acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

VibeArena: Self-Evolving Executable Worlds for Embodied Agents

19 views

Abstract

We present VibeArena, which builds executable 3D worlds in code and improves construction knowledge and agent harness policies using construction and execution experience. The challenge is to reuse successful builds and repairs while preserving relations between object mechanisms and spatial context. Therefore, VibeArena links scene layout, object geometry, articulation, physical properties, and tasks in a shared world program that coordinates multiple agents. Hierarchical intermediate representations carry interaction constraints into code-based object generation, while execution feedback directs targeted revisions to structures that determine task feasibility. Validated builds provide templates, accepted repairs provide conditional rules, and their histories refine inspection and repair scheduling. Self-evolution consolidates construction experience into reusable templates, conditional rules, and scheduling policies, with rules and policies validated across scenes and refined or retired as evidence accumulates. Experiments demonstrate leading performance in object and scene generation quality, physical stability, and downstream tasks, with visual examples of diverse scenes and detailed articulated assets. VibeArena uses lessons from building and testing worlds to improve how it constructs later worlds.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Agentic 3D Scene Generation, Embodied AI, Self-Evolving Environments

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_e1jPOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a system for building executable 3D worlds for embodied agents. The authors propose VibeArena. It uses a shared world program to represent scene layouts, object geometry and articulation, physical properties, and tasks. Multiple agents work together to generate executable 3D environments. VibeArena uses hierarchical intermediate representations to pass task requirements and spatial constraints to a code-based object generation module. It then uses robot execution feedback from a simulator to identify problems. The system performs targeted repairs to object structures, scene layouts, or physical parameters. Across multiple worlds, validated builds are distilled into reusable templates. Accepted repairs are distilled into conditional rules that specify when a repair may apply. Construction histories are also used to improve inspection and repair scheduling. This creates a self-evolving construction loop. The authors evaluate VibeArena on scene generation quality, object quality, physical stability, and downstream embodied task success.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a valuable problem. A world may fail because of the interaction between an object’s mechanisms and the surrounding scene layout rather than because of the object itself. To address this issue, the paper introduces a task grounded and traceable representation of the world and develops a system for targeted diagnosis and repair. It also stores validated construction results as templates and establishes systematic procedures for validation, selection, refinement, and retirement. These procedures allow the system to extract general rules that can transfer across different scenes. This is an insightful idea. Overall, the experimental design is reasonable and provides some support for the paper’s main claims.

Critical weaknesses

The paper should further narrow and clarify its contribution at the system level. The first contribution presents code based scene construction, Articraft based articulated asset generation, simulation, and targeted repair as major contributions, but each of these capabilities has already been explored in prior work. The hierarchical intermediate representations and the mechanism for self evolution from construction experience described in the latter two contributions are closer to the paper’s central ideas. The authors should reorganize the contribution section around a clear system design principle, or explain more explicitly which capabilities VibeArena provides that existing systems cannot easily offer. This issue mainly affects the paper’s clarity and persuasiveness and does not diminish the practical value of the system itself.

A question that deserves further clarification is whether VibeArena’s system design can produce construction experience that transfers across systems. The paper summarizes successful builds and repairs as templates, conditional rules, and harness policies. However, it remains unclear whether this experience depends on ArenaProgram, realization mappings, and the particular validation pipeline, making it knowledge specific to VibeArena, or whether it can serve as an independent mechanism in other multi agent scene generation systems.

If this experience can be transferred to other systems and provide similar benefits, the paper should emphasize its generality. If it depends on VibeArena’s particular system design, the authors should explain what additional capabilities arise from this coordinated design at the system level.

Questions for authors

Please try to address my questions and concerns in the critical weakness section.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer e1jP

Thank you for recognizing the value of VibeArena!

Below, we address the weaknesses you identified.


The paper should further narrow and clarify its contribution at the system level.

We agree that the hierarchical intermediate representations and self-evolution from construction experience are the two main technical contributions. The original first point was meant to introduce the framework as a whole.

We have rewritten it around the design principle that connects its components and the capability this gives VibeArena:

  • An interaction-driven framework for executable world generation. VibeArena carries the same interaction requirements through construction, simulation, and repair. This lets VibeArena diagnose and repair failures at multiple scales, from how a single object part moves to how the entire scene supports an embodied task.

