- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes AdaProteina, a noise-space adapter for property-conditioned antibody generation with a fixed backbone. The method freezes the La-Proteina denoiser and decoder and learns an adapter using a property-prediction loss and class-conditional MMD regularization. A kernel Perron-Frobenius (kPF) operator combines separately learned property spaces. Experiments examine non-specific binding, humanness, germline conditioning, structural quality, and downstream data augmentation.
Critical strengths
- Conditioning through an initial-noise adapter while freezing the base generator is a practical approach that avoids updating the full generative model.
- The ablations illustrate how property optimization can produce repetitive sequences and how MMD regularization mitigates this failure mode.
Critical weaknesses
- The baseline comparisons do not sufficiently establish the method's advantage. The principal conditional baseline shifts Gaussian noise from mean 0 to mean3 according to the class label, without establishing this as an effective conditioning strategy. Comparisons against generation followed by predictor-based filtering or direct noise optimization are missing. How does AdaProteina compare with these alternatives under matched computational budgets? Such comparisons are particularly important given the claimed efficiency advantage.
- Predictor-based improvements are not sufficiently connected to independently validated properties. Binding scores are computed using the same predictor optimized during training (Appendix A.1.1), leaving open whether gains reflect actual property improvement or predictor-specific biases. Downstream classification and EquiFold geometry provide complementary evidence but do not directly validate the generated antibodies' non-specific binding. Can the authors provide evaluation using an independent property predictor or other indepenedent measurements? For kPF composition, please also clarify why transferring between property spaces should preserve the first property and provide joint success rates demonstrating that both conditions are retained.
Questions for authors
Please see the questions included in Critical Weaknesses 1 and 2.
Reviewers please respond
Hi reviewers,
Thanks for your work so far on this paper. Please respond to the authors, even if to acknowledge their response.