acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Never Lose the Thread: Collaborative Latent Reasoning for Generative Recommendation

13 views

Abstract

Generative Recommendation (GR) reformulates item recommendation as autoregressive generation over structured item identifiers. Recent studies enhance GR through collaborative alignment and latent reasoning, incorporating behavioral preference and intermediate computation into semantic ID generation. However, these methods overlook collaborative continuity throughout hierarchical generation, i.e., action supervision leaves collaborative preference underdetermined in intermediate states and autoregressive path scoring fails to fully retain collaborative preference for the resulting item ranking. To address the above issues, we first identify the collaborative continuity gap, measured by the divergence between level-wise collaborative preference and intermediate-state preference. Subsequently, we propose CoLaGR, a collaborative latent reasoning framework for generative recommendation. CoLaGR derives level-wise collaborative preference from item-level behavioral signals. Furthermore, we develop latent reasoning guided by collaborative preference, where each reasoning state is grounded by the corresponding level-wise collaborative preference. Finally, collaborative leaf calibration is introduced using our constructed collaborative memory to refine complete-item ranking after generation. Extensive experiments demonstrate that CoLaGR consistently outperforms SOTA baselines, with improved collaborative preference modeling at both intermediate-decision and complete-item levels.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Generative Recommendation, Recommender Systems, Semantic IDs, Latent Reasoning, Collaborative Filtering

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_BxazOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes CoLaGR for generative recommendation. The method projects a frozen recommender's item preferences onto each SID level and uses them to supervise additional CP states before code prediction. After generation, CoLeaf combines generation scores with collaborative memory to rerank candidates. Experiments on three Amazon datasets show improvements over the compared methods.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper examines how collaborative preferences are preserved during SID generation and provides a diagnostic measure for intermediate states.

  2. Projecting item-level preferences onto SID levels provides a straightforward way to transfer collaborative knowledge. Separate preference and action heads accommodate the different supervision targets.

  3. CoLeaf improves complete-item ranking with collaborative memory while preserving the generated candidate set.

  4. The experiments show improvements across three datasets. The ablation studies help distinguish the contributions of collaborative supervision and final reranking.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The additional CP tokens seem to offer limited benefit. Applying the same collaborative supervision directly to ordinary decoder states achieves similar results and sometimes performs better. It is unclear what the CP tokens add beyond the auxiliary supervision.

  2. This paper shows that level-wise marginals cannot determine the joint item distribution. However, autoregressive models use prefix-conditioned probabilities. This result therefore does not establish that autoregressive path scoring itself loses information.

  3. The collaborative-continuity analysis mainly uses ground-truth prefixes, whereas inference uses model-generated prefixes. Recovering more teacher preferences under correct prefixes does not establish that this advantage remains useful during actual decoding.

  4. More efficiency analysis is needed to isolate the overhead of inserting a CP token before each SID token. How are the fixed CP positions handled during beam search?

Questions for authors
  1. How do prefix-conditioned teacher targets compare with the proposed prefix-independent targets?

  2. Does the reported training cost include teacher training and preference export?

10 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Collaborative Grounding and Joint Item Scoring (Part 1/4)

Dear Reviewer Bxaz,

Thank you for recognizing our diagnostic, separate preference/action supervision and candidate-preserving calibration. We have added generated-prefix experiments, isolated CP timing and conditional-target comparisons.

W1: The additional CP tokens seem to offer limited benefit. Applying the same collaborative supervision directly to ordinary decoder states achieves similar results and sometimes performs better. It is unclear what the CP tokens add beyond the auxiliary supervision.

Response to W1: The main benefit is user-matched collaborative supervision through separate readouts; CP provides a dedicated pre-action interface. Section 4.8 / Table 4 (p. 10) changes over 99.7% of within-SID reference matches while holding architecture, action labels, objective and the reference multiset fixed. Shuffling lowers NDCG@10 by 9.5%/11.0%/5.3%, showing the value of user-reference correspondence. Validation-tuned Direct gives a complementary comparison: G improves three-seed mean NDCG@10 by 4.80%/3.07% on Industrial/Musical before CoLeaf, with some per-seed intervals spanning zero (Appendix E.2, pp. 32-33).

S2GR supervises interleaved thinking states with cluster semantics [1]; CoLaGR reconstructs the user's collaborative reference through a separate preference head. Native-State implements this grounding at existing states and is competitive, including a calibrated lead on Industrial (Tables C.8 and C.23, pp. 23 and 32). CP supplies a uniform position for this decision-aligned computation rather than making auxiliary supervision exclusive to inserted tokens.

W2: This paper shows that level-wise marginals cannot determine the joint item distribution. However, autoregressive models use prefix-conditioned probabilities. This result therefore does not establish that autoregressive path scoring itself loses information.

Response to W2: AR joint expressiveness and collaborative supervision are different questions. AR conditionals can represent joint distributions; Proposition 1 establishes that collaborative marginals alone leave item order underdetermined. We clarify this distinction in the revised manuscript and Appendix A.6 (pp. 16-17).

