- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
For planar-camera game world models (top-down/isometric), the paper argues that action control should be geometric rather than learned feature conditioning. ActionRoPE is a parameter-free interface that converts action-driven camera displacement into world-coordinate rotary positions, so that a static world location keeps the same positional address across frames. Building on this, Coordinate-Conditioned Noise Scheduling (CNS) exploits the resulting known/new partition to denoise first-frame-observed regions earlier than newly revealed ones. Using clips collected from 50.9 hours of gameplay, the method is trained on Wan2.2-TI2V-5B and compared against four action-injection mechanisms on motion fidelity, direction compliance, and closed-loop revisit, plus cross-backbone (1.3B–33B) and OOD-scene transfer.
Critical strengths
- A simple, parameter-free control representation. Writing displacement into RoPE avoids a separate learned action-conditioning pathway. Results across backbones support the usefulness of the interface beyond a single generator.
- A useful closed-loop evaluation. The revisit-drift protocol directly tests spatial consistency. The training-versus-sampling control for CNS (Appendix B.4) further supports the conclusion that its benefit stems from training rather than from a sampling-time change alone.
Critical weaknesses
- Action information is unequal for two baselines. Prompt and Cross-Attn discard motion magnitude, confounding the speed-following comparison. AdaLN receives continuous displacement and provides the strongest drift baseline, so its comparison remains informative.
- The full-model gain combines positional encoding with a different training recipe. The CNS ablation is useful, but a continuous-displacement baseline with the same known/new conditioning and loss treatment is missing. Such a comparison would show how much of the improvement requires ActionRoPE, rather than the accompanying region-dependent training.
Questions for authors
- Full-command baselines. Do the motion-fidelity gains persist when Prompt and Cross-Attn also receive displacement magnitude under the same backbone and training data?
- ActionRoPE vs. recipe. Since AdaLN already gets continuous displacement, can it use the same known/new mask, noise schedule, and loss weighting? Comparing it with ActionRoPE+CNS would isolate the coordinate-based positional encoding.
- Comparable revisit distances. For the out-and-back trajectories in Table 1, please report displacement at the turning point alongside final drift, to confirm the revisit advantage does not merely reflect greater generated motion.
4 comments
Follow-up Response to Reviewer FNPM
Dear Reviewer FNPM,
We sincerely appreciate the time and effort you have dedicated to reviewing our paper. As the rebuttal discussion session draws to a close, we kindly request you to review our submitted rebuttal and welcome any further questions that you might have.
Thank you once again for your valuable feedback and consideration.
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. The experiments addresses my concerns and reinforces my original positive assessment of the paper, so I will keep my positive score.
Thank you for your review
We’re glad our response helped clarify the concerns. Thank you for taking the time to discuss our work and for your constructive feedback.
Response to Reviewer FNPM
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the parameter-free design and closed-loop revisit evaluation of ActionRoPE. We address the three concerns below.
W1 & Q1. Full-command baselines
All methods receive the same source camera displacement. To preserve their original action interfaces and implementations, Prompt (Incantation) and Cross-Attn (Matrix-Game) convert it into discrete directions (Appendix C.3). We thank the reviewer for highlighting this distinction and will clarify it in the revision.
We further evaluate full-command variants preserving displacement magnitude under identical training settings:
These information-matched comparisons further demonstrate the effectiveness of world-coordinate positional encoding for accurate motion control and spatial consistency.
W2 & Q2. ActionRoPE vs. training recipe
We further apply the identical training recipe to AdaLN, including the known/new mask, CNS noise schedule, and 2× region-weighted loss, while preserving its continuous-displacement conditioning. We compare the results under the same backbone and training protocol:
The matched training recipe degrades AdaLN's revisit performance, highlighting the importance of world-coordinate positional alignment. Meanwhile, the ActionRoPE ablation keeps Mask and Loss×2 unchanged, demonstrating the complementary benefit of CNS for revisit consistency.
Q3. Comparable revisit distances
We additionally report the commanded and generated displacement at the turning point (frame 40), alongside the final residual drift, across the same evaluation trajectories in main paper.
Under identical commanded distances, ActionRoPE achieves both the closest outbound displacement to the target and the lowest final revisit drift. These results jointly demonstrate accurate motion execution and spatial consistency.