The revised contribution is highlighted in light green in §1 of the updated PDF.

Thank you for the suggestion.


A question that deserves further clarification is whether VibeArena’s system design can produce construction experience that transfers across systems. …

We agree that cross-system transfer deserves a separate test. VibeArena learns from building and testing each world and applies those lessons to later scenes. Our original experiments show this works within VibeArena. Here we test whether the same idea works in a general-purpose agent framework.

We ran GPT-6 Astra and DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash in Codex. The paper’s general-agent baselines use our direct tool-use setup. Here, Codex manages the agent loop and tool calls, so we measured the starting scores separately under Codex.

We applied VibeArena’s self-evolution design over eight rounds using 135 cases from the SceneSmith and Function-Room benchmarks. For each model, we evaluated the starting agent and the agents after rounds 4 and 8 on the same SceneEval-30 benchmark.

SceneEval-30 scores (%) at three checkpoints

Base modelStageOOR ↑OAR ↑ACC ↑COL ↓
GPT-6 AstraBefore30.662.768.120.8
Round 432.464.268.818.6
Round 834.165.869.717.2
DS-V4.1-FlashBefore27.357.963.824.1
Round 428.759.164.322.3
Round 830.260.565.121.0

Both models improved on SceneEval-30 under Codex, showing that the self-evolution design transfers across harnesses. Collision rates fell by 3.6 and 3.1 percentage points, possibly because local placement edits can resolve overlaps. VibeArena started at 2.8%, leaving less room to reduce collisions (Tab. 2), and gained more on OOR, OAR, and ACC (Tab. 13). Our ablations show the value of carrying spatial constraints from scene planning into object generation (Tab. 5).

So a generator can improve through its own work by turning the results of construction and testing into guidance for future builds.

We added a sentence at the end of the Introduction summarizing VibeArena’s self-evolution results and their relevance to other systems that build executable 3D worlds. We report the Codex experiment in §4.6 of the updated PDF.

The Codex experiment supports our self-evolution as a potentially valuable design principle for world-building agents.

Thank you for prompting us to test the design beyond VibeArena.

Reviewer_2zrfOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper describes VibeArena, a VLM system which rewrites its own prompts and other natural language context based on repeated attempts to create 3D scenes using code. The system produces three scenes which are visually higher quality than alternatives, and outperforms LLMs and other harnesses on a suite of quantitative metrics from SceneEval (WACV26).

Critical strengths

Continued improvement of prompts and LLM-usable 3D abstractions is interesting and useful. Creating and productively using new abstractions is challenging and not proven for LLMs to my knowledge.

The qualitative examples in Figure 6 seem quite strong and have objects placed reasonably throughout the room, neither overly cluttered nor empty in the middle.

Critical weaknesses

I am unable to understand the method in terms of concrete components or what they do. The paper could not be reproduced based on its description, and does not provide any code.

Descriptions such as below make no progress in defining what anything concretely is or does:

  • "The capability planner produces interaction challenges and world intent jointly." L718
  • "Realization mappings connect requirements, declared construction decisions, and executable entities"

Almost no components are defined in additional detail, only in relation to other high level natural language concepts. The comparison / differences in the related work section are also not understandable or concrete: "Compared with SimWorld Studio... VibeArena emphasizes conditional knowledge of mechanism–scene relations" L152 with no grounding of knowledge, mechanism-scene or relations.

Objectively missing is that the method does not give its prompts - these should be given as a textblock in the appendix or supplement, and are provided concretely in many similar works. I also believe the method does not state what LLM it uses, or the cost per scene.

I believe if I understood the general method I would have additional questions on soundness.

Questions for authors

What are the data representations of the variables in Sec3.1? What is their concrete function? Could you give an example execution showing what data they contain for a specific scene?

Can the method be described in terms of concrete things like "The text of the LLM session is provided to a second LLM with the prompt <Figure of full prompt>, which is stored as a .md file and used for future LLM sessions" or a similar combination of concrete terms and data would describe it?

What concrete discoveries did the system make in practice to improve its harness or skills or self-evolve? Are any able to be interpreted or described?

Could the authors provide additional, randomized, qualitative results? Does Fig3 show solely outputs from the system, or are any shown only as reference?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Critical Weaknesses

Thank you for highlighting the value of continually improving reusable 3D abstractions for LLMs and for recognizing the visual quality of our generated scenes.

