- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PRISM makes forecasts from a frozen time-series foundation model more interpretable by replacing TimesFM 2.5’s forecasting head with three decoders whose outputs sum to the prediction: a two-knot piecewise-linear trend, a gated combination of predefined daily-to-yearly Fourier components, and an autoregressive residual. The authors validate PRISM through domain examples, agreement with classical decompositions, forecasting benchmarks, and noise tests.
Overall, the results support PRISM as a useful structured forecasting interface, but do not prove that it fully represent TimesFM’s internal reasoning due to bias in training and framework design.
Critical strengths
The paper propose a practically meaningful bridge between foundation-model forecasting and structured interpretability. PRISM converts a frozen TSFM representation into an exactly additive trend, seasonal, and residual forecast without fitting parameters to each evaluation series. While limiting the average accuracy degradation relative to TimesFM, and PRISM still outperforms the evaluated post-hoc explanable forecasters on three of five dataset groups.
Critical weaknesses
-
It is unclear whether PRISM interprets information genuinely encoded by the TSFM or primarily learns a new, author-designed forecasting model on top of it. The trend and seasonal meanings are imposed through a particular synthetic-data generator, a fixed calendar-period dictionary, sparsity and overlap penalties, and a sequential training schedule. These choices introduce substantial design bias into the resulting decomposition.
-
If PRISM is intended only as an intrinsically structured forecasting framework, the paper should not use strong language such as "reading components from the model itself" and "interpreting time-series foundation models".The authors should either provide faithfulness or causal evidence, or narrow the framing to structured forecasting from pretrained TSFM features.
-
Not sure if R is interpretable as autoregressive model is hard to understand.
-
The authors do not provide comprehensive verification against common sense R, T, and S across datasets, only several selected plausibility checks. Thus, we are not sure if the proposed framework is more interpretable than others.
Questions for authors
- How stable are the decoded (T/S/R) components across decoder-training seeds, synthetic-data distributions, regularization strengths, and training orders?
- Can PRISM be extended to other TSFMs such as Chronos or Morair?
- What are the results of removing (T) or (S), analogous to the reported removal of (R)? How do (T+R), (S+R), (R)-only, and jointly trained variants perform?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer 3hv1 (2/2)
We have updated only the references to sections, tables, and line numbers to match the latest revision; the content of this response is unchanged.
[Q1] Stability of the decoded components
The decoded T, S, and R are stable across seeds, synthetic data distributions, and regularization coefficients. In contrast, the training order substantially increases their variation across runs (Appendix G.4). We retrain the decoders while varying one factor and fixing the others. The across-run standard deviation of each component's output is at most 0.044 context standard deviations for the first three factors and 0.139–0.408 for the training order. Changing the synthetic data distribution also leaves accuracy, sparsity, and output overlap nearly unchanged (Appendix G.3).
[Q2] Extension to other TSFMs
PRISM can be extended to Chronos-2 and Moirai 2.0 (Appendix E). We train PRISM on each frozen backbone in a setting similar to that described for TimesFM 2.5. On both backbones, the metrics of Sections 4.1–4.3 generally support the same claims as on TimesFM 2.5. These include PRISM's MSE relative to each model's own backbone (−4.1% on Chronos-2 and −3.9% on Moirai 2.0) and the change in MSE when R is removed (+4.3% and −0.2%).
| TimesFM 2.5 | Chronos-2 | Moirai 2.0 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Backbone MSE | 0.309 | 0.309 | 0.323 |
| PRISM MSE | 0.312 | 0.296 | 0.311 |
| vs. backbone | +0.8% | −4.1% | −3.9% |
| MSE increase without R | +1.8% | +4.3% | −0.2% |
[Q3] Component removal and decoder subsets
Removing T or S from the forecast raises MAE by 7.4% and 75.5%, respectively, compared with 3.3% for removing R (Appendix Table 16).
The decoder subsets and joint training let R absorb structure that T and S can represent. Models that train only some of the decoders, with R last, stay close to PRISM in accuracy (MAE 0.335 for T+R, 0.340 for S+R, and 0.341 for R only; PRISM 0.332). Training all three decoders jointly from random initialization increases MAE to 0.350. R's variance share is 13.2% in PRISM. It rises to 23.5% without T, 94.9% without S, and 52.8% under joint training. The T and S decoders therefore limit how much of the forecast is assigned to the unconstrained R.