The complete-item evidence is empirical. Tables C.21-C.22 (p. 31) fix candidates, AR scores, the memory-score multiset and Recall@50; matched memory improves ranking and shuffling the item-memory correspondence removes the gain. MemGen-GR likewise studies complementary generative/conventional scores [2], while our control isolates item-specific transition memory on the same generated candidates. These results establish CoLeaf's ranking benefit alongside AR scores, rather than asserting that AR factorization cannot express the joint distribution.

References

[1] Guo et al. (2026). S2GR: Stepwise Semantic-Guided Reasoning in Latent Space for Generative Recommendation. KDD 2026.

[2] Ding et al. (2026). On the Memorization and Generalization of Generative Recommendation. KDD 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Preference Recovery under Generated Prefixes (Part 2/4)

W3: The collaborative-continuity analysis mainly uses ground-truth prefixes, whereas inference uses model-generated prefixes. Recovering more teacher preferences under correct prefixes does not establish that this advantage remains useful during actual decoding.

Response to W3: G's recovery advantage persists on the full beam-50 frontiers, including after earlier SID errors. We added the generated-prefix measurements to Section 4.7 / Table 3 (p. 9). G has lower L2/L3 recovery KL than Direct and Native-State on all three domains, under both own-generated prefixes and shared-prefix replay.

Across own-generated prefixes and shared-prefix replay, all 24 incorrect-prefix comparisons favor G, with every 95% interval for the KL reduction above zero. Tables 1(a)-1(b) report G's KL reductions relative to each control; positive values indicate lower recovery error for G, and brackets give 95% paired-history intervals. Own-prefix evaluation follows each model's generated branches, while shared replay holds earlier code choices fixed across models.

Table 1(a). G's KL reductions on own incorrect prefixes (higher is better; seed 2024; beam 50; extended readout fits).

Domain / levelKL reduction vs. Direct ↑KL reduction vs. Native-State ↑
Industrial L2+0.002229[0.001769,;0.002698]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.002229\enspace[0.001769,\\;0.002698]+0.006077[0.005681,;0.006482]+0.006077\enspace[0.005681,\\;0.006482]
Industrial L3+0.010239[0.009828,;0.010676]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.010239\enspace[0.009828,\\;0.010676]+0.001649[0.001267,;0.002044]+0.001649\enspace[0.001267,\\;0.002044]
Musical L2+0.019277[0.018831,;0.019702]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.019277\enspace[0.018831,\\;0.019702]+0.006272[0.005902,;0.006632]+0.006272\enspace[0.005902,\\;0.006632]
Musical L3+0.023135[0.022787,;0.023485]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.023135\enspace[0.022787,\\;0.023485]+0.001674[0.001386,;0.001988]+0.001674\enspace[0.001386,\\;0.001988]
Video Games L2+0.039965[0.039599,;0.040316]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.039965\enspace[0.039599,\\;0.040316]+0.074426[0.073767,;0.075083]+0.074426\enspace[0.073767,\\;0.075083]
Video Games L3+0.039897[0.039577,;0.040205]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.039897\enspace[0.039577,\\;0.040205]+0.083338[0.082781,;0.083887]+0.083338\enspace[0.082781,\\;0.083887]

Table 1(b). G's KL reductions on shared incorrect-prefix replay (higher is better; seed 2024; beam 50; extended readout fits).

Domain / levelKL reduction vs. Direct ↑KL reduction vs. Native-State ↑
Industrial L2+0.003013[0.002565,;0.003470]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.003013\enspace[0.002565,\\;0.003470]+0.005911[0.005515,;0.006314]+0.005911\enspace[0.005515,\\;0.006314]
Industrial L3+0.009426[0.009028,;0.009845]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.009426\enspace[0.009028,\\;0.009845]+0.001777[0.001400,;0.002160]+0.001777\enspace[0.001400,\\;0.002160]
Musical L2+0.020103[0.019665,;0.020515]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.020103\enspace[0.019665,\\;0.020515]+0.005930[0.005574,;0.006274]+0.005930\enspace[0.005574,\\;0.006274]
Musical L3+0.023063[0.022723,;0.023410]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.023063\enspace[0.022723,\\;0.023410]+0.001549[0.001271,;0.001848]+0.001549\enspace[0.001271,\\;0.001848]
Video Games L2+0.040711[0.040356,;0.041050]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.040711\enspace[0.040356,\\;0.041050]+0.071817[0.071198,;0.072440]+0.071817\enspace[0.071198,\\;0.072440]
Video Games L3+0.040430[0.040122,;0.040725]\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}+0.040430\enspace[0.040122,\\;0.040725]+0.079278[0.078773,;0.079793]+0.079278\enspace[0.078773,\\;0.079793]

Readouts fit observed-prefix training states, use validation selection with a 400-epoch cap, and are evaluated unchanged on the frozen generators' generated states; intervals use 2,000 paired-history bootstrap draws. Appendix E.1 (pp. 32-33) gives the protocol and complete prefix-group results.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reasoning Efficiency and Beam Handling (Part 3/4)

W4: More efficiency analysis is needed to isolate the overhead of inserting a CP token before each SID token. How are the fixed CP positions handled during beam search?