Here, we first point to the code, prompt excerpts, model, and costs already documented in the submission.

We then explain the components you highlighted.

We also summarize the new explanations and examples marked in blue in the revised PDF to clarify how the components fit together.

Details already provided in the original submission

  • “does not provide any code.” The supplementary core code/CODE_EXAMPLES.md contains the ArenaProgram class and implementation excerpts for realization mappings, repair checks, rule matching, policy acceptance, and selective rebuilding.

  • “Objectively missing is that the method does not give its prompts” Appendix B (L930–978) gives prompt excerpts for planning, construction, and revision.

  • “The method does not state what LLM it uses, or the cost per scene.” Appendix D.1 (L1026–1027) specifies GPT-6 Astra with medium reasoning effort. Tabs. 10–11 report generation and evolution costs (L1178–1187, L1220–1228). At round 8, mean generation costs per scene are 0.79M tokens and 4,160 s on SceneSmith, and 0.82M tokens and 4,240 s on Function-Room (revised Tab. 16).

  • “Almost no components are defined in additional detail” Appendix A.1 explains what the world program stores. A.2 shows how we use execution results to decide what to fix. A.3 and A.4 explain what we save from successful repairs and how we test changes to the order of checks and repairs.

Method clarifications

  • “The capability planner produces interaction challenges and world intent jointly.” The Architect agent decides in one step what the embodied agent should practice in the arena and what the world must provide for that activity. It then turns those requirements into a layout plan (revised §3.1 and A.1).

  • “Realization mappings connect requirements, declared construction decisions, and executable entities” The map links a required embodied interaction to the objects and layout choices that support it. If the embodied agent cannot reach a target, the map can point to where the target was placed and how much space was left for the embodied agent to approach it (revised A.1).

  • “Compared with SimWorld Studio... ” While SimWorld Studio uses verifier feedback to add reusable tools and procedures, we use construction and execution feedback to evolve both what VibeArena builds and how it checks and repairs worlds. (revised A.3–A.4 and Tab. 11). VibeArena turns automated training-world generation into a self-improving process, using validated experience from earlier worlds to build more usable environments for embodied agents.

What we added in the revision

To make the method easier to follow, we added a table of ArenaProgram fields and data types in §3.1 and an office example in Appendix A.1 that follows a scene from the text request to the world program. Appendices B.1–B.3 add prompt excerpts and input templates for planning, construction, and revision. Appendix A.6 shows what failed in actual runs, what VibeArena changed after evolution, and what happened when it tested those changes. It also shows which rules and policies VibeArena saves for later runs. Appendix D.10 adds Fig. 8 with more views of the worlds in Fig. 3.

You can find a step-by-step explanation of the full method in our Response to Questions below.

A simple workflow of VibeArena is:

  1. Plan the world (A.1, B.1). The Architect agent specifies the actions the embodied agent should practice and the objects and conditions needed to support those actions, then turns those requirements into a scene layout. B.1 shows the prompts that produce these plans.

  2. Build the world (A.1, B.2). Tab. 1 defines the data types in ArenaProgram, and Tab. 7 shows an example. B.2 shows the prompts that use the layout to fill the program and guide object code generation.

  3. Run and repair (A.2, B.3). A.2 explains what we record when a task runs. B.3 gives prompt excerpts that use the trace and current program to propose a local edit or request a check.

  4. Learn from the past (A.3–A.6). VibeArena uses past builds and repairs to build up reusable construction knowledge and update its harness policies for when to check a scene or try a fix. Tabs. 8–10 show recorded repairs, what the system saves, and how it validates later updates.

In the main text, §3.1 covers planning and construction, §3.2 covers task execution and repair, and §3.3 explains how VibeArena learns from past worlds to improve later runs.

Fig. 8 adds views of the three worlds in Fig. 3 (Appendix D.10).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Questions for Authors

Q1

Tab. 1 in the revised PDF lists the fields and data types in ArenaProgram. Below this is an example.

  1. Natural-language input. “A private office with a desk and office chair, a shelf with books against the wall, and two guest chairs facing the desk.”

  2. Planning. The Architect agent turns the request into 3-layer structured planning records (IRs = intermediate representations).

