- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this study, fMRI representations were derived from DCAE pretrained exclusively on natural images and evaluated on downstream prediction tasks including trait prediction and brain state prediction. Experimental results demonstrated the competitive performance of the derived representations, compared with that from fMRI-specific pre-trained models.
Critical strengths
The DCAE derived representations were comprehensively evaluated across different tasks at both global level and frame level.
Critical weaknesses
Though competitive performance, the interpretability of the derived representation remains unclear, which is important for neuroimaging studies to explore the brain-wide associations with traits/behaviors.
Questions for authors
-
Regarding the data normalization, it is not clear why the FReD-State uses the coordinate-frame normalization but the FReD-Trait uses combined global and coordinate-frame normalization.
-
For the evaluation, the baselines should also include conventional functional connectivity (FC) based models (e.g., KRR, SVM), which demonstrated competitive performance compared with foundation models, as demonstrated in this study: Marraffini, Giovanni, et al. "The Variance Brain Foundation Models Forgot: Third-Order Statistics Predict Cognition Where Billion-Parameter Models Fail." arXiv preprint arXiv:2606.04010 (2026).
-
It is not clear how to interpret the derived fMRI representation. Also, how to identify the brain regions that significantly contribute to the trait or brain state prediction? This is important for neuroimaging-based brain-wide association studies.
-
For the fMRI variation captured by the principal directions of DCAE representations learned from nature images, what does high or low fraction of variance explained indicate from the perspective of neuroscience?