Please let us know if you have any further concerns.
Sincerely,
Authors
Respectful Inquiry Before Discussion Deadline
Dear Reviewer 3hv1,
Thank you for your time and thoughtful review of our work.
As the discussion period is approaching its end, we would like to kindly follow up on our previous response. We hope that our clarifications have adequately addressed your concerns, and we are willing to engage in further discussion if needed.
Sincerely,
Authors
Response to Reviewer 3hv1 (1/2)
Dear Reviewer 3hv1,
We thank Reviewer 3hv1 for the valuable comments and suggestions. We appreciate your positive assessment of PRISM as a practical bridge between foundation-model forecasting and structured interpretability, without fitting parameters to each target series. Our responses below clarify the scope of our claims and address your questions about component validation, stability, and applicability to other backbones.
We have updated only the references to sections, tables, and line numbers to match the latest revision; the content of this response is unchanged.
[W1] Contribution of the pretrained backbone
PRISM's forecasting accuracy and decomposition depend on the pretrained backbone, not only on the designed decoders and their training (Appendix H). To separate its contribution from that of the designed heads and their training, we replace only the frozen backbone and train the same PRISM decoders on each backbone in the same way. Besides the pretrained TimesFM 2.5, we use the TimesFM 2.5 architecture trained from scratch, the same architecture with random weights, and two MLP backbones.
With the pretrained backbone, PRISM's error is closest to that of TimesFM 2.5 with its original forecasting head. Its MAE increase over this reference is 3.1%, 8.5–19.3 percentage points smaller than with the other backbones. In synthetic experiments that decompose T and S along three axes (trend, number of seasonal components, and amplitude ratio), the pretrained backbone consistently yields the highest decomposition accuracy.
[W2] Scope of the claims
PRISM adapts pretrained TSFMs for interpretable forecasting through basis decoding, and we narrowed the framing accordingly (revised in Section 1, lines 51–53, 69–70, and 74–75). The revision no longer uses the phrase "reading components from the model itself." Interpretability here refers to PRISM's own forecast components. This adaptation requires only decoder training, without backbone retraining or parameter fitting to individual evaluation series.
[W3] Role and interpretability of the residual decoder
R makes the forecast easier to interpret mainly by keeping T and S clean. The trend and seasonal decoders capture the overall structure of the series, leaving R to predict the remaining local variation. Unlike a forecasting head that outputs each horizon time point directly, R thus isolates this local variation. Where R's output is large, as with periodic fluctuations at periods outside the Fourier dictionary or predictable spikes, this narrows down what the pattern can be attributed to and supports further analysis. Figure 5 shows such a case on ILINet, where R recovers the outbreaks that T and S smooth over.
[W4] Interpretability compared with other decomposition models
PRISM is more interpretable than other decomposition models in terms of sparsity, regularity, and concurvity (Appendix F). We have added a quantitative analysis of these three criteria on the evaluation data, comparing PRISM with the decomposition models to which each criterion applies. Plots of PRISM's decomposition across the evaluation datasets and on synthetic data are included for qualitative inspection (Appendix F.4–F.6), and the decoder checkpoints we provide allow further checks on other series.
First, sparse bases make the periods behind a seasonal pattern explicit, so the forecast can be read in terms of specific daily or weekly cycles (Appendix F.1). Compared with N-BEATS-I, which also outputs its seasonal component as an explicit Fourier basis expansion, PRISM sets unnecessary coefficients to zero and explains its seasonal component with fewer bases at a similar MAE, concentrating it on a few of them (2.45 vs. 5.11 effective atoms).
Second, regular component curves are easier to read, because T and S are meant to summarize the forecast at the level of the whole trajectory (Appendix F.2). Even a component output as T or S must be followed point by point if its local fluctuations are large. PRISM keeps sample entropy low in both T and S, whereas the other models place short-interval fluctuations in T or S.
Third, low concurvity keeps each component responsible for its own part of the forecast (Appendix F.3). When a component can be approximated by the others, part of the forecast can move between components without changing their sum, which makes the split into T, S, and R ambiguous. PRISM shows the lowest correlation-based concurvity on every component pair. In addition, the variance of R projected onto the span of the T and S bases is only 5.2% of the variance of T+S, so R has only a minor influence on the component-level interpretation.