    • Interaction Requirements specify that the embodied agent should be able to approach the cabinet and open its upper door.
    • World Intent specifies what the Arena can contain, including the requested office furniture and any other objects needed for the interaction. It also calls for space around moving parts.
    • World Structure contains the layout plan that groups and arranges those objects in the room.
  3. Construction. The construction agents use the layout plan to fill ArenaProgram, a Python dataclass saved as JSON. The cabinet’s ID lets the program refer to the same object across the scene, object, physics, and task records.

  4. What the program stores for the cabinet.

    • S records the cabinet’s position, (4.14, 3.1, 0.0) m.
    • O records upper_door_swing, the joint that lets the upper door swing.
    • Φ records physical properties such as mass, inertia, and friction. It also records a damping value of 0.2 for that joint.
    • U defines an operation that reads the joint angle.
    • T defines a task that checks whether the door starts at its neutral angle.

    The realization mappings (R) link the clearance requirement to the upper door and the layout decision that leaves room for it to swing. If the door cannot open, those links show VibeArena what to inspect.

    The build dependencies (B) tell VibeArena which models to rebuild after an edit. Moving the cabinet changes its placement in the scene, so VibeArena can reuse its 3D model. Changing the door’s shape changes an input used to build that model, so VibeArena rebuilds it.


Q2

Appendix B (inference prompts) details what each step reads and returns.

  1. The Architect agent reads the natural-language request and produces three planning records called intermediate representations (IRs). It defines the actions the embodied agent must be able to perform (Interaction Requirements) and the objects and space those actions need (World Intent). It then uses those requirements to make the layout plan in the World Structure layer, grouping objects by area and leaving room for the agent to move and use them (A.1 and B.1).

  2. The construction agents use the layout plan to write JSON for the world program and code for the objects (B.2).

  3. After simulation, the repair model reads the program and run log, then proposes an edit or asks for a check (B.3).

  4. VibeArena reruns the same task to check whether the edit fixed the problem (A.2).

  5. VibeArena saves construction knowledge as templates from successful builds and rules based on measurements from repairs that pass validation (A.3).

  6. VibeArena learns from past runs which attempts failed and which fixes worked. It uses recurring patterns to propose its own changes to the agent harness, deciding when to run a check, switch repairs, or stop retrying. It compares the new schedule with the current one on separate scenes before adopting it (A.4).

  7. Later runs use matching templates and rules and follow the check and repair schedules that passed testing (A.5).


Q3

a) VibeArena saves successful object designs as templates and uses measurements from validated repairs to write rules for placing and fixing objects. When it builds a similar scene, it uses those templates to build objects and those rules to decide where to place them or how to fix them (A.3).

b) VibeArena reads past run logs to see which checks it ran, which repairs failed, how often it retried, and which fix worked. When the same pattern repeats, it proposes running a check sooner, switching to the repair that worked, or limiting retries (A.4).

The ablation shows better scene layouts and higher task success after these updates (Tab. 5). After the harness evolved, runs using the learned policies for choosing what to inspect or fix used 6% fewer tokens and took 8% less time in matched comparisons (Tab. 13).


Q4

The original supplementary material includes three 3D scenes generated by VibeArena in GLB format (glb/city.glb, glb/cafe.glb, and glb/balcony.glb).

Fig. 8 adds views of the three worlds in Fig. 3.

The renders, robot execution, and repair views in Fig. 3 come from actual VibeArena runs.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Additional Qualitative Results

To provide additional qualitative evidence, we add Fig. 9 to Appendix D.10 of the revised PDF.

We used GPT to mimic the style of SceneEval prompts and randomly generated new room descriptions, then ran VibeArena on them. Appendix D.10 includes the full input prompts.

The figure shows that VibeArena generates detailed 3D scenes and arranges objects well. Our IRs guide scene generation by defining what the embodied agent should be able to do (Interaction Requirements), identifying the objects and conditions needed for those actions (World Intent), and specifying where the objects go and how much clearance they need (World Structure). VibeArena uses the resulting layout to guide the generation of each object.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up Before the Discussion Closes

Dear Reviewer 2zrf,

Thank you again for your careful and constructive review. As the discussion period draws to a close, we would be grateful to hear whether our responses address your concerns or whether further clarification would be helpful. We would be happy to respond promptly. If you find that the revisions address your concerns, we would appreciate your considering an updated rating.