Response to W4: CoLaGR uses three fixed, non-verbal CP steps instead of generating a textual reasoning chain. Explicit chain-of-thought (CoT) verbalizes intermediate reasoning token by token [3], whereas CoLaGR inserts one prescribed CP position before each SID level. Each beam advances through that position without branching or adding a probability term; only the following SID choice expands the beam and contributes to its score. This fixes the intermediate-computation budget at three steps per path and avoids decoding a free-form rationale. Neither the teacher nor the preference heads is required at inference.

Comparing CP with NoCP yields 1.57%/1.83% higher training microstep time and 15.88%/15.35% higher beam-generation time on Industrial/Musical (Table 2). Measurements use synchronized RTX-5090 timing after warmup in exclusive-computation windows; both training cases include action and preference losses. Training and decoding batches are 256 and 128, respectively, with beam 50. Industrial compares trained Native-State and CP checkpoints, while Musical toggles CP on the same frozen weights as a runtime control. Appendix E.3 / Table E.3 (p. 33) gives the full timing protocol.

Table 2. Isolated CP overhead on Industrial and Musical (seed 2024; RTX 5090).

\hspace{1.051em}Domain\hspace{1.051em}\hspace{0.768em}Variant\hspace{0.768em}\hspace{0.768em}Training (ms/step)\hspace{0.768em}\hspace{0.860em}Increase\hspace{0.860em}\hspace{0.768em}Decoding (ms/1,024 histories)\hspace{0.768em}\hspace{0.860em}Increase\hspace{0.860em}
IndustrialNoCP;33.0910;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;33.0910\\;reference;457.018;\\;457.018\\;reference
IndustrialCP;33.6095;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;33.6095\\;;1.57\\;1.57\\%\\;;529.601;\\;529.601\\;;15.88\\;15.88\\%\\;
MusicalNoCP;33.1898;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;33.1898\\;reference;454.909;\\;454.909\\;reference
MusicalCP;33.7964;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;33.7964\\;;1.83\\;1.83\\%\\;;524.750;\\;524.750\\;;15.35\\;15.35\\%\\;

References

[3] Hao et al. (2025). Training Large Language Models to Reason in a Continuous Latent Space. COLM 2025.

Reviewer_Jez9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies semantic-ID generative recommendation, where the next item is produced as a sequence of discrete codes. The authors argue that collaborative preference is lost at two points along this pipeline: intermediate decoder states do not determine which items under a committed code prefix the user prefers, and accumulated path scores can misrank complete items. They call this the collaborative continuity gap and measure its first part as the divergence between a level-wise code distribution derived from a frozen SASRec teacher and a probe of the decoder state. The proposed CoLaGR inserts a learned reasoning token before each code and attaches two heads to its state: an action head trained on next-code prediction and a preference head trained toward the teacher-derived reference. The teacher is not used at inference. A second component, CoLeaf, reranks the fixed 50-item beam by fusing the generation score with an item-transition memory score. On three Amazon domains the full system exceeds twelve baselines on all metrics. A long appendix provides ablations, three-seed results, probe diagnostics with shuffle controls, and calibration controls.

Critical strengths

Thorough and transparent control experiments. The appendix includes shuffle controls for the probe analysis, a training-time correspondence shuffle, a memory-score permutation for the reranker, a placement control that moves the two heads to the native decoder states, and three-seed results (App. C). The authors also report results that cut against their narrative, such as the native-state control leading after calibration on one domain. This makes the paper auditable, since a reader can trace which component produces which part of the gain. Two findings are also useful in their own right: supervising the soft collaborative target through a separate head helps mainly where the teacher disagrees with the observed code, and a lightweight memory-based rerank of the beam improves every generator the paper tests.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The headline gain largely comes from a post-hoc rerank that no baseline receives. Tab. 1 reports NDCG@10 gains of roughly 19 to 24 percent for the full system. CoLeaf, however, is a method-agnostic reranker applied after decoding, and the paper's own Tab. C.23 shows that applying it to the plain Base generator already exceeds the best baseline's NDCG@10 in every domain. The generator-only variant CoLaGR-G exceeds the best baseline by a much smaller margin, about one to nine percent NDCG@10, at a single seed and without a significance test. The three-seed results cover only the paper's own variants. The paper also does not say whether the nine baselines that are not local adaptations were re-run on its splits and semantic-ID assets or taken from prior work, nor how they were tuned (App. B.3). In the released repository, the code reproduces the CoLaGR row from the released checkpoints and implements CoLeaf as a standalone step over exported beam candidates, but I could not find baseline code or configurations. For these reasons, the central claim that CoLaGR consistently outperforms SOTA baselines is not yet shown to be a property of the proposed generator itself. This seems addressable with a limited experiment: apply CoLeaf to the beams of the strongest baselines, and compare CoLaGR-G with the baselines over seeds.

