framework can produce visually convincing glyphs and that TASA and DPF each contribute to the reported performance, although the magnitude and cause of the gains require further clarification.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main quantitative comparison needs clarification. Section 4.1 and Appendix D identify FLUX-based FM as the primary model, yet the SFUC entries in Table 1 match the FLUX-based DM results in Table 5, while the UFUC entries match the FLUX-based FM results in Table 6. This may be a reporting error, but the configuration behind each main result must be clear to interpret the central comparison. Tables 3 and 4 provide useful evidence that individual UC-Font components improve performance within the framework. However, comparisons with external methods using different generators and training procedures do not, on their own, establish how much of the overall advantage is attributable to UC-Font rather than the FLUX backbone.
-
The evidence supports a benefit from TASA, but does not yet establish its proposed shared-component explanation. In Eqs. (2)–(4), target–reference content similarity is summarized into an attention temperature for each target token; the matched reference-content position is not explicitly used to select a reference style token. Table 3 already shows an improvement over ordinary cross-attention, and Fig. 6 provides illustrative examples. Neither result directly demonstrates that the style attention selects the corresponding shared component. An analysis of the attended reference regions or performance separated by component overlap would make this interpretation more convincing.
Questions for authors
Which generator configuration produced the SFUC and UFUC results in Table 1? The SFUC values match FLUX-based DM in Table 5, whereas the UFUC values match FLUX-based FM in Table 6. Is this a reporting error, or were different generators intentionally used for the two settings? Please clarify the selection and correct the table or description as appropriate.
Tables 3 and 4 assess the proposed components separately. For the image-input setting, was a simple content-and-style conditioning baseline without UCR, TASA, and DPF evaluated using the same pretrained FLUX checkpoint and comparable training and sampling settings? Such a result would help determine the contribution of the complete framework beyond the backbone.
In TASA, how is a target–reference content match linked to the reference style token that receives attention, given that the content-similarity matrix appears to influence the temperature rather than directly specify style-token correspondence? Could the authors clarify whether this correspondence is learned implicitly and provide evidence, such as attention visualizations or results grouped by component overlap, for the claimed shared-component behavior?
2 comments
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your review. Our article has been updated significantly, and we hope that we addressed all of your concerns. Since the discussion period is concluding, if there is anything else you would like us to clarify, please let us know. Thank you for your time and efforts in reviewing our paper.
Thanks,
Authors
We are grateful for your recognition of the practical value of our flexible multimodal content interface, which unifies glyph images, radical and stroke sequences in one framework, as well as our comprehensive evaluations across generators, held-out fonts, characters, module ablations and qualitative visualizations. We have addressed all your questions and suggestions below and integrated all revisions and new experimental results into the updated manuscript (highlighted in blue).
Response to Weakness 1 and Question 1: Which generator was used for SFUC and UFUC in Table 1? Is the mismatch between Table 1 and Table 5/6 a reporting error?
Both the SFUC and UFUC results in Table 1 were obtained using the FLUX-based FM model. The numerical results in Table 1 are correct. During the preparation of Table 5, we inadvertently placed the FM results under “FLUX-based DM” and the DM results under “FLUX-based FM.” We will swap these two numerical result blocks. After this correction, the FLUX-based FM results in Table 5 agree with the SFUC results in Table 1.This was a table preparation error, not an intentional use of different generators for SFUC and UFUC.We used the FM variant consistently for both settings in the main comparison, while the alternative generator variants are reported in the appendix. We apologize for the confusion.
Response to Weakness 1 and Question 2: Is there a matched FLUX baseline without UCR, TASA, and DPF to isolate the backbone effect?
A matched baseline without UCR, TASA, and DPF is useful for assessing the contribution of the proposed framework beyond the FLUX backbone. We have therefore trained an image-input baseline initialized from the same pretrained FLUX checkpoint and evaluated it on UFUC using the same training and sampling protocol as UC-Font. This baseline corresponds to setting (a) in the table below. As shown in the table, UC-Font achieves the best results across all metrics, supporting the contribution of UCR, TASA, and DPF beyond the shared FLUX backbone. This experiment and the corresponding analysis are added in Appendix K.
Table. Comparison between the matched FLUX baseline and UC-Font on UFUC.
Response to Weakness 3 and Question 3: How does TASA link content matching to style attention, and is there evidence for the shared-component behavior?
We agree that the target–reference content-similarity matrix in TASA does not directly route a target token to a particular reference-style token. However, for each target query, it converts the distribution of content similarities over reference-content tokens into an entropy-based temperature. When this distribution is concentrated on a small number of reference-content tokens, its entropy is lower, yielding a lower temperature and a sharper subsequent attention distribution over the reference-style features. When the content-similarity distribution is diffuse, the higher temperature produces broader style aggregation. We added attention visualizations in Fig. 4 in the main text. In the first two illustrative examples, where the target regions have visually identifiable counterparts in the reference glyphs, TASA produces more localized attention responses than vanilla cross-attention. In examples with less evident local counterparts, the responses are broader, allowing information to be aggregated from a wider set of reference-style tokens. These visualizations illustrate how the query-dependent temperature modulates style aggregation.We also added temperature distribution in Fig. 5 in the main text. We can observe that at low ranks, the temperatures of the high-overlap group are substantially lower than those of the zero-overlap group, whose temperatures consistently cluster at higher values. This also demonstrates that TASA performs more selective style aggregation for queries with clearer content matches.