Following your suggestions, we added concrete examples and further qualitative results. The additions are marked in blue in the revised paper. For your convenience, we summarize the main updates below.

  • Method and data representations. Table 1 lists the fields and data types in ArenaProgram, and Appendix A.1 walks through how an office request becomes a world program, including how the program records a cabinet door and its clearance requirements.
  • Reproducibility. Appendices B.1–B.3 expand the prompt excerpts and input templates for planning, construction, and repair. Our response also points to the supplementary code excerpts and the reported model and per-scene costs.
  • What VibeArena learns. Appendix A.6 shows failures from actual runs, the rules and policies VibeArena derived from them, and how it tested those updates.
  • Qualitative results. Figure 9 shows outputs for randomly generated room descriptions, with the full input prompts in Appendix D.10. We also clarified that the renders, robot execution, and repair views in Figure 3 all come from actual VibeArena runs.

Thank you again for helping us make the method and evaluation clearer.

Best regards,
The Authors

Reviewer_fEBHOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

VibeArena constructs executable 3D worlds through a shared program connecting scene layout, object geometry and articulation, physics, and tasks. A fixed embodied controller provides execution feedback for world repair. Across construction runs, the system accumulates reusable knowledge and policies for inspection and repair scheduling. This cross-world evolution is distinct from the within-world revision already present in the initial system. Experiments evaluate scene and object quality, physical stability, and simulated task success, including initial/evolved comparisons on a separate SceneEval-30 set with experience updates disabled.

Critical strengths
  1. Useful integration of construction and execution. Connecting object mechanisms, surrounding layout, and task requirements addresses failures that isolated object generation can miss. Table 4 supports the importance of execution-guided revision: removing it reduces diagnostic task success from 67.2% to 51.2%.

  2. Evidence for overall evolution gains. The evaluation includes a separate test set, five evolution runs, frozen experience during testing, and paired improvements in Table 7. Table 5 reports task-success gains of 10.4, 13.0, and 8.0 percentage points across three task families, with generation and loading failures included in the denominator. These results support the practical value of accumulated experience.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Mechanism-level attribution of evolution gains remains incomplete. The initial system already performs strongly (Table 1: OOR 51.4%, versus 38.1% for the strongest external result), while evolution provides a further improvement to 56.8%. Section 4.3 explicitly acknowledges the strong initial results, and the initial/evolved comparisons and knowledge-only/harness-only ablations usefully distinguish these contributions. My remaining concern is the attribution of the additional benefit to the particular form of conditional knowledge and its consolidation.

    In particular, the plain-summary baseline omits numeric bounds and explicit applicability conditions (D.7), whereas conditional knowledge supplies them. This changes both representation and information content. The 71.6% versus 69.6% diagnostic success comparison therefore does not isolate the value of explicit conditions over an equally informative natural-language memory. Although D.7 describes grouping trials that share a generated world, paired intervals for this comparison and the smaller consolidation gains are not reported. These limitations weaken the evidence for the distinctive experience mechanism, while leaving the overall evolution results meaningful.

  2. The controller and downstream task protocols lack sufficient implementation detail. Section 3.2 describes a planner producing operations executed through fixed motion, gripper, and simulation-step primitives. However, the controller's algorithm or model, whether its skills are scripted or learned, its observation/action interfaces, the simulator-state information available to it, and motion-planning/grasping/navigation implementations remain insufficiently specified. The evolving harness policy governs inspection and repair scheduling; it does not specify the robot's action policy.

    D.5 provides useful evaluation controls: Table 5 uses 30 requests with ten matched resets per task family and method, freezes worlds before evaluation, and counts generation/loading failures. A.2 also describes state-based inspection, controlled probes, and preservation of task objectives and safety during repair. However, the evaluated task families lack complete task specifications, robot/control configurations, numerical success/safety criteria, per-trial execution and skill-retry limits, and sufficiently documented world-export and control settings across Genesis diagnosis and Isaac Gym evaluation. These details are needed to reproduce the gains and assess how task difficulty and controller limitations affect the results. The evidence supports simulated task usability under the authors' fixed control system, whose capabilities and evaluated tasks need clearer specification.