W2. The paper's own placement control suggests that the latent-reasoning interface contributes little, leaving a modest delta over two named prior ideas. The Native-State Grounding control, which attaches the same two heads to the existing pre-action decoder states without the inserted tokens, is within a few ten-thousandths of CoLaGR-G in NDCG@10 on all three domains (Tab. C.8) and ahead after calibration on Industrial (Tab. C.23). The tokens without grounding add little over Base (Tab. 2). What remains are two mechanisms. The first is an auxiliary preference head trained toward teacher-projected code marginals. Its advantage over the shared-output design, Direct, which places the soft target at the action output in the same way as TCA4Rec, is small, and it is measured at a single seed with Direct's weight fixed rather than tuned. The second is score fusion after decoding, which is the idea behind MemGen-GR, here with a transition memory as the second score. The theoretical statements are also brief, and as far as I can tell they do not add a mechanism specific to the proposed design. Thm. 1 is the conditional mutual-information chain rule for any deterministic state, as its proof notes, and Thm. 2 characterizes a pointwise optimum that the paper itself says does not describe the trained generator. Neither result involves the inserted tokens. Prop. 1 concerns level-wise marginals, whereas beam search scores joint path probabilities. Since the title, abstract, and contribution list present the latent-reasoning interface as the contribution, I think the framing should be reconsidered. A multi-seed comparison with a tuned Direct variant would help, but would not fully remove this concern.

Questions for authors

Q1. For the nine baselines that are not local adaptations, were the numbers re-run on the paper's splits and semantic-ID assets or taken from prior work such as Hou et al. (2026)? If re-run, how were hyperparameters selected and how many seeds were used? Could you release the baseline configurations or result logs?

Q2. Could you report NDCG@10 and Recall@10 for the strongest baselines (Latte, ActionPiece, MemGen-GR) after applying the same CoLeaf rerank with a validation-selected α\alpha, as done for the control generators in Tab. C.23? Since the released CoLeaf script operates on exported beam candidates, this should be a limited-scope experiment.

Q3. Could the Direct versus CoLaGR-G comparison be reported over the three seeds of Tab. C.6 with a paired test, and with Direct's weight selected on validation rather than fixed to λpref\lambda_{\text{pref}}?

Q4. App. B.3 notes that Tab. B.2 evaluates the frozen export checkpoint, whereas the SASRec row in Tab. 1 follows the baseline protocol. Since the teacher's NDCG@10 in Tab. B.2 is far below that row, what differs between the two protocols? Separately, why does the TCA4Rec adaptation fall below the Base generator on Industrial?

11 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Baselines and Equal Calibration (Part 1/4)

Dear Reviewer Jez9,

Thank you for recognizing our transparent controls and separate readouts. We added equal-CoLeaf, three-seed baseline and tuned-Direct comparisons.

Q1: For the nine baselines that are not local adaptations, were the numbers re-run on the paper's splits and semantic-ID assets or taken from prior work such as Hou et al. (2026)? If re-run, how were hyperparameters selected and how many seeds were used? Could you release the baseline configurations or result logs?

Response to Q1: The paper's nine literature baseline rows are published results from Latte's Amazon Reviews 2023 benchmark [1]. Additional comparisons cover Latte, ActionPiece and MemGen-GR. Latte and ActionPiece follow their public implementations [1,2]; MemGen-GR applies the released adaptive fusion to Base-generator and SASRec scores [3]. All use the same splits/evaluator and validation-based selection. Industrial Latte/ActionPiece use 150 epochs and seeds 2024/2025/2026 (Appendix B.3/Table B.3).

Q2: Could you report NDCG@10 and Recall@10 for the strongest baselines (Latte, ActionPiece, MemGen-GR) after applying the same CoLeaf rerank with a validation-selected α\alpha, as done for the control generators in Tab. C.23?

Response to Q2: G leads Latte, ActionPiece and MemGen-GR before CoLeaf, and Full CoLaGR remains ahead after CoLeaf on both datasets. CoLeaf is our complete-item calibration stage, also applied here to each comparator. All comparisons use the same splits/evaluator, validation-selected weights, and each method's own candidates/scores; every history's Recall@50 stays unchanged. Table 1 reports seed 2024 with validation-selected method settings. Best values per domain/condition are bold and underlined.

Table 1. Performance before and after equal CoLeaf calibration (seed 2024).

