- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies how input presentation affects evidence use in multimodal document RAG. It proposes LoC, combining higher-resolution page images with OCR from query-relevant regions. Controlled experiments examine visual budgets and content refinement, while evaluations on three benchmarks show improvements over the same retriever–generator baseline.
Critical strengths
The controlled experiments hold retrieved pages and the generator fixed, providing useful evidence that input presentation matters beyond retrieval quality.
LoC improves accuracy on three benchmarks without additional training. Same-budget ablations and uncertainty estimates help substantiate its practical effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
Limited novelty and incomplete attribution. LoC combines resolution scaling, existing region scoring, and OCR. Much of the improvement comes from increased input budgets, while the specific value of query-aware OCR selection over simpler OCR augmentation remains unclear. Clear’s gain on ViDoRe-v3 is not statistically significant.
Unclear advantage over adaptive alternatives. Existing agentic approaches already support query-dependent OCR or visual inspection through cropping and zooming. Without a comparison under matched computational budgets, it is unclear what LoC’s fixed pipeline offers over these alternatives. Larger inputs also increase observed latency, while end-to-end latency and peak memory remain unmeasured.
Questions for authors
-
Agentic RAG already supports query-dependent OCR, cropping, and zooming [1–3]. Given this, what does LoC offer beyond a fixed recipe for related tools? Why should we prefer uniformly increasing page resolution and appending selected-region OCR over letting an agent inspect the evidence and decide what needs clarification? Under matched computational budgets, does LoC provide a distinct advantage, or would an agent with these tools do better?
-
*Much of the improvement comes from increased input budgets. What additional benefit comes specifically from query-aware region selection compared with generic OCR augmentation? How do you distinguish increased token capacity from changes in spatial representation? Given that Clear’s gain on ViDoRe-v3 is not statistically significant, how broadly does the evidence support this component?
-
Larger input budgets increase observed generation latency, while end-to-end latency and peak memory remain unmeasured. Once region selection and OCR overhead are included, does LoC remain competitive with simpler baselines and adaptive agents under matched computational budgets?
[1] AgenticOCR: Parsing Only What You Need for Efficient Retrieval-Augmented Generation.
[2] VRAG-RL: Empower Vision-Perception-Based RAG for Visually Rich Information Understanding via Iterative Reasoning with Reinforcement Learning.
[3] MDocRAG-RL: Empowering Multi-Modal Document RAG via Complex Visual Reasoning with Reinforcement Learning.