Questions for authors
  1. D.7 states that plain summaries omit numeric bounds and explicit applicability predicates. Could you show the actual retrieved inputs? An information-matched comparison with natural-language memory retaining those bounds and applicability facts, under the same retrieval and context budgets, would help isolate the contribution of the conditional representation.

  2. What exact planner, robot controller, and skill implementations are used in Genesis and Isaac Gym? Please specify whether they are scripted, planning-based, or learned; the controller's observation/action interfaces, including any access to simulator state; and the motion/IK, grasping, and navigation implementations. Which components are shared across the two simulators?

  3. Could you provide one complete TaskSpec per evaluated task family, including the robot, reset distribution, success/safety predicates and thresholds, control frequency, execution horizon, and controller retry/timeout rules? Please also specify how articulation, collision geometry, and physical parameters are transferred to the Table 5 evaluation simulator.

  4. Could you instantiate the diagnosis and repair protocol in A.2 with one complete example showing the execution failure, competing explanations, inspection/probe evidence, accepted patch, and formal revalidation? Please show how the evidence supports a construction defect, how the allowed edit scope is enforced, and which task objectives and safety conditions remain protected.

  5. D.7 states that trials sharing a generated world are grouped for uncertainty estimation. Could you report paired intervals for the Table 4 mechanism comparisons and the Table 5 initial/evolved gains using this grouping? Please confirm whether the stated 50 × 5 diagnostic and 30 × 10 downstream trial counts apply to each evolution run, and clarify the number of independently generated worlds and aggregation across runs.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Critical Weaknesses

Thank you for recognizing the gains from execution feedback and cross-scene learning.

Below, we report paired results and describe the controller, tasks, retrieval, and repair.

The new material is highlighted in red in Appendix E of the revised PDF.


Respond to W1

My remaining concern is the attribution of the additional benefit to the particular form of conditional knowledge and its consolidation.

Table 5 in the updated PDF separates the two sources of self-evolution. Diagnostic success was 67.2% for the initial system, 69.6% with knowledge updates alone, 71.2% with harness updates alone, and 73.2% with both. To isolate the effect of rule format and assess consolidation, we added the table below (Table 20 in the updated PDF).

ComparisonSR A (%)SR B (%)ΔSR (pp)95% CI (pp)
Conditional rules vs. plain summaries71.669.6+2.0[+1.21, +2.79]
Structured rules vs. Same rules in prose71.670.8+0.8[+0.45, +1.15]
Full vs. w/o individual updates73.272.1+1.1[−0.78, +3.02]
Full vs. w/o cross-scene confirmation73.271.5+1.7[−0.38, +3.74]
Full vs. w/o retirement73.272.6+0.6[−1.21, +2.49]
SR A and SR B give the success rates of the first and second variants in each row.

Structured rules performed better than matched prose. The full consolidation setting achieved the highest diagnostic success among the consolidation variants.

The 71.6% versus 69.6% diagnostic success comparison therefore does not isolate the value of explicit conditions over an equally informative natural-language memory.

The original conditional-rule versus plain-summary comparison changed both the format and the information shown to the generator. We therefore compared structured rules with prose versions that retain the same numerical bounds and applicability facts. The conditions use the same retrieved repairs, record order, context budget, and task validation.

Information-matched comparison.

MemorySR (%)
Structured rules71.6
Same rules in prose70.8

With retrieval and validation held fixed, encoding applicability conditions as structured predicates worked better than expressing the same conditions in prose.

Although D.7 describes grouping trials that share a generated world, paired intervals for this comparison and the smaller consolidation gains are not reported.

The table above reports paired differences and 95% confidence intervals.


Additionally, Full self-evolution reduces time and token use compared with the initial system.

By round 8, the full evolved system also used 27–34% fewer tokens and took 17–26% less time per learning description than the initial system (revised Table 17).

Reusable rules guide the generator toward repairs that worked in similar scenes. The evolved harness runs relevant checks earlier, which can catch problems before the system spends more time and tokens on a flawed candidate.

Appendix E gives the retrieval example and diagnostic comparisons.


Respond to W2

We address the controller and evaluation details in Q2 and Q3 below. Q2 explains how the planner selects operations, how the fixed controller executes them, and what simulator state it uses. The harness evolves by changing when VibeArena checks and repairs worlds, while the robot controller stays fixed.