\hspace{0.542em}Domain\hspace{0.542em}\hspace{2.493em}Generator\hspace{2.493em}Before CoLeaf NDCG@10+CoLeaf NDCG@10Before CoLeaf Recall@10+CoLeaf Recall@10
IndustrialLatte;0.024133;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.024133\\;;0.029817;\\;0.029817\\;;0.046014;\\;0.046014\\;;0.051525;\\;0.051525\\;
IndustrialActionPiece;0.023086;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.023086\\;;0.028196;\\;0.028196\\;;0.043640;\\;0.043640\\;;0.049132;\\;0.049132\\;
IndustrialMemGen-GR;0.018206;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.018206\\;;0.026917;\\;0.026917\\;;0.034540;\\;0.034540\\;;0.045876;\\;0.045876\\;
IndustrialCoLaGR-G;0.027200‾;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.027200}}\\;;0.030946‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.030946}}\\;;0.050250‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.050250}}\\;;0.053643‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.053643}}\\;
MusicalLatte;0.032519;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.032519\\;;0.037479;\\;0.037479\\;;0.060743;\\;0.060743\\;;0.065966;\\;0.065966\\;
MusicalActionPiece;0.032263;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.032263\\;;0.036971;\\;0.036971\\;;0.061718;\\;0.061718\\;;0.065757;\\;0.065757\\;
MusicalMemGen-GR;0.023112;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.023112\\;;0.035293;\\;0.035293\\;;0.044813;\\;0.044813\\;;0.061996;\\;0.061996\\;
MusicalCoLaGR-G;0.035285‾;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.035285}}\\;;0.039515‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.039515}}\\;;0.064817‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.064817}}\\;;0.069448‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.069448}}\\;

G leads Latte and ActionPiece on both metrics at all three Industrial seeds. Table 2 uses a fixed configuration across seeds and reports mean ± sample seed SD; all fixed-model paired-history intervals favor G. MemGen-GR's two-domain results, before and after CoLeaf, are included in Table 1. CoLeaf improves every tested generator.

Table 2. Generator-only performance on Industrial (seeds 2024/2025/2026).

\hspace{2.758em}Generator\hspace{2.758em}\hspace{7.043em}NDCG@10\hspace{7.043em}\hspace{7.011em}Recall@10\hspace{7.011em}
Latte;0.023889±0.000296;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.023889 \pm 0.000296\\;;0.044739±0.000366;\\;0.044739 \pm 0.000366\\;
ActionPiece;0.023154±0.000059;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.023154 \pm 0.000059\\;;0.044059±0.000381;\\;0.044059 \pm 0.000381\\;
CoLaGR-G;0.027085‾±0.000266;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.027085}} \pm 0.000266\\;;0.049786‾±0.000422;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.049786}} \pm 0.000422\\;

References

[1] Hou et al. (2026). Expressiveness Limits of Autoregressive Semantic ID Generation in Generative Recommendation.

[2] Hou et al. (2025). ActionPiece: Contextually Tokenizing Action Sequences for Generative Recommendation. ICML 2025.

[3] Ding et al. (2026). On the Memorization and Generalization of Generative Recommendation. KDD 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Validation-Tuned Direct (Part 2/4)

Q3: Could the Direct versus CoLaGR-G comparison be reported over the three seeds of Tab. C.6 with a paired test, and with Direct's weight selected on validation rather than fixed to λpref\lambda_{\mathrm{pref}}?

Response to Q3: After the complete 13-point validation search, G has higher mean NDCG@10 and Recall@10 on both datasets. NDCG@10 improves by 4.80% on Industrial and 3.07% on Musical; Recall@10 improves by 3.23% and 2.11%. Seed-2024 validation selects Direct weights 0.75 and 1, fixed thereafter for seeds 2025/2026. Direct retains 150 epochs and the original batch, beam and validation settings. Table 3 reports mean ± sample seed SD before CoLeaf; best means within each domain are bold and underlined.

Table 3. Validation-tuned Direct versus G before CoLeaf (seeds 2024/2025/2026).

\hspace{0.547em}Domain\hspace{0.547em}\hspace{2.493em}Generator\hspace{2.493em}\hspace{5.918em}NDCG@10\hspace{5.918em}\hspace{5.886em}Recall@10\hspace{5.886em}
IndustrialTuned Direct;0.025846±0.000249;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.025846 \pm 0.000249\\;;0.048230±0.000604;\\;0.048230 \pm 0.000604\\;
IndustrialCoLaGR-G;0.027085‾±0.000266;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.027085}} \pm 0.000266\\;;0.049786‾±0.000422;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.049786}} \pm 0.000422\\;
MusicalTuned Direct;0.033689±0.000170;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.033689 \pm 0.000170\\;;0.062484±0.000716;\\;0.062484 \pm 0.000716\\;
MusicalCoLaGR-G;0.034722‾±0.000505;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.034722}} \pm 0.000505\\;;0.063801‾±0.000977;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.063801}} \pm 0.000977\\;

G's point estimates are higher in all six domain-seed pairs. Paired-history 95% intervals exclude zero in 3/6 NDCG@10 comparisons and 2/6 Recall@10 comparisons; the others span zero. The exact two-sided seed sign-flip test gives p=0.25 with three pairs. These are distinct summaries: history intervals condition on fixed models, whereas seed SD describes training variation. The results support separate preference/action readouts after tuning the shared-output weight; Appendix E.2 / Table E.2 (pp. 32-33) records the grid, selected weights and three-seed summary.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Collaborative Grounding and CP Placement (Part 3/4)

W2: "The paper's own placement control suggests that the latent-reasoning interface contributes little, leaving a modest delta over two named prior ideas."

