- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SLoHa captures 21.4 hours of large-object carrying using four cameras, covering 152 objects and 435 modular obstacle layouts in two rooms. It evaluates scene-conditioned motion generation and humanoid motion tracking.
Critical strengths
The dataset captures a useful interaction regime. Large-object carrying couples foot placement, body posture, object orientation, and environmental clearance. SLoHa records these adjustments around physical obstacles, including narrow passages and overhead barriers (Section 3). This coverage gives scene-conditioned models information that isolated human–object interaction data cannot provide.
The matched generation experiment demonstrates useful scene information. The authors hold CHOIS, training data, and task inputs fixed while adding scene occupancy (Section 4.1). The fraction of penetrating object vertices falls from 27% to 18%, and human vertices from 16% to 13% (Table 3). This isolates a measurable benefit of the reconstructed scenes.
Critical weaknesses
Geometric label accuracy lacks quantitative validation. Appendix A.4 provides ten paired MoCap sequences but relies on visual comparisons; smoothness and contact statistics do not measure body or object pose error. This matters because the task depends on precise relative human–object–obstacle geometry.
The scene-diversity claim conflates layouts with environments. At least some visual difference must be shown on top of the box collison. Table 1 counts 435 modular box-obstacle layouts as "scenes," although collection used only two rooms (Section 3.1; Appendix A.1). Five layout types account for the data, and 73% are straight or corner passages (Figure 4). This measures local constraint variation, not breadth of physical environments, and makes comparisons potentially misleading. The sequence-level 90/10 split does not test held-out layouts or rooms; Section 4.3 supplies only qualitative obstacle-replacement examples. IF author can justify that, i am happy to discuss possible improvement of score.
Questions for authors
Can the authors report held-out-layout or held-out-room results to support generalization beyond the 435 box arrangements?
What are the body-joint and object-pose errors before and after alignment?
Thank you for the clarifications and the additional reconstruction results. I appreciate that participants navigated real obstacles and adjusted both their body motion and the object pose. My main concern is what these demonstrations add beyond existing human–object motion data combined with scene geometry and collision constraints. The scene-conditioning ablation shows that geometry helps, but it does not isolate the benefit of collecting demonstrations around physical obstacles. The HUMOTO comparison is a useful first step, but it is qualitative and uses training sets of different sizes. The benchmark also mainly tests box-lined corridors. These layouts capture the challenge of carrying large objects through tight spaces, but the results do not show whether the model handles irregular obstacles in more cluttered rooms. Unless more concrete proof is shown, I am keeping my original score.