In brief, like SceneSmith (ICML 2026) and EmbodiedSmith, we evaluate generated scenes by running robot tasks in simulation. In our downstream evaluation, a shared task plan agent selects operations for each task and scene, a fixed controller executes them in Isaac Gym, and predefined goal predicates determine success.

Q3 specifies the reset conditions, success and safety criteria, time limits, and retry rules for all three downstream task families. It also explains how we transfer generated worlds to Isaac Gym and validate them before evaluation. Table 19 in Appendix E summarizes the task specifications.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Questions 1-3 for Authors

Q1

Appendix E shows all three versions. For example, a conditional record may specify:

  • Mechanism: articulated storage, revolute joint about local z.
  • Neighbor: support surface.
  • Applicability:
    • normalized distance ∈ [1.02, 1.25]
    • joint-local x-offset ∈ [−1.05, −0.77]
  • Guidance: prefer the witnessed relative placement.
  • Scope: empirical guidance; independent validation required.

The summary describes the placement repair. Matched prose keeps the record’s bounds, roles, and scope. W1 reports the matched comparison.


Q2

In Genesis, the language-model planner orders existing operation IDs. Each operation contains a validated program of fixed simulator primitives. The arm follows Cartesian waypoints with IK and joint-position control. Failed IK, failed tracking, or a newly introduced collision pair can cause rollback. The gripper takes a width command and a force limit. The evolving harness changes inspection and repair scheduling, while the robot controller stays fixed.

The downstream evaluation holds the task and scoring protocol fixed across methods. The table below gives the controller specification for the downstream task protocol.

ComponentSpecification
RobotPanda arm and parallel gripper; mobile tasks add planar base and vertical-lift joints
ObservationsObject/link poses, joint positions and velocities, target bounds, end-effector pose, contacts and collisions
Arm actionDesired joint positions obtained from Cartesian waypoint IK
Gripper actionOpening width and force limit
IKURDF-derived kinematics with bounded nonlinear least squares; acceptance requires position error ≤2.5 cm and orientation error ≤0.12 rad
GraspingDeterministic target-anchor or geometry-based grasp selection; approach, close, lift, transport and release
OpeningGrasp the handle and follow the specified revolute arc or prismatic direction; object joints are not directly commanded during task execution
Mobile motionPlanar base waypoint tracking; evaluated as simulated mobile manipulation, without claims about wheeled locomotion
LearningGeneration and high-level planning use language models; low-level skills remain fixed

Q3

Table 19 in Appendix E of the revised PDF lists the initial states, reset ranges, skill sequences, success criteria, and numerical tolerances for pick-and-place, opening and retrieval, and mobile manipulation. The trial horizons are 20, 30, and 60 seconds, respectively.

Common evaluation settings

  • The physics timestep is 0.01 s with two substeps. The controller updates joint-position commands once per simulation step.
  • Each skill has up to three attempts, including the first. A failed skill does not restart the trial. All attempts and elapsed steps count toward the same trial horizon.
  • We score task success and safety separately and record whether both criteria are met. Intended gripper–target contacts and declared support contacts are allowed. Robot self-collision, unintended robot–environment contact, and penetration above 5 mm count as safety failures.
  • Worlds and experience snapshots remain frozen during evaluation. Generation and loading failures count as unsuccessful trials in the end-to-end success rate.

World transfer to Isaac Gym. The export manifest records link identities and transforms, joint topology, axes and limits, collision geometry, mass, center of mass, inertia, friction, restitution, and whether each body is fixed or free. The Isaac Gym importer preserves joint topology and disables fixed-joint merging where link identity matters.

The import record lists any synthesized inertia, collision decomposition, material overrides, and drive settings. Before running tasks, we check link and joint counts, initial poses, joint limits, geometry bounds, and physical parameters against the exported world.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Questions 4-5 for Authors

Q4

Appendix E.4 gives a controlled Genesis example. The task was to open a cabinet, retrieve the cup inside, and place it on a table.