Response to W2: CoLaGR's contribution is decision-aligned collaborative grounding through separate preference/action readouts, connected to complete-item calibration. The following evidence distinguishes the supervised information, its readouts and the CP implementation.

  • User-specific supervision. Section 4.8 / Table 4 (p. 10) preserves architecture, action labels, objective and the reference multiset while changing over 99.7% of user-reference matches. Shuffling lowers NDCG@10 by 9.5%/11.0%/5.3% across the three domains: the useful information is the reference matched to the user, beyond adding an auxiliary loss.
  • Separate preference and action readouts. TCA4Rec aligns the action output with collaborative targets [4]; CoLaGR represents preference reconstruction and hard-action prediction separately. The validation-tuned Direct comparison above retains an advantage before CoLeaf. MemGen-GR combines generative and conventional scores [3], while CoLeaf uses sparse transition memory; the equal-CoLeaf comparison separates the complete framework's gain from access to reranking alone.
  • A pre-action interface. CoLaGR's CP state reconstructs the user's collaborative reference, unlike Coconut's continuous-state reasoning [5] or S2GR's cluster-semantic supervision [6]. Native-State achieves comparable generator results (Industrial NDCG@10: 0.026911 versus G's 0.027200, with a paired interval spanning zero) and leads after calibration (0.031570 versus 0.030946). Grounding therefore extends beyond inserted tokens; CP supplies a uniform pre-action interface (Tables C.8 and C.23, pp. 23 and 32).

The theory explains the supervision requirements: Theorem 1 uses the conditional mutual-information chain rule, and Theorem 2 gives the pointwise shared-output compromise between preference/action targets. Proposition 1 concerns identical collaborative marginals with different item orders, not a loss of joint expressiveness in AR factorization. AR conditionals can represent joint dependencies; the fixed-candidate memory controls establish the empirical benefit of additional complete-item evidence (Appendix A.6, pp. 16-17; Tables C.21-C.22, p. 31).

References

[3] Ding et al. (2026). On the Memorization and Generalization of Generative Recommendation. KDD 2026.

[4] Lin et al. (2026). Token-level Collaborative Alignment for LLM-based Generative Recommendation. WWW 2026.

[5] Hao et al. (2025). Training Large Language Models to Reason in a Continuous Latent Space. COLM 2025.

[6] Guo et al. (2026). S2GR: Stepwise Semantic-Guided Reasoning in Latent Space for Generative Recommendation. KDD 2026.

Reviewer_jNWCOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

CoLaGR studies how collaborative preference is represented during semantic-ID generation and used in final item ranking. It projects a frozen SASRec teacher’s item scores into level-wise references, supervises preference and hard-action readouts separately at pre-action states, and reranks a fixed generated beam using training-interaction memory. The analysis distinguishes action identity from reference recoverability and shows that level-wise marginals do not determine item order. On three Amazon Reviews 2023 domains, the full system improves NDCG@10 by 18.8–24.1% over the strongest listed baselines; component, correspondence, and multi-seed experiments examine the sources of these gains.

Critical strengths
  1. Separating preference reconstruction from hard-action prediction is a useful, experimentally supported design principle. CoLaGR-G improves all reported metrics over Base, Latent-only, and Direct across the three domains (Table 2), and the gains persist across seeds (Table C.6). Native-State Grounding obtains comparable results (Tables C.8/C.23), which makes the contribution applicable beyond the particular CP-token implementation.
  2. The controls make the empirical account convincing. Training-time within-SID reference shuffling tests user-specific supervision (Table C.9), action-conditioned probes test recovery beyond action identity (Table C.16), and fixed-beam memory-score permutations separate candidate coverage from item-specific reranking (Tables C.21–C.22). The paper also reports reversals and near-ties rather than claiming every diagnostic uniformly favors CoLaGR.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The intermediate-state evidence is limited to observed prefixes (Appendix C.1). It therefore does not establish that improved reference recovery persists after the generator makes its own earlier code decisions. Appendix A.5 acknowledges this distribution shift but does not measure it. Evaluating L2/L3 probe KL on generated prefixes, separated by correct and incorrect prefixes, would substantiate the continuity claim during inference. This limits the mechanism evidence; the reported end-to-end ranking gains remain supported.
  2. The supplied repository makes the core method inspectable and supports reproduction of the main CoLaGR row, but its README explicitly excludes the diagnostic RQs. The probe-fitting and action-conditioned evaluation scripts underlying the reference-recoverability analysis (Appendices C.1 and C.11) are therefore not included. The paper describes the probe protocol; providing these diagnostic scripts and configurations would improve reproducibility of this central supporting analysis. This is a limited artifact-completeness concern, rather than evidence against the reported results.
Questions for authors
  1. Does CoLaGR-G retain its reference-recovery advantage over Direct and Native-State Grounding at L2/L3 under generated prefixes on the three domains, including histories with an incorrect earlier prefix? Such evidence would strengthen the inference-time interpretation of collaborative continuity.
  2. Could the probe-fitting and action-conditioned evaluation scripts and configurations used in Appendices C.1 and C.11 be added to the release? This would help reproduce the reference-recoverability measurements independently.
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Generated-Prefix Recovery (Part 1/2)

Dear Reviewer jNWC,

We sincerely thank you for recognizing preference/action separation and our diagnostic controls. We have added generated-prefix recovery measurements to the revised manuscript and released the requested diagnostic scripts and configurations.

