- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
DomainShuttle is a method for cross-domain, subject-driven video generation. It enables the generation of videos, such as transforming real people into an anime style, converting virtual characters into tangible objects, or creating interactions between real and virtual subjects, while faithfully adhering to prompts and preserving the subject's identity.
Critical strengths
Strengths:
- The paper clearly distinguishes identity preservation from appearance replication and addresses practically relevant scenarios, including multiple subjects and maintains the structure of the body, alternating between different areas, etc.
- The in-domain and cross-domain demos on the project page are visually impressive and demonstrate the strong capabilities of DomainShuttle.
- The experimental evaluation is comprehensive, with comparisons against a broad range of leading baselines and state-of-the-art results across the reported metrics. The ablation studies are thorough and clearly establish the contribution of each module.
- The paper is well written, with a clear structure and a coherent presentation.
Critical weaknesses
Weaknesses
- Although the training paradigms differ, the following recent and closely related works should be cited and discussed to better position the proposed method:
- [1] Li W, Zhang Y, Long F, et al. ReactID: Synchronizing Realistic Actions and Identity in Personalized Video Generation[C]//International Conference on Learning Representations. 2026, 2026: 62463–62485.
- [2] Xu X, Li Y, You S, et al. Smrabooth: Subject and Motion Representation Alignment for Customized Video Generation[C]//Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. 2026: 16130–16141.
- [3] Wang W, Huang M, Tu Y, et al. Dualreal: Adaptive Joint Training for Lossless Identity-Motion Fusion in Video Customization[C]//2025 IEEE/CVF International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV). IEEE, 2025: 16565–16575.
- The DOMAIN-MOT design intuitively provides an effective way to incorporate reference images into the model through in-context conditioning. However, the paper offers limited analysis of why this architecture is particularly suitable for customization, leaving the design somewhat insufficient beyond its empirical effectiveness. While I find the design promising, I would appreciate deeper architectural insights, supported by visualizations or additional analyses that explain how it facilitates reference conditioning and identity preservation.
- The introduction presents streaming autoregression as a core contribution, whereas the method section describes only the training of a bidirectional model and does not explain any training procedure specific to streaming generation. This creates a substantial inconsistency between the claimed contributions and the technical presentation. Although the supplementary material provides some implementation details (L886–894), these are insufficient to establish streaming autoregression as a core methodological innovation. The authors should either substantiate this claim in the main paper or revise the contribution statement accordingly.
- Style control appears to rely solely on text prompts. The paper does not explore conditioning on visual style references, such as a painting that exemplifies a particular artistic style. This limits the demonstrated scope of style customization, and a discussion or evaluation of reference-based style control would strengthen the work.
Questions for authors
See the above weakness. Overall, I find this paper promising, with visually impressive results and a comprehensive experimental evaluation. If the authors adequately address my concerns and provide convincing supporting evidence, I would keep my acceptance.
4 comments
I thank the authors for their response. Their explanations have addressed my concerns, the experiments on Domain-MoT are sufficiently thorough, and the revisions to the manuscript are appropriate. I therefore maintain my recommendation to accept the paper and have adjusted my confidence score accordingly. I hope the authors will retain these revisions in the final version.
Dear Reviewer KQQk,
Thank you for your positive feedback and continued support. We appreciate your constructive suggestions, which helped us strengthen the experimental analysis and clarify the manuscript. We will retain these revisions in the final version. Thank you again for your time and thoughtful review.
Best regards,
The Authors
Since the rebuttal period is coming to an end, I would like to reiterate my positive assessment of this work. I believe the paper makes a valuable engineering contribution to the field, and the quality of the results is sufficiently impressive to warrant acceptance at ICLR. I also appreciate the authors' efforts to thoroughly address the reviewers' concerns and to demonstrate the system through compelling demos.
Although the other two reviewers have not yet responded, I am willing to raise my score to 4 to reflect my confidence in the work and my recognition of the substantial effort the authors have made during the rebuttal period.
As a researcher working on video stylization and personalized generation, I have particular confidence in the practical value and potential impact of this work. I believe the paper would be a valuable contribution to the community.
Thank you for your positive assessment and constructive suggestions. We address your four concerns below.
W1: Related work and task differences.
We have cited these works in Related Work (L142) and discussed their differences from our method in the appendix (L1384–L1392). ReactID focuses on identity preservation and action generation, while SMRABooth and DualReal jointly customize subject identity and reference motion. Our task instead emphasizes preserving subject features under flexible cross-domain transformations. To this end, we propose DomainShuttle to improve subject consistency and generation flexibility across visual domains.
W2: Architectural motivation and analysis of Domain-MoT.
The independent reference branch of Domain-MoT allows reference features to be processed separately from video features, while joint attention connects reference information to video generation. Domain-aware AdaLN further conditions reference processing on each subject's target-domain attributes. This design follows our motivation to preserve recognizable subject features while allowing domain-dependent appearance to change. To examine this motivation, we have added two ablation studies to the main paper (L503–L530).
(1) Target-domain information versus its injection mechanism. We compare Domain-aware AdaLN with a control that adds learned domain embeddings to the corresponding subject's reference features.
Adding domain embeddings improves CD-Score by 2.1%. Domain-aware AdaLN further increases it with a relative improvement of 7.4% over additive embeddings. This shows that the performance gains are mainly from Domain-aware AdaLN, rather than merely from additional information.
(2) Effect of shuffling domain attributes. We randomly shuffle domain attributes at inference to examine their role in generation.
Shuffling reduces CD-Score and Style Score by 8.3% and 7.5%, respectively, while DINO-I and CLIP-I decrease by only 0.79% and 0.59%. These results suggest that domain attributes mainly guide domain transformations, while the identity similarity remains almost unaffected by our domain-aware modeling.
W3: Clarifying the streaming autoregressive contribution.
We clarify streaming autoregression as an extension to verify reference modeling. The original manuscript already describes streaming training in L314–L320. We initialize the streaming model from the trained bidirectional checkpoint and perform an additional 5,000 steps of chunk-wise causal training, retaining Domain-MoT and STRA-RoPE. The construction of streaming cross-attention masks is described in L210–L230. Appendix A further details the reference-aware self-attention and cross-attention masks, together with KV caching for streaming inference.
Following your advice, we have revised the introduction (L94) to describe DomainShuttle as a framework for subject consistency and generation flexibility across domains, “which we further extend to streaming autoregressive generation.” We have also revised the contribution statements in L108–L117, presenting streaming generation only in the third contribution: “We further extend DomainShuttle to streaming autoregression through chunk-wise causal generation to verify our reference modeling.”
These revisions position streaming generation as an extension and validation of our reference modeling.
W4: Reference-based style customization.
We clarify that our model was not trained on a dataset for reference-image-based style transfer. Following your advice, we evaluate it on 10 cases with style reference images as visual inputs without additional training. We have added comparisons in Fig. 7 of the revised manuscript (L479–L500). DomainShuttle transfers the reference style to both subjects and backgrounds. In contrast, baselines either only transform the background style or fail to ensure that both the background and the subject adhere to the reference style. We use the main paper’s Style Score, computed using a simple text label describing the style of the reference image.
Our method achieves the highest Style Score, with a 6.02% relative improvement over baselines. Together, these results support the potential of DomainShuttle for reference-based style customization without task-specific training.