- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Current agent memory architectures are generally based on coarse-grained feedback focusing on an global representation during an execution. MemScope proposes that such coarse-feedback without localization of failure can make the memory updating weakly constrainted and result large revision despite current architecture only needs a small edit at where it failed. To tackle the limitation, MemScope develops a framework that consider trace, memory state and architecture code and produce constrained edit on the memory architecture. With this framework, authors found the agent with various LLM backbones improved notably with small editing rate, which demonstrated MemScope's advantages in in-place edit while keeping notable improvement compared with trace and summary-only feedback.
Critical strengths
-
Authors propose a in agent memory architecture. The paper distinguishes failure triggered by missing memory content (or experience), failed retrieval, and bad downstream reasoning based on retrieved memory. And inspecting trace, memory, and scripts in provider can allow a more targeted and well-scoped revision on the memory architecture.
-
The . The comparison among summary-only, trace-only, and trace+memory directly demonstrates the importance of diagnostic evidence in agent execution. The overall task accuracy improvement margin from 63.33% to 70.00% to 86.67% well supports the strength of inspecting trajectory as well as current memory state.
-
The to self-evolving agent. This improvement is solid and allows comprehensive evaluation of failure mode and direct ablations for in-place editing in memory architecture.
Critical weaknesses
-
from closely related precedents. The method distinction from earlier evidence-grounded architecture and harness optimization needs a stronger jusification. MemEvolve [1] already proposes trajectory-based diagnosis of memory failure mode and employ constrained memory architecture evolving. Meta-Harness [2] already introduces source code and execution trace inspection as well as targeted edits or rewrites with larger scope. Therefore, evidence-grounded diagnosis and targeted code revision are established ideas. MemScope's contribution lies specifically at dedicated memory-store inspection and local repair, which is easier to track the editing records. Honestly, these improvement are useful, but the benefit of MemScope is not supported by related prior works in comparison.
-
The epxeriments do not . The ablation only include various evidence source control but no comparison between local editing and unconstraint redesign. Therefore, it only supports richer evidence source makes the agent perform better, but not demonstrate the benefit of local edits.
-
The comparison does not . Authors uses many different backbone models for various frameworks. For example, when comparing self-evolving memory architecture, MemEvolve uses Kimi K2 but MemScope uses Kimi K2.7 Code. The improvement thus cannot solely be attributed to memory architecture. Even though DeepSeek V3.2 partially address this concern, most architectures still use heterogeneous model families and versions.
[1] Zhang, G., Ren, H., Zhan, C., Zhou, Z., Wang, J., Zhu, H., ... & Yan, S. (2025). Memevolve: Meta-evolution of agent memory systems. arXiv preprint arXiv:2512.18746.
[2] Lee, Y., Nair, R., Zhang, Q., Lee, K., Khattab, O., & Finn, C. (2026). Meta-harness: End-to-end optimization of model harnesses. arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.28052.
Questions for authors
-
What precisely distinguishes MemScope from earlier MemEvolve's trajectory-based diagnosis and Meta-harness's trace-grounded code editing? How would you describe it?
-
The ablation supports richer evidence, but does not show the benefit of localized edits. How does localized edit compare with unrestricted revision when both receive identical traces, memory access, initial status and agent budgets?
-
How would you interpret the effect of various model families and versions on the task result comparison, given most baselines use different models and also change from Kimi K2 to Kimi K2.7 Code?
Response to Reviewer GMpL
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of soundness and the clear questions.
Q1 / W1. Distinction from MemEvolve and Meta-Harness. On evidence, MemScope is close in spirit to Meta-Harness: both let an agent read raw artifacts (code and execution traces) rather than compressed feedback. MemScope applies this to a running memory system, where the Patch Agent also queries the memory store (record statistics, raw records, a replay of the retrieval decision for the failed query) to locate where a failure arises: in what was stored, in what was retrieved, or in how the retrieved content was used; MemEvolve analyses trajectories for design recommendations and does not inspect the store. The main distinctions lie in what is changed and how a change is accepted.
(1) Scope. Meta-Harness and MemEvolve search over whole programs: each step writes a new candidate (a harness; a complete memory system with its own storage). MemScope repairs the one deployed provider in place with bounded replacements: a recorded update changes a median of 4.4% of the provider's lines (14 transitions), the provider keeps its identity, and an update leaves its memory store in place.
(2) Acceptance. Meta-Harness and MemEvolve score candidates by evaluation, so every update costs benchmark executions: in the default MemEvolve round we ran, 110 of 130 task executions served only to choose among candidates (General Response G2). MemScope installs a repair after static and import checks and relies on Patch History instead: the later outcomes of each patch (recovered failures, regressed successes) are recorded during normal task execution and given to subsequent repairs, which can adjust or undo an earlier change.
Q2 / W2. Localized edits vs. unrestricted revision under identical conditions. Table 5 holds editing fixed and varies evidence. For edit scope, General Response G2 runs localized repair and MemEvolve's unrestricted regeneration under identical conditions.
Q3 / W3. Different backbones. Table 2 contains a same-backbone comparison: with DeepSeek V3.2 and Flash-Searcher, both at pass@1, MemEvolve reports 67.88% on GAIA and MemScope reaches 83.64%. Our claim rests on this comparison. The Kimi K2.7 Code row shows that MemScope works with a second backbone; it is not a controlled comparison with MemEvolve's Kimi K2 result, which is quoted as reported by its authors. We will add a comparison with both systems on the same Kimi model. Other rows are quoted with their authors' backbones, as context.