Q1: Does CoLaGR-G retain its reference-recovery advantage over Direct and Native-State Grounding at L2/L3 under generated prefixes on the three domains, including histories with an incorrect earlier prefix?

Response to Q1: Yes. G has lower L2/L3 recovery KL than Direct and Native-State on all three full beam-50 frontiers, including incorrect-prefix branches. The advantage holds on each model's own generated prefixes and under shared-prefix replay, where every model receives the same earlier code choices. Across all/incorrect branches and own/shared prefixes, all 48 pointwise paired-history intervals favor G: 12 comparisons in each of the four settings.

Table 1 gives recovery over all generated branches; Table 2 isolates branches with an incorrect earlier SID code. G denotes CoLaGR-G. Lower KL is better, and the lowest value within each own/shared comparison is bold and underlined.

Table 1. Reference recovery over all generated branches (seed 2024; beam 50; extended readout fits).

\hspace{0.163em}Domain / level\hspace{0.163em}Own: DirectOwn: Native-State\hspace{0.874em}Own: G\hspace{0.874em}Shared: DirectShared: Native-State\hspace{0.362em}Shared: G\hspace{0.362em}
Industrial L2;0.530565;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.530565\\;;0.534465;\\;0.534465\\;;0.528395‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.528395}}\\;;0.531147;\\;0.531147\\;;0.534103;\\;0.534103\\;;0.528196‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.528196}}\\;
Industrial L3;0.682249;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.682249\\;;0.673680;\\;0.673680\\;;0.672031‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.672031}}\\;;0.681382;\\;0.681382\\;;0.673749;\\;0.673749\\;;0.671972‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.671972}}\\;
Musical L2;0.545994;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.545994\\;;0.533038;\\;0.533038\\;;0.526794‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.526794}}\\;;0.546628;\\;0.546628\\;;0.532514;\\;0.532514\\;;0.526609‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.526609}}\\;
Musical L3;0.655710;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.655710\\;;0.634274;\\;0.634274\\;;0.632600‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.632600}}\\;;0.655466;\\;0.655466\\;;0.633975;\\;0.633975\\;;0.632426‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.632426}}\\;
Video Games L2;0.486679;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.486679\\;;0.521216;\\;0.521216\\;;0.446860‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.446860}}\\;;0.487244;\\;0.487244\\;;0.518462;\\;0.518462\\;;0.446688‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.446688}}\\;
Video Games L3;0.584986;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.584986\\;;0.628447;\\;0.628447\\;;0.545135‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.545135}}\\;;0.585014;\\;0.585014\\;;0.623893;\\;0.623893\\;;0.544632‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.544632}}\\;

Table 2. Reference recovery on incorrect-prefix branches (seed 2024; beam 50; extended readout fits).

\hspace{0.163em}Domain / level\hspace{0.163em}Own: DirectOwn: Native-State\hspace{0.874em}Own: G\hspace{0.874em}Shared: DirectShared: Native-State\hspace{0.362em}Shared: G\hspace{0.362em}
Industrial L2;0.530677;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.530677\\;;0.534524;\\;0.534524\\;;0.528447‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.528447}}\\;;0.531262;\\;0.531262\\;;0.534159;\\;0.534159\\;;0.528248‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.528248}}\\;
Industrial L3;0.682281;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.682281\\;;0.673692;\\;0.673692\\;;0.672043‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.672043}}\\;;0.681410;\\;0.681410\\;;0.673762;\\;0.673762\\;;0.671985‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.671985}}\\;
Musical L2;0.546136;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.546136\\;;0.533131;\\;0.533131\\;;0.526859‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.526859}}\\;;0.546775;\\;0.546775\\;;0.532602;\\;0.532602\\;;0.526672‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.526672}}\\;
Musical L3;0.655749;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.655749\\;;0.634289;\\;0.634289\\;;0.632615‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.632615}}\\;;0.655505;\\;0.655505\\;;0.633991;\\;0.633991\\;;0.632441‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.632441}}\\;
Video Games L2;0.486944;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.486944\\;;0.521405;\\;0.521405\\;;0.446979‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.446979}}\\;;0.487518;\\;0.487518\\;;0.518624;\\;0.518624\\;;0.446807‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.446807}}\\;
Video Games L3;0.585060;\rule[-1.5ex]{0pt}{1.5ex}\\;0.585060\\;;0.628501;\\;0.628501\\;;0.545163‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.545163}}\\;;0.585089;\\;0.585089\\;;0.623937;\\;0.623937\\;;0.544659‾;\\;\underline{\mathbf{0.544659}}\\;