  1. Execution failure. The robot opened the cabinet and revealed the cup. The first failure was REACH, with an IK residual of 2.00597 at the cup’s target position. PICK and PLACE then failed their preconditions.
  2. Competing explanations and evidence. We evaluated candidate edits to the cup placement, cabinet joint settings, cabinet implementation, and cup scale. All four model-generated candidates retained the same three failures. A predefined control changed only the cup’s position, from [2.8, −0.15, 0.65] m to [0.45, −0.15, 0.65] m. The reach residual dropped to 6.46 × 10⁻⁵. This supports cup placement as a cause of the reach failure in this scene.
  3. Accepted patch and revalidation. The accepted edit changed only the cup’s placement. On rerun, all five task transitions passed, including the two that had passed before. The goal of placing the cup on the table and the original operation sequence were preserved. This run used the historical acceptance contract.

A separate offline test in Appendix E.4 shows how the current A.2 verifier enforces scope. It checks the actual program diff and permits changes only to the declared entity’s placement. The task objective, success thresholds, collision predicates, and safety conditions stay fixed. The verifier recompiles the patched world and reruns the protected tasks. It commits the patch only when the target issue is resolved, the protected checks still pass, and no new blocking issue appears. Probe outcomes are used for diagnosis and excluded from formal task-success statistics.


Q5

Paired intervals. W1 and Table 20 of the revised PDF report paired 95% confidence intervals for the diagnostic comparisons. Conditional rules improved diagnostic success over plain summaries by 2.0 percentage points (95% CI [1.21, 2.79]). With the same information in both conditions, structured rules improved success over prose by 0.8 percentage points (95% CI [0.45, 1.15]). Table 20 also gives the paired intervals for all three consolidation ablations.

Trial counts and aggregation. The diagnostic suite uses 50 tasks with five resets each, for 250 trials per variant. The downstream evaluation uses 30 requests with ten matched resets each, for 300 trials per family and condition. As described in Appendix D.7, resets that share a generated world are grouped for uncertainty estimation. We pair outcomes by run, request, task family, and reset seed. We average the paired differences within each world group, then across groups to obtain one effect per run. The five run-level effects are the inputs to the Student-t interval.

Downstream gains. The initial-to-evolved point differences from the original Table 5 (Table 6 in the revised PDF) are shown below.

Task familyEvolved − initial
Pick-and-place+10.4 pp
Opening and retrieval+13.0 pp
Mobile manipulation+8.0 pp

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response and Summary of Rebuttals

Dear Area Chair and Reviewers,

We thank the reviewers for recognizing VibeArena’s self-evolving construction loop (Reviewer e1jP), highlighting the evidence for execution-guided repair and cross-world learning (Reviewer fEBH), and noting the quality of the generated scenes (Reviewer 2zrf).

In the revised manuscript, we added

(1) a cross-harness experiment (§4.6, Table 7),

(2) a comparison of structured rules and matched prose, along with paired confidence intervals for the diagnostic results (Appendix E, Table 20),

(3) three new qualitative examples with their full prompts (Appendix D.10, Fig. 9), and

(4) more detail on the method, robot controller, and task protocols (§3.1 and Appendices A, B, and E).

Thank you for your careful reading and constructive feedback. We have posted detailed responses in the individual review threads.


For Reviewer fEBH.

(1) We clarified what the original ablations established about the contributions of construction knowledge and harness updates.

(2) We added a controlled comparison to isolate the benefit of structured rules and reported the downstream gains from self-evolution.

(3) We clarified the downstream task protocols and explained how the robot controller stays fixed as the harness evolves.


For Reviewer 2zrf.

(1) We clarified where the original submission provided code and prompt excerpts, model settings, and cost measurements.

(2) We revised the method description and added worked examples and prompt excerpts to make the workflow easier to follow.

(3) We added qualitative results showing both room layouts and object details.


For Reviewer e1jP.

(1) Following the reviewer’s suggestion, we revised the contribution statement in the Introduction to highlight how the embodied interaction requirements guide world construction, simulation, and repair.

(2) We showed that our self-evolution design also improves scene generation when applied to general-purpose agents under a different harness. This demonstrates its broader applicability to other world-building systems.


As we enter the half of the public discussion period, we would welcome any follow-up questions from reviewers. We would be happy to clarify them before the discussion closes!

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up Before the Discussion Closes

Thanks again for your insightful comments and valuable time devoted to our paper. As the author-reviewer discussion period is coming to an end, please let us know if there's any further information we can provide to facilitate the discussion process. We are happy to answer any questions or concerns you may have during the author-reviewer discussion period.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.