These results show that the reference remains more recoverable from G's states during generation, including after earlier code errors. We added the main results to Section 4.7 / Table 3 (p. 9); Appendix E.1 (pp. 32-33) gives the protocol. Part 2 below reports the paired differences and the requested code.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

A Brief Follow-up

Dear Reviewer jNWC,

Thank you again for your thoughtful review and constructive suggestions. Following your requests, we added L2/L3 reference-recovery experiments under generated prefixes, including branches with earlier SID errors, and provided the diagnostic scripts and configurations for Appendices C.1 and C.11. Parts 1–2 of our response present the results and paired comparisons, and the revised manuscript incorporates the new evidence.

As the discussion period approaches its end, could you please take a moment to review these additions and let us know whether they address your concerns? We would welcome any further questions and would be happy to discuss them during the remaining time. If you find the additional evidence and materials satisfactory, we would be grateful if you would consider a higher rating.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Best regards,
The Authors

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on Our Responses and Revised Manuscript

Dear Reviewer,

We understand that you have a busy schedule and sincerely appreciate your time and effort in reviewing our work. As the discussion period is drawing to a close, we would be grateful if you could let us know whether our responses and revised manuscript have addressed your concerns. We welcome any remaining questions and would be happy to continue the discussion.

Best regards,
The Authors

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response to All Reviewers and the Area Chair

Dear Reviewers and Area Chair,

We sincerely thank you for the time and care devoted to reviewing our work and considering our responses. Your thoughtful feedback has helped us strengthen the experiments and clarify the paper. We appreciate the recognition of our design principle, transparent controls and empirical improvements, and summarize the contributions and additional evidence below.

Core Strengths of Our Work

  1. A reusable preference/action separation principle. CoLaGR reconstructs collaborative preferences separately from hard-action prediction. Reviewer jNWC recognizes this as a "useful, experimentally supported design principle" and highlights its applicability beyond the CP-token implementation through Native-State (review).

  2. Decision-aligned collaborative latent reasoning. CP provides dedicated non-verbal preference-reconstruction steps conditioned on the history and decoded prefix. Reference-shuffling and action-conditioned controls test the user-specific preference information retained beyond action identity.

  3. Reusable complete-item calibration. CoLeaf improves every tested generator while preserving its candidate set. Fixed-beam memory permutations support the value of item-specific collaborative evidence, distinguishing better ranking from broader candidate coverage.

Updates and Clarifications during Rebuttal

  1. Fair comparisons and gains over tuned Direct (Jez9). At seed 2024, the same CoLeaf protocol favors CoLaGR over Latte, ActionPiece and MemGen-GR on Industrial and Musical. With Direct's weight selected on validation, CoLaGR-G improves mean NDCG@10 by 4.8%/3.1% on Industrial/Musical across seeds 2024, 2025 and 2026 (baselines; Direct). Jez9 acknowledges that the new equal-reranking comparisons largely resolve that concern (follow-up).

  2. CP's role and recovery after prefix errors (jNWC, Bxaz, Jez9). All 24 incorrect-prefix KL comparisons favor CoLaGR-G over Direct and Native-State across three domains, using own-generated prefixes and shared replay; every pointwise 95% paired-history interval for the KL reduction is above zero. At seed 2024, CP also improves generator NDCG@10/Recall@10 over Native-State on all three datasets (Table C.8). Preference recovery and ranking gains support our collaborative latent reasoning formulation (recovery; CP comparison).

  3. CP placement and complete-SID uniqueness (Bxaz). On Musical, interleaving improves NDCG@10/Recall@10 by 2.73%/3.07% over frontloading under identical CoLeaf calibration, supporting computation aligned with successive SID decisions. The final complete-SID mappings have zero collisions on all three datasets (follow-up).

  4. Theory, target design and computational cost (Jez9, Bxaz). We clarified that marginal non-identifiability concerns the collaborative reference, while autoregressive conditionals can represent joint dependencies. We also compared global and prefix-conditioned targets, explained fixed CP handling during beam search, and separately reported CP overhead and teacher-training times (theory; overhead; targets and cost).

  5. Diagnostic materials and implementation details (jNWC, Jez9). We supplied the requested C.1/C.11 diagnostic scripts and configurations, distinguished published baseline results from new evaluations, and clarified the frozen SASRec teacher setup (diagnostic code; teacher setup).


We would be grateful if the reviewers could consider a higher rating in light of the additional evidence, and if the Area Chair could assess the revised manuscript alongside the complete discussion record. We welcome further questions and would be happy to clarify any remaining concerns. Thank you again for your time, thoughtful consideration and constructive discussion.

Best